Latest / Deep Dive Ortho — Orthopaedic Surgery, AI & Digital Health Podcast. / Ankle Sprains

Transcript

Ankle Sprains · Deep Dive Ortho — Orthopaedic Surgery, AI & Digital Health Podcast.

0:00
Welcome to The Deep Dive, the show where we cut
0:02
through the noise, unpack complex medical topics,
0:05
and pull out the crucial insights that can genuinely
0:07
elevate your clinical practice. Today, we're
0:10
plunging into a subject that, well, at first
0:11
glance, seems incredibly straightforward, yet
0:14
it consistently throws up significant challenges
0:16
in diagnosis, treatment, and especially long
0:19
-term patient recovery, ankle sprains. Now, when
0:22
we talk about how common these are, the figures
0:24
are really quite startling. We're looking at
0:27
an estimated 28 ,000 ankle sprains happening
0:30
every single day in the United States alone.
0:35
It really is. And if you've spent any time in
0:37
sports medicine or even A &E, you'll know it's
0:40
often the single biggest reason why athletes
0:42
miss participation. So despite their ubiquity,
0:45
their impact, both on individuals and on health
0:47
care systems, is undeniably profound. Our mission
0:51
today is to unpack the intricate nuances of these
0:54
injuries, from the fundamental anatomy that underpins
0:56
them to the cutting edge advanced treatment protocols
0:59
and, crucially, the prevention strategies that
1:02
can make all the difference. We want to provide
1:05
you, our discerning medical professional listener,
1:08
with a comprehensive yet concise understanding
1:10
that you can apply directly. And to guide us
1:13
through this intricate landscape, I'm absolutely
1:15
thrilled to welcome Prof. Mal Imam. Thank you
1:18
so much for having me. It's a genuine pleasure.
1:20
You've really nailed the core issue right there.
1:22
Ankle sprains are indeed incredibly common, almost
1:24
a rite of passage for many active individuals,
1:26
aren't they? Almost seems that way sometimes.
1:28
But the critical point... And one that's so often
1:30
underestimated is their potential for serious
1:33
debilitating long -term complications if they're
1:36
not managed appropriately from day one. We frequently
1:40
see patients in clinic years down the line still
1:42
grappling with persistent pain, instability,
1:45
or even early arthritis, all stemming from an
1:48
initial sprain that simply wasn't given the attention
1:50
it deserved. So that initial management is key.
1:53
Absolutely critical. For this deep dive, we're
1:55
going to embark on a comprehensive journey, starting
1:58
with the very first moment of injury, understanding
2:00
the mechanisms, then moving through precise diagnostic
2:03
approaches, exploring the full spectrum of treatment
2:05
from conservative to operative, and finally,
2:08
really honing in on robust prevention strategies.
2:11
Our shared aim is to arm you with actionable,
2:14
evidence -based insights that can significantly
2:16
improve patient outcomes. Right then. Let's roll
2:19
up our sleeves and get into it. Before we even
2:21
begin to unpick the various types of ankle injuries
2:24
and their manifestations, could you perhaps take
2:27
us back to basics? For many of us, it's, well,
2:30
it's been a while since anatomy lab. Could you
2:32
refresh our memory on the critical structural
2:35
foundations of the ankle? Specifically, which
2:38
ligaments are the prime suspects, the most vulnerable
2:41
players in a typical ankle sprain scenario? Absolutely.
2:45
Happy to. It's always vital to start with the
2:47
foundations, as understanding the anatomy illuminates
2:49
the pathology. The ankle joint itself is a marvel
2:53
of engineering, really. A complex articulation
2:56
involving three primary bones, the tibia and
2:59
fibula, which are the long bones of your lower
3:01
leg, and the talus, the crucial bone in your
3:03
foot, that essentially acts as the fulcrum between
3:06
your leg and the rest of your foot. The connecting
3:07
piece. Precisely. These three bones are held
3:11
together quite ingeniously by a sophisticated
3:14
network of robust ligaments. These aren't just
3:17
passive restraints. They provide both the necessary
3:19
static stability and also guide the intricate
3:22
range of motion required for everything from
3:24
a gentle stroll to a full -on sprint. When we
3:28
talk about ankle sprains, we're almost exclusively
3:30
referring to injuries to these ligaments. And
3:33
we can broadly categorize them into two main
3:35
groups based on their location and the type of
3:37
force they resist. On the outer side of the ankle,
3:40
the lateral aspect, we find the ligaments that
3:42
are unfortunately the most frequent victims in
3:45
ankle sprains. The absolute lead character here,
3:48
if you will, but one that gets injured most commonly,
3:51
is the anterior telofibular ligament, or ATFL.
3:54
ATFL, okay. This ligament is quite slender and
3:56
is positioned anteriorly at the front, connecting
3:58
the fibula to the talus. It's typically injured
4:01
when the foot is in a planter flexed or pointed
4:03
down position and then rolls inwards that classic
4:06
inversion mechanism like stepping awkwardly off
4:08
a curb or landing badly from a jump. The classic
4:11
going over on your ankle. Exactly that. It's
4:14
the weakest of the lateral ligaments, which is
4:16
why it bears the brunt of most inversion injuries.
4:20
Following the ATFL in terms of injury frequency
4:22
is the calcaneofibular ligament. or CFL. This
4:26
one sits a bit deeper and more vertically, connecting
4:28
the fibula to the calcaneus, your heel bone.
4:31
So fibula to heel bone? Correct. It tends to
4:34
be affected when the foot is in a more neutral
4:36
or even dorsiflex, flexed upwards position, during
4:39
an inversion injury. A critical distinction with
4:42
the CFL is its role not just in ankle joint stability,
4:46
but also in supporting the subtailer joint, which
4:48
allows for inversion and eversion of the foot.
4:51
Ah, so it affects more than just the main ankle
4:52
hinge. Indeed. An injury to the CFL can have
4:56
broader implications for foot mechanics. And
4:58
then, less commonly involved, usually only in
5:01
quite severe or multi -ligamentous injuries,
5:03
is the posterior televibular ligament, or PTFL,
5:06
which, as its name suggests, is at the back.
5:09
Now, shifting our focus to the inner side of
5:11
the ankle, the medial aspect, we encounter the
5:13
exceptionally strong deltoid latiment. The medial
5:15
side, right? Yes. This isn't a single band, but
5:19
rather a broad, fan -shaped complex made up of
5:22
several distinct parts. It provides truly substantial
5:26
support to the inner ankle and plays a crucial
5:28
role in limiting talar abduction. It's the outward
5:31
movement of the talus. Okay. And its deep portion
5:34
is particularly good at limiting external rotation
5:37
of the talus. Essentially, it's the primary guardian
5:40
against excessive aversion of the foot, where
5:43
the ankle rolls outwards. So it stops the ankle
5:46
collapsing inwards effectively. Precisely. It
5:48
resists that outward roll, the aversion. Interestingly,
5:52
because of its inherent strength and broad attachment,
5:55
isolated injuries to the deltoid ligament are
5:57
relatively rare. You don't see them often on
5:59
their own. Not usually. When they do occur, they
6:02
often signify a higher energy trauma or occur
6:04
in conjunction with other injuries, sometimes
6:06
even a fracture, because the bone gives way before
6:08
the ligament does. Right, the forces must be
6:10
significant. They usually are. So understanding
6:13
these specific anatomical relationships, knowing
6:16
exactly which ligament sits where and how it
6:19
functions to provide stability is absolutely
6:22
paramount. It's what allows us to accurately
6:24
diagnose the mechanism of injury when a patient
6:26
walks into our clinic. That's a truly excellent
6:29
anatomical breakdown, Prof. It really paints
6:31
a clear picture and sets the stage for understanding
6:33
the injury itself. So with that intricate anatomy
6:35
now firmly in our minds, let's move on to the
6:38
practical reality. What are the primary types
6:41
of ankle sprains we commonly encounter in clinical
6:43
practice, and how do their underlying mechanisms
6:46
and defining characteristics truly differ? I
6:48
mean, it's not just a twisted ankle, is it? Precisely.
6:52
It's far more nuanced than just a twisted ankle.
6:55
For clinicians, classifying these injuries is
6:58
fundamental to effective management. We primarily
7:01
categorize ankle sprains based on the direction
7:03
the foot moves during the injury, which in turn
7:05
dictates which ligaments bear the brunt of the
7:07
force. There are essentially three main types
7:10
we encounter. First, and by far the most ubiquitous,
7:13
are inversion sprains. These are what many colloquially
7:16
refer to as low ankle sprains, and they represent
7:18
over 90 % of all ankle sprains we see. Over 90
7:21
%? Easily. The mechanism is exactly as it sounds.
7:25
The foot rolls inward, often quite violently,
7:28
leading to damage of those lateral ligaments
7:29
we just discussed, predominantly the ATFL and
7:32
frequently the CFL as well, especially if the
7:34
injury is more severe. So the outer ligaments?
7:37
Yes, the classic scenario is an inversion injury
7:41
on a plantar flexed foot. Think of stepping into
7:44
a pothole, landing awkwardly after a jump in
7:47
netball, or simply misjudging a step off a curb.
7:50
The forces here can be quite significant, often
7:53
leading to immediate pain and swelling on the
7:55
outer side of the ankle. Secondly, we have aversion
7:59
sprains. These are significantly less common,
8:02
and for good reason. As we just highlighted,
8:05
the deltoid ligament on the inner side of the
8:07
ankle is exceptionally robust. A big fan -shaped
8:09
one. Exactly. An aversion sprain occurs when
8:11
the ankle rolls outward, placing immense stress
8:13
on this formidable deltoid ligament. These types
8:16
of sprains typically demand a much more forceful
8:19
external rotation or abduction mechanism, often
8:22
involving a higher energy impact, such as a contact
8:24
sports injury or a motor vehicle accident. Because
8:27
the deltoid is so strong, an isolated aversion
8:30
sprain is rare. You're often looking for an associated
8:32
fracture, perhaps of the fibula, because the
8:35
bone might break before the ligament pair. Interesting.
8:37
And thirdly, a less common but often far more
8:40
debilitating and challenging type are syndesmotic
8:42
sprains, universally known as high ankle sprains.
8:46
The dreaded high ankle sprain. Indeed. While
8:49
they only account for about 1 % to 10 % of all
8:52
ankle sprains, their significance is disproportionately
8:56
high. These injuries involve the tibiofibular
8:59
ligaments, specifically the anterior and posterior
9:02
tibiofibular ligaments, and the interosseous
9:05
membrane, which connect the tibia and fibula
9:07
bones above the actual ankle joint. Right, higher
9:09
up the leg. Correct. They're critical for maintaining
9:12
the integrity of the tibiofibular syndesmosis,
9:14
which forms the roof of the ankle mortis. These
9:17
sprains are frequently associated with high -end
9:19
impact activities and powerful twisting motions,
9:22
particularly where there's external rotation
9:23
of the foot on a fixed or planted leg or hyperdorsiflexion.
9:27
Like in rugby or football tackles. Exactly those
9:30
sorts of scenarios. Think of a rugby player getting
9:33
tackled with their foot caught or a footballer
9:35
twisting on the pitch. The key takeaway here
9:38
is that syndesmotic injuries can lead to significant
9:41
and chronic instability if not correctly identified
9:44
and managed, and they invariably demand a much,
9:47
much longer recovery period compared to the more
9:50
common lateral sprains. Much longer recovery,
9:52
okay. Significantly longer. Yeah. Beyond this
9:55
specific mechanism, we then classify ankle sprains
9:58
by their severity, which naturally directly dictates
10:01
the immediate management plan and the prognostic
10:04
outlook. This uses a widely accepted three -grade
10:07
system, and it's essential for clinical decision
10:10
-making. Great ice brains represent the mildest
10:12
form. Here, there's just a slight stretching
10:15
of the ligament fibers, perhaps with some microscopic
10:17
tears. Clinically, you'll observe minimal pain,
10:20
often a bit of mild swelling, and perhaps very
10:22
slight localized ecomosis or bruising. So, quite
10:25
subtle sometimes. Can be. Crucially, the patient
10:28
can usually bear weight normally. albeit perhaps
10:31
with some discomfort, and there's no detectable
10:34
ligamentous instability during your physical
10:36
examination. They might feel a bit stiff, but
10:39
the joint itself feels solid. Grade 2 sprains
10:42
indicate a more significant injury, a partial
10:45
tearing of the ligament. At this grade, the pain
10:48
is moderate, and you'll typically see more noticeable
10:50
swelling and bruising. Patients will experience
10:53
mild to moderate pain with weight bearing, and
10:55
during your examination, you might detect slight,
10:58
but definite instability. A bit wobbly. A bit
11:01
wobbly, yes. A classic, though not universal,
11:04
presentation for grade 2 sprains is often characteristic
11:06
horseshoe -shaped bruise that appears around
11:08
the heel. Ah, yes, I've seen that. Sort of wraps
11:10
around the malleolus. Exactly. That pattern is
11:13
quite indicative of the extent of the soft tissue
11:15
damage and the underlying hematoma. Finally,
11:19
grade 3 sprains represent the most severe injury,
11:22
a complete rupture of one or more ligaments.
11:25
These are truly painful injuries, presenting
11:27
with pronounced, often excruciating, pain, significant
11:31
and rapid swelling, extensive ecomosis that can
11:34
spread quite widely, and sometimes even a visible
11:36
deformity of the ankle due to the swelling and
11:38
instability. Can't bear weight at all, usually.
11:41
Often impossible or severely painful. And during
11:44
your examination, you will detect substantial
11:46
instability of the joint. It's this grade in
11:49
particular where meticulous and careful management
11:51
is absolutely critical to prevent the transition
11:54
to long -term chronic instability and other complications
11:57
we'll discuss later. Makes sense. Understanding
11:59
these grades is truly fundamental for any clinician
12:02
as it directly guides your immediate therapeutic
12:04
approach and helps in setting realistic expectations
12:07
for the patient's recovery trajectory. That distinction
12:10
between the specific mechanisms and then the
12:12
subsequent severity grading is incredibly helpful
12:15
for navigating what patients present with. It
12:18
transforms a vague twisted ankle into a precise
12:21
diagnosis. Now, let's pivot and consider the
12:24
why behind these injuries. What are the typical
12:27
scenarios that often lead to ankle sprains, and
12:29
what should we as clinicians be acutely aware
12:32
of regarding both intrinsic patient -related
12:34
factors and extrinsic environmental risk factors?
12:37
What makes someone more vulnerable? It's a fantastic
12:40
question because understanding the etiology is
12:43
paramount, not just for acute management, but
12:45
crucially for prevention. The primary cause of
12:48
an ankle sprain is almost always a sudden, uncontrolled,
12:51
and forceful twisting motion of the foot or ankle.
12:53
Right. This can manifest in a myriad of common
12:56
scenarios. Think of simply misstepping on uneven
12:59
terrain, that unexpected dip in a pavement, or
13:01
a rogue tree root on a trail run. Tripping or
13:04
falling is another ubiquitous cause, where the
13:06
foot can unexpectedly roll inward or outward
13:08
upon impact, or as you lose balance. Happens
13:10
to everyone. It really does. However, a very
13:14
significant proportion of ankle sprains especially
13:16
the more severe ones, occur during sports and
13:19
high impact activities. Any sport that demands
13:22
sudden directional changes, rapid pivoting, quick
13:25
cuts, or repetitive jumping, is inherently high
13:28
risk. We're talking about basketball, volleyball,
13:31
tennis, football, rugby, netball, essentially
13:34
any dynamic sport where the foot can get caught
13:36
or twisted while the body continues its motion.
13:39
Landing awkwardly from a jump, perhaps? Very
13:41
common mechanism. In the more severe cases of
13:43
ligament tearing, patients will often vividly
13:45
report hearing or feeling a distinct pop or snap
13:48
at the very moment of injury. Ah, the pop always
13:51
makes your ears prick up. It certainly should.
13:54
This auditory sensory feedback is a strong indicator
13:57
of a significant ligamentous event, often a complete
13:59
rupture, and should immediately raise your index
14:02
of suspicion during history taking. Beyond these
14:05
direct causes, we also identify a number of key
14:07
risk factors that predispose individuals to ankle
14:09
sprains or to recurrent sprains. These are broadly
14:12
categorized into patient -related or intrinsic
14:14
factors and environmental -related or extrinsic
14:17
factors. Okay, intrinsic first. Yes. On the intrinsic
14:20
side, we frequently observe individuals with
14:22
preexisting biomechanical limitations. For example,
14:26
limited dorsiflexion. That's a restricted upward
14:28
movement of the foot towards the shin. Skiffness
14:31
going upwards. Exactly. It significantly increases
14:34
risk because it limits the anchor's ability to
14:37
absorb shock and adapt to uneven surfaces. Similarly,
14:42
decreased proprioception. The body's subconscious
14:45
awareness of its position in space and a general
14:48
balance deficiency are major contributors. So
14:50
poor balance control. Precisely. If your body
14:54
isn't getting accurate feedback on where your
14:56
foot is in relation to the ground, or if your
14:58
reflexive muscle responses are slow, you're far
15:01
more likely to roll your ankle. Furthermore,
15:04
a subtle cavivarous foot alignment, a foot structure
15:07
characterized by a high arch and a heel that
15:09
turns slightly inward. High arch is heel turned
15:12
in. Yes. That can place the ankle in a persistently
15:14
more vulnerable position for recurrent inversion
15:17
injuries. This is a structural predisposition
15:19
that puts the lateral ligaments under greater
15:21
baseline tension. Making them more prone to injury.
15:24
Inherently more prone. As for the extrinsic factors,
15:27
Indoor court sports have historically presented
15:30
the highest risk, primarily due to the combination
15:32
of rapid multi -directional movements on often
15:35
hard, unforgiving surfaces that offer high friction,
15:39
sometimes causing the foot to stick while the
15:40
body rotates. Like basketball or netball court.
15:43
Exactly. Recognizing these modifiable risk factors
15:47
is absolutely paramount. It's not just about
15:50
treating the acute injury, it's about implementing
15:52
effective long -term prevention strategies, particularly
15:55
within athletic populations, to break that cycle
15:58
of recurrent sprains. It's fascinating how those
16:01
subtle biomechanical environmental factors can
16:03
contribute to such a common injury. Now, when
16:06
a patient actually walks into our clinic with
16:08
a suspected ankle sprain, often in quite a bit
16:10
of pain and distress, what are the absolute key
16:13
symptoms we should be looking out for? And crucially,
16:16
what are the essential elements of our clinical
16:18
and imaging evaluations to ensure we arrive at
16:20
an accurate diagnosis and, perhaps even more
16:23
importantly, rule out anything more sinister,
16:25
like a fracture or a more complex injury? This
16:28
is truly where our clinical judgment shines,
16:30
isn't it? When a patient presents, the symptoms
16:32
they report will naturally guide your initial
16:34
assessment. The most prevalent symptoms include
16:37
acute pain, which can range from a dull ache
16:40
to a sharp incapacitating pain, present at rest,
16:44
exacerbated with weight -bearing, or during any
16:47
movement of the ankle. Pain is obviously number
16:49
one. Almost always. You'll almost invariably
16:52
observe varying degrees of swelling and ecomosis
16:54
or bruising around the affected area. This can
16:57
be anything from mild puffiness to extensive
17:00
disfiguring bruising that spreads widely across
17:03
the foot and ankle. A very strong diagnostic
17:06
indicator is tenderness to touch, specifically
17:09
localized over the involved ligaments. This pinpoint
17:12
tenderness directly over the ATFL or CFL, for
17:14
example, is highly suggestive of their involvement.
17:17
Finding that exact spot. Yes, it's very helpful.
17:20
Patients will often describe a feeling of ankle
17:22
instability or a sensation of the ankle giving
17:24
way, particularly during movement or weight -bearing
17:26
activities, even if it's a subtle feeling. Restricted
17:30
range of motion is also extremely common due
17:31
to pain, swelling, and muscle guarding. They
17:34
just don't want to move it. Understandably. Less
17:37
commonly, but important to note, some individuals
17:40
might report numbness or tingling sensations
17:42
in the foot or ankle, which warns consideration
17:45
of nerve involvement. Great flag there. Potentially,
17:47
yes. Needs careful assessment. And for those
17:51
with recurrence sprains, they might describe
17:53
new or persistent catching or popping sensations,
17:56
which can signal associated intraarticular pathology,
17:59
perhaps a loose body or cartilage damage. Now,
18:03
Moving on to the clinical evaluation itself.
18:05
It begins, as always, with a meticulous history.
18:09
Understanding the precise mechanism of injury
18:11
is crucial, how exactly the foot twisted, the
18:13
direction of force, the surface, any immediate
18:16
sounds or sensations like that pop we discussed.
18:18
Getting the story straight. Absolutely. This
18:20
immediately helps you narrow down which ligaments
18:22
might be affected and the potential severity.
18:25
The physical examination, while potentially painful
18:27
for the patient due to acute inflammation and
18:29
swelling, is absolutely essential. First, Observation.
18:34
Visually assess the injured ankle. Crucially
18:36
compare it to the contralateral uninjured ankle.
18:38
Always compare. Always. Look for the extent of
18:41
swelling. The exact location and pattern of ecumosis.
18:44
Is it the classic horseshoe bruise? Is it more
18:46
diffuse? Then palpation. Gently but systematically
18:51
palpate around the entire ankle. Pinpointing
18:54
tenderness directly over specific injured ligaments
18:57
like the ATFL just anterior to the lateral malleolus
19:00
or the CFL inferior to it is a key diagnostic
19:03
step. You're also palpating around the malleoli
19:06
and the base of the fifth metatarsal and navicular
19:08
bone to rule out bony tenderness. Checking those
19:11
Ottawa rules points. Exactly. We'll come back
19:13
to those. Next, range of motion testing. Gently
19:16
assess both active and passive movement of the
19:18
ankle in all planes. While this will often be
19:21
limited by pain and swelling in the acute phase,
19:23
it gives you a baseline for functional impairment.
19:26
Next, range of motion testing. Finally, and critically,
19:29
stability testing helps assess the integrity
19:31
of the ligaments. The interior drawer test is
19:33
performed to check for excessive anterior displacement
19:36
of the talus relative to the tibia. It's often
19:38
best tested with the foot in slight plantar flexion
19:41
when assessing the ATFL and endorsiflexion for
19:43
the CFL. Testing that forward glide. Correct.
19:47
However, its usefulness can be somewhat limited
19:49
in the acute setting due to patient pain and
19:51
muscle guarding. The TALR tilt test evaluates
19:54
excessive ankle inversion typically. A difference
19:57
greater than 15 degrees compared to the uninjured
19:59
side is considered significant. 15 degrees difference.
20:02
Yes, that's the threshold often cited. It strongly
20:05
indicates injury to both the ATFL and CFL. This
20:08
test is particularly valuable for diagnosing
20:10
CFL injury by directly assessing overall ankle
20:13
instability in the coronal plane. Now, regarding
20:16
imaging studies, radiographs or x -rays are almost
20:20
always your first -line imaging modality. Their
20:23
primary purpose is to rule out fractures, which
20:25
can often present with symptoms very similar
20:27
to severe sprains. Crucial first step. Absolutely.
20:31
The indications for x -rays are brilliantly guided
20:33
by the widely adopted Ottawa ankle rules. These
20:36
rules are incredibly sensitive, boasting a sensitivity
20:39
between 96 % and 99 % for ruling out clinically
20:42
significant ankle fractures. Very sensitive indeed.
20:45
meaning if the patient doesn't meet the criteria,
20:47
you can generally confidently exclude a fracture
20:50
without x -rays, thereby reducing unnecessary
20:52
radiation exposure. You should order x -rays
20:55
if the patient presents with an inability to
20:57
bear weight both immediately after the injury
20:59
and in the emergency department or clinic, or
21:02
if there's point tenderness over the posterior
21:03
edge or tip of either the medial or lateral malleolus,
21:07
or tenderness of the base of the fifth metatarsal
21:09
or the navicular bone. So weight -bearing ability
21:12
and those specific bony points. Those are the
21:14
key criteria. Standard views include AP, lateral,
21:18
and mortis views, with weight -bearing views
21:20
where possible to assess joint space integrity
21:22
under load. For suspected high ankle sprains,
21:25
stress x -rays can be particularly useful for
21:28
diagnosing syndesmosis injury. Stress views for
21:30
the high sprains. Yes. You're specifically looking
21:33
for asymmetric widening of the mortis, specifically
21:36
a medial clear space widening greater than 4
21:39
millimeters, and a tibiofibular clear space widening
21:42
of 6 millimeters or more. These measurements
21:45
indicate a diastasis, or separation, of the tibia
21:48
and fibula. Varus stress fuse can also be used
21:51
to diagnose CFL injury by assessing for an increased
21:54
talar tilt. MRI is generally not routinely needed
21:58
for the initial diagnosis of a straightforward
21:59
ankle sprain. However, you should definitely
22:02
consider an MRI if pain and instability persist
22:05
for six to eight weeks following the initial
22:07
sprain, despite appropriate conservative management.
22:09
If things aren't getting better. Exactly. Or
22:11
if you strongly suspect associated injuries that
22:14
plain x -rays can't visualize. It's an excellent
22:17
modality for evaluating soft tissue structures
22:19
like perineal tendon pathology problems with
22:21
the tendons on the outer ankle, osteochondral
22:24
lesions of the talus, which are areas of damaged
22:26
cartilage and underlying bone, occult or hidden
22:29
syndesmotic injuries that weren't clear on x
22:31
-ray, anterior or anterolateral synovitis, which
22:34
is inflammation of the joint lining, or anterior
22:37
ankle impingement, where soft tissues get pinched
22:39
in the front of the ankle. So MRI for the complications
22:42
or persistent symptoms. That's the general rule.
22:44
Lastly, quick word on referral considerations.
22:48
Orthopedic referrals are warranted for specific
22:50
situations. This includes any suspected fractures
22:53
that aren't clearly benign or simple on x -ray,
22:55
any signs of neurovascular compromised numbness,
22:58
tingling, diminished pulses. Durgent referral
23:01
for those. Absolutely. Suspected tendon ruptures,
23:03
such as the Achilles or perennial tendons, symptoms
23:06
that are disproportionate to the trauma observed,
23:09
perhaps indicating a more complex underlying
23:11
issue, or if there's persistent diagnostic uncertainty
23:14
after your initial thorough clinical and imaging
23:17
workup. These are the cases that truly demand
23:19
specialist input to ensure optimal outcomes.
23:22
That's a truly comprehensive and incredibly practical
23:25
roadmap for diagnosis, Professor. It really demystifies
23:29
the initial clinical encounter. So once we've
23:31
accurately diagnosed an ankle sprain and we've
23:34
got a clear picture of its type and severity,
23:36
the next critical hurdle is effective management.
23:40
How do we best approach treatment from those
23:42
initial conservative measures that apply to the
23:44
vast majority of patients to considering surgical
23:47
intervention for those specific, often more complex
23:49
circumstances? I imagine it's a careful balance,
23:52
particularly with athletes keen to return to
23:55
play. It is indeed a careful balance and a multi
23:58
-phased approach is key. For the overwhelming
24:00
majority of low ankle sprains, including many
24:02
severe grade three ligament tears, robust and
24:05
effective healing can absolutely be achieved
24:07
without the need for surgery provided they are
24:10
appropriately immobilized initially and crucially
24:12
diligently rehabilitated. So non -operative first
24:16
for most. The vast majority. Non -operative treatment
24:19
typically begins with initial management or phase
24:21
one. This is where the well -known RICE protocol
24:24
has historically held sway. Rest. Advise patients
24:28
to avoid weight bearing on the injured ankle
24:30
or resuming sports activities that aggravate
24:32
it. For more severe sprains, particularly grade
24:35
two or three, crutches may be recommended for
24:38
a period to avoid weight bearing completely and
24:40
allow initial healing. Ice. Immediate application
24:44
helps significantly to reduce swelling and pain.
24:46
Recommend applying an ice pack for 20 to 30 minutes,
24:49
three to four times daily, ensuring it's wrapped
24:51
in a cloth to prevent direct skin contact and
24:53
potential ice burns. Compression. Using elastic
24:57
bandages and ace wrap or compression stocking
24:59
can help to both immobilize and support the ankle
25:01
while also actively managing edema. Elevation.
25:05
Instruct patients to raise their ankle above
25:06
heart level as often as possible during the first
25:08
48 hours. This uses gravity to help drain excess
25:11
fluid and control swelling. Right, see everyone
25:13
knows it. Everyone knows it. Now here's a critical
25:17
insight that's shifting clinical practice. While
25:20
rice has been a cornerstone for decades, recent
25:23
evidence suggests its isolated effectiveness
25:25
particularly the R for rest and the I for ice,
25:28
is somewhat limited in terms of accelerating
25:30
definitive healing beyond immediate pain and
25:33
swelling control. Oh, interesting. So rice alone
25:35
isn't the whole story. Not entirely. Strong evidence
25:39
primarily supports cryotherapy, or ice, when
25:42
combined with early controlled exercise therapy
25:44
for truly improving functional outcomes. So it's
25:46
not simply rest and ice. It's ice and move it
25:49
judiciously. Bice and movement. Controlled movement,
25:52
yes. It's also important to advise patients to
25:54
avoid in the first two to three days. Heat, alcohol
25:58
running, or excessive activity and massage, as
26:00
these can exacerbate swelling and bleeding in
26:02
the acute phase. Avoid harm, remember rice, with
26:05
caveats. Exactly. Regarding immobilization, a
26:09
short period of immobilization, perhaps around
26:11
one week, in a walking boot, in an air cast,
26:13
or a walking cast, may be required, particularly
26:16
for gray Daseki's brains, or those with significant
26:19
pain. For grade 3 sprains, a slightly longer
26:22
period of casting or bracing for 10 -14 days
26:24
with strict non -weight -bearing might be beneficial
26:27
to protect the completely torn ligament in its
26:29
initial healing phase. So immobilize, but not
26:33
for too long? That's the key. The overarching
26:35
principle that has emerged strongly in the last
26:37
decade is that early mobilization generally facilitates
26:39
a better and quicker recovery, leading to superior
26:42
functional outcomes and less stiffness in the
26:44
long run. So the immobilization period should
26:47
always be as brief as clinically necessary, guided
26:49
by the patient's pain levels and the stability
26:51
of the injury. For medication, non -steroidal
26:54
anti -inflammatory drugs or NSAIDs, such as ibuprofen,
26:58
naproxen, or Celecoxib, are widely used for pain
27:01
relief and swelling reduction. They are generally
27:04
preferred over narcotic painkillers for mild
27:06
to moderate sprains, as they improve function
27:08
by addressing both pain and inflammation. Standard
27:11
NSAIDs. Yes. However, And here's another nuanced
27:15
insight for our listeners. It's worth noting
27:17
the potential for NSI's to actually delay the
27:21
natural healing process in some contexts. This
27:23
is because they suppress the inflammatory response,
27:26
which ironically is a necessary and initial component
27:29
of the body's natural tissue repair process.
27:32
Right. Inflammation is part of healing. It is.
27:34
So while they provide symptomatic relief, we
27:36
need to be mindful of this potential trade -off,
27:38
especially in the very early stages of healing
27:41
for more severe sprains. The true cornerstone
27:44
of long -term recovery, particularly from phase
27:46
two onwards, is dedicated physical therapy and
27:48
rehabilitation. This is absolutely crucial irrespective
27:51
of the initial severity. Physio is key. Absolutely.
27:54
The early phase, phase two, or functional rehabilitation,
27:58
begins once the initial acute swelling and pain
28:01
have subsided, usually within a few days to a
28:03
week. This involves gentle motion exercises,
28:06
progressing quickly to isometric strengthening,
28:09
proprioception training, and activity -specific
28:11
exercises. It's vital that any rigid immobilization
28:14
is discontinued at this stage to prevent joint
28:16
stiffness and muscle atrophy. The goal here is
28:19
to regain a pain -free range of motion. Strengthening
28:22
phase, phase three, commences once full range
28:25
of motion is achieved and pain is well under
28:27
control. The primary focus here is on strengthening
28:29
the peroneal muscles, the muscles on the outside
28:32
of your lower leg, which are key dynamic stabilizers
28:34
of the ankle and actively resistant version.
28:37
Strengthening those outer muscles. Crucial. Neuromuscular
28:41
training, which helps improve the brain's communication
28:43
with the muscles, is integrated. Gradual incorporation
28:47
of resistance exercises using bands, weights,
28:49
or body weight is key. Water -based exercises
28:53
like aqua jogging or exercises in a pool can
28:56
be incredibly useful for patients who are still
28:58
experiencing pain during land -based weight -bearing
29:00
exercises as the buoyancy reduces load. Hydrotherapy
29:04
can be great. Very helpful. Proprioception balance
29:07
training is an absolutely essential component,
29:10
particularly given that poor balance is a significant
29:12
well -established risk factor for recurrent sprains
29:15
and chronic instability. These exercises are
29:18
designed to enhance the body's awareness of joint
29:20
position and movement. Think of simple exercises
29:22
like standing on the affected foot with eyes
29:24
open, then progressing to eyes closed. Wobble
29:27
boards and things like that. Exactly. Or using
29:30
unstable surfaces like a wobble board or foam
29:32
pad. These drills are not just about balance.
29:36
They help to re -educate the nervous system,
29:38
training faster, more reactive responses from
29:40
the peroneal muscles during dynamic activities,
29:43
helping the ankle to catch itself before it rolls.
29:46
Endurance and agility exercises are gradually
29:48
introduced once the patient is pain -free and
29:51
has achieved good strength and balance. Examples
29:54
include progressively smaller figure of eight
29:56
running drills, side -to -side shuffles, or ladder
29:58
drills. These improve agility, ankle strength,
30:01
and calf endurance, simulating sport -specific
30:04
movements. A functional brace that specifically
30:06
controls inversion and eversion is typically
30:09
recommended for use during the strengthening
30:10
period and often as a prophylactic measure for
30:13
high -risk activities, particularly in the early
30:15
return to sport phase. Bracing for sport. Often
30:18
advisable, especially initially. In terms of
30:21
outcomes for non -operative treatment, consistent
30:23
evidence shows that early functional rehabilitation
30:26
consistently leads to the quickest return to
30:28
physical activity and superior long -term outcomes.
30:31
While supervised physical therapy shows early
30:34
benefits in terms of patient confidence and adherence,
30:37
there isn't convincing evidence of a significant
30:39
long -term difference in outcome compared to
30:42
a well -structured unsupervised home program
30:44
for mild to moderate sprains, provided the patient
30:47
is compliant. So home exercises can work well
30:50
if done properly. They certainly can. Also, it's
30:53
an important point for clinicians that there's
30:55
no convincing evidence that the future development
30:57
of chronic ankle instability can be reliably
30:59
predicted solely by history, acute physical examination,
31:03
or initial radiographic parameters. So a seemingly
31:06
minor sprain can still lead to long -term issues
31:08
if not rehabilitated properly. You can't always
31:10
tell at the start. Not reliably, no. Return to
31:13
play or activity varies significantly and must
31:16
be individualized. It depends heavily on the
31:19
sprains grade, whether there's syndesmosis involvement
31:21
as high ankle sprains take longer, any associated
31:24
injuries, and critically, the patient's compliance
31:27
and progression through the rehabilitation program.
31:30
As a general guideline, Grade 1 sprains typically
31:33
allow return within 1 -2 weeks. Grade 2 sprains
31:37
usually take 2 -4 weeks. Grade 3 sprains generally
31:40
require 4 -8 weeks. And high ankle sprains? They
31:42
take longer. For high ankle sprains managed with
31:45
immobilization, recovery can be 6 -12 weeks.
31:48
If screw fixation is required for a high ankle
31:50
sprain to stabilize the syndesmosis, it could
31:53
even be a season -ending injury for an athlete
31:55
requiring 4 -6 months before return to sport.
31:58
Overall, recovery can range from as little as
32:00
two weeks for very minor sprains to three, six
32:03
months for more severe complex injuries. Quite
32:05
a range. A very wide range. Now, for operative
32:07
treatment, it is thankfully rarely required for
32:10
the majority of ankle sprains. Surgery is typically
32:12
considered only for specific, well -defined circumstances.
32:15
When does surgery come into play? The primary
32:17
indications for surgery include persistent pain
32:20
and chronic ankle instability. Despite an extensive
32:24
and rigorous course of non -operative management,
32:27
and we're talking about months of dedicated supervised
32:29
rehabilitation, not just a few weeks. After failed
32:32
conservative treatment. Yes, genuine failure
32:35
despite best efforts. It might also be considered
32:38
for great third sprains if there's a significant
32:40
bony avulsion, meaning a piece of bone has been
32:42
pulled off by the ligament. Certain high ankle
32:45
sprains with clear tibiofibular diastasis, which
32:48
is that pathological widening or separation between
32:50
the tibia and fibula, often indicating a complete
32:53
syndesmotic disruption, are also surgical candidates.
32:56
Unstable high ankle sprain. Correct. Furthermore,
32:59
if there are associated significant injuries
33:01
identified, such as osteochondral lesions, cartilage
33:04
damage on the talus, ruptured peroneal or other
33:07
tendons, or significant impingement syndromes
33:09
that don't respond to conservative care, then
33:12
surgery may be necessary to address these concomitant
33:15
issues. As for the types of surgery, arthroscopy
33:19
is a minimally invasive keyhole procedure, often
33:22
performed prior to open ligament reconstruction.
33:24
It allows the surgeon to inspect the entire joint
33:27
meticulously, identify and debride any impinging
33:30
scar tissue or synovitis, or remove loose fragments
33:33
of bone or cartilage that might be causing ongoing
33:35
pain, catching, or mechanical symptoms. We look
33:37
inside first. Often very helpful, yes. It's an
33:40
excellent diagnostic tool as well as therapeutic.
33:42
For the ligament repair or reconstruction itself,
33:45
there are two main approaches. The gold standard
33:47
for chronic lateral ankle instability is the
33:49
anatomic reconstruction, famously exemplified
33:52
by the Gould modification of the Brostrum procedure.
33:55
That's the one. This procedure involves shortening
33:58
and reinserting the ATFL and CFL to their anatomical
34:02
origins and insertions, often reinforced with
34:05
the inferior extensor retinaculum and distal
34:08
fibular periosteum, which are local soft tissues
34:11
providing additional strength. In more recent
34:13
years, suture tape augmentation, where a strong
34:16
tape is placed alongside the repair, has been
34:18
shown to further increase the strength and early
34:21
stability of this repair, allowing for potentially
34:23
faster rehabilitation. Adding extra support.
34:26
Exactly. A critical point to remember with this
34:29
procedure is that if the ligaments are overtly
34:31
lightened, it can unfortunately lead to a restricted
34:33
range of dorsiflexion post -operatively causing
34:36
stiffness. The outcomes for the Brostrom Gold
34:38
are generally very good, with good to excellent
34:41
results reported in about 90 % of cases. High
34:43
success rate. Generally, yes. Alternatively,
34:47
particularly in cases of severe instability,
34:50
failed previous repairs, or significant tissue
34:52
laxity, there are tendon transfer or tenodesis
34:55
procedures. Examples include the Watson -Jones,
34:59
Christman -Snoek, Colville, or Evans techniques.
35:02
These are considered non -anatomic reconstructions
35:04
because they don't recreate the original ligament
35:07
anatomy directly. Instead, they use a segment
35:09
of a healthy local tendon, often one of the peroneal
35:13
tendons, which is then passed through bone tunnels
35:15
to create a new functional restraint. Using a
35:18
tendon instead of repairing the ligament. Correct.
35:21
It's absolutely critical that any pre -existing
35:22
foot or ankle malalignment, such as a hindfoot
35:25
virus where the heel turns inward, is identified
35:27
and corrected, often assessed with something
35:29
like Coleman block testing before these procedures
35:32
are undertaken, as malalignment can jeopardize
35:34
the success of the reconstruction. You need to
35:36
fix the alignment first. Absolutely essential.
35:39
A common complication with these non -anatomic
35:41
reconstructions due to their altered biomechanics
35:44
can be subtalar stiffness, which can affect foot
35:47
mobility. Postoperative recovery following surgery
35:51
invariably involves a period of immobilization
35:54
in a cast or protective boot typically for four
35:57
to six weeks to safeguard the delicate repaired
36:00
ligaments during their initial healing. Strict
36:03
adherence to non -weight -bearing protocols during
36:05
this crucial initial phase is absolutely critical
36:08
to prevent re -tear of the surgical repair. Protecting
36:11
the repair. Vitally important. Rehabilitation
36:14
then commences, focusing intently on regaining
36:17
strength and range of motion, similar in principle
36:19
to conservative rehab, but often more gradual
36:22
initially. Recovery takes weeks to many months,
36:25
depending on the extent of the original injury
36:27
and the specific type of surgery performed. While
36:30
some newer mobilization protocols advocate for
36:32
earlier postoperative mobilization to improve
36:34
functional scores, it's a careful balance, as
36:37
they can also potentially lead to increased ankle
36:39
laxity and a slightly higher risk of wound healing
36:41
complications if not managed meticulously. That
36:44
distinction between non -operative and operative
36:47
strategies and the intricate nuances within each
36:49
is incredibly insightful, profess. It highlights
36:52
the depth of decision -making involved. But as
36:55
the old saying goes, and it holds so true here,
36:57
prevention is always better than cure. How can
37:01
we as clinicians truly empower our patients,
37:03
especially our athletes, like our hypothetical
37:05
netball player Sarah, who just wants to get back
37:08
on court without constant fear to proactively
37:10
reduce their risk of both initial ankle sprains
37:13
and critically those debilitating recurrent injuries?
37:16
This is indeed a vital area. and one where we
37:19
can make a tremendous impact on a patient's long
37:21
-term quality of life. It genuinely requires
37:23
a multifaceted approach, empowering patients
37:26
to be proactive and consistently maintaining
37:28
their ankle strength, balance, and flexibility.
37:30
For us as clinicians, the focus must be on targeting
37:33
and modifying any identifiable intrinsic and
37:36
extrinsic risk factors. Tackling those risk factors
37:39
we talked about. Exactly. One of the most fundamental,
37:42
yet often overlooked, aspects is footwear selection.
37:45
This is absolutely crucial for providing adequate
37:48
support and stability. For individuals whose
37:51
feet pronate excessively or who have naturally
37:53
low arches, often referred to as flat feet, advise
37:57
them to opt for shoes that offer robust arch
37:59
and front foot support, coupled with a stable,
38:02
firm heel counter. Supporting the flat foot?
38:05
Yes, controlling that inward roll. Conversely,
38:08
those with stiffer feet or high arches, a cavalvaris
38:10
alignment, for example, may benefit more from
38:13
cushioned and softer platforms, as their feet
38:15
are inherently less shock -absorbent. It goes
38:18
without saying that sport -specific shoes are
38:20
highly recommended. A runner needs running shoes
38:22
designed for gait, a basketball or netball player
38:25
needs court shoes with good lateral support and
38:27
grip, and so on. Right tool for the job. Precisely.
38:30
General cross -training shoes, while versatile,
38:33
may not offer the precise support and stability
38:35
needed for specific high -demand activities,
38:37
and importantly, advise regular replacement of
38:40
athletic shoes typically every six months for
38:42
regular runners, or even more frequently if the
38:44
tread wears out or the shoe's cushioning and
38:47
support degrade prematurely. A simple check is
38:50
if the midsole feels flat or compressed. Don't
38:52
wear worn -out trainers. A simple but effective
38:54
message. Beyond footwear, Exercise -based prevention
38:58
truly forms the core of a robust program. Strengthening
39:01
exercises are key to improving dynamic ankle
39:04
stability. This includes simple calf raises,
39:07
resistance band ankle exercises to target various
39:09
planes of motion, dorsiflexion, plantar flexion,
39:12
inversion, and aversion, and critically specific
39:15
and dedicated strengthening of the evertoor muscles,
39:18
particularly the peroneals. Again, those peroneal
39:20
muscles. They're the active stabilizers, resisting
39:23
that inversion force. Propreception exercises
39:26
are absolutely essential. Given that poor balance
39:29
and diminished joint awareness are such significant
39:32
risk factors for recurrent sprains, exercises
39:35
that enhance the conscious and subconscious awareness
39:37
of joint position and movement are paramount.
39:40
Think of single leg balance exercises. Progressively
39:42
perform first with eyes open, then with eyes
39:45
closed to remove visual cues, or using unstable
39:48
surfaces like a wobble board, balance disc, or
39:50
foam pad. Training that balance reaction. Exactly.
39:53
These drills are profound. They help to re -educate
39:56
the nervous system, training faster, more accurate
39:59
neuromuscular responses from the peroneal and
40:01
other stabilizing muscles during dynamic activities,
40:05
helping the ankle to catch itself and correct
40:07
its position milliseconds before a sprain occurs.
40:10
A structured warm -up routine, including dynamic
40:13
stretches and light cardiovascular activity targeting
40:15
the lower limbs, should always proceed any physical
40:17
activity. This prepares the muscles and ligaments
40:20
for the demands of the activity, increasing blood
40:23
flow and elasticity, thereby reducing injury
40:25
risk. And for those returning to sport or higher
40:28
-level activities, incorporating progressive
40:30
drills like quick support drills, shuttle runs,
40:32
and dynamic landings can further enhance neuromuscular
40:35
control, agility, and stability in sport -specific
40:38
contexts. These drills mimic the demands of their
40:41
sport, building confidence and resilience. Maintenance
40:44
and activity modification are also critical for
40:46
long -term success. Encourage patients to regularly
40:49
include balance and strengthening exercises in
40:51
their routine, perhaps two to three times per
40:53
week, even when they feel completely well and
40:55
pain -free. Keep doing the exercises. It isn't
40:58
just rehabilitation. It's preventative maintenance.
41:01
Furthermore, advise them to be mindful of and,
41:04
whenever possible, avoid high -risk situations,
41:07
stepping on uneven or slippery surfaces, especially
41:10
when fatigued or distracted, significantly increases
41:13
vulnerability to injury. Sometimes, just being
41:16
aware of your environment can prevent an incident.
41:19
Finally, when we consider return to activity
41:21
for athletes like Sarah, it must be a meticulously
41:24
gradual transition to sport -specific activities,
41:27
ensuring full functional recovery, confidence,
41:29
and assessed readiness before resuming previous
41:31
intensity levels. For athletes with a history
41:34
of prior sprains, a comprehensive prevention
41:36
program is particularly important. And this may
41:39
indeed include the consistent use of semi -rigid
41:41
ankle orthosis or taping, especially for those
41:44
who demonstrate a cavovirus foot alignment to
41:46
provide that essential additional mechanical
41:48
support and proprioceptive feedback. Bracing
41:51
or taping for those at higher risk? It can make
41:53
a real difference. Implementing these measures
41:55
consistently can dramatically reduce the risk
41:57
of both initial ankle sprains and, crucially,
42:00
that frustrating cycle of recurrence. That's
42:02
a truly powerful message on Prevention Prof,
42:04
emphasizing that our role extends far beyond
42:07
merely treating the acute injury. It's about
42:10
empowering patients to stay robust. But even
42:13
with the best care, diligent rehab, and robust
42:15
prevention strategies, complications can, unfortunately,
42:19
arise. What are the potential long -term complications
42:22
of ankle sprains, and how do we, as clinicians,
42:25
best identify and manage them to ensure optimal
42:28
patient outcomes, avoiding that debilitating
42:30
cycle of reinjury and chronic issues? This is
42:33
a critical discussion, because while the majority
42:35
of ankle sprains do heal well with proper management,
42:38
we absolutely cannot overlook the significant
42:40
potential for long -term term consequences if
42:42
they are not correctly identified, managed or
42:45
rehabilitated. The most immediate and significant
42:48
risk following an ankle sprain, especially if
42:49
the ankle isn't adequately healed and strengthened
42:51
before resuming full physical activity, is re
42:54
-injury. Going over on it again. Exactly. The
42:57
structural integrity of the ankle has been compromised,
42:59
even if subtly, making it inherently more susceptible
43:02
to future sprains. Each re -injury can progressively
43:05
worsen the joint's stability. A notable and pervasive
43:09
long -term consequence affecting a significant
43:11
proportion of patients is chronic ankle instability,
43:14
or CAI. This develops in an estimated 15 % to
43:18
20 % of patients, particularly when an initial
43:20
ankle sprain, especially a severe one like a
43:23
grade II or III, isn't allowed to heal completely
43:25
or isn't adequately rehabilitated. 15 to 20 %
43:28
is quite high. It is worryingly high. CAI is
43:32
clinically characterized by persistent pain,
43:34
ongoing swelling that seems to come and go, and
43:36
most tellingly, the ankle repeatedly giving way
43:39
or feeling profoundly unstable during weight
43:41
-bearing activities, even on flat ground. That
43:43
feeling of untrustworthiness. Precisely. It can
43:46
be the result of a single, severe, inadequately
43:49
rehabilitated sprain or the cumulative effect
43:52
of multiple recurrence sprains that progressively
43:54
stretch and weaken the ligaments. This chronic
43:57
instability often leads to debilitating chronic
43:59
pain, significant difficulty with activities
44:01
like walking, running, or playing sports, and
44:04
in the very long term dramatically increases
44:07
the risk of developing early onset osteoarthritis
44:09
and further damage to the underlying articular
44:11
cartilage and bone within the joint due to abnormal
44:14
loading patterns. Leading to arthritis down the
44:16
line. A very real risk. When we look at long
44:19
-term symptom statistics, the data is quite sobering.
44:22
Research indicates that between 5 % and 46 %
44:25
of patients report lingering pain years after
44:27
their initial injury, and a staggering 33 % to
44:30
55 % continue to experience a sensation of instability
44:34
or giving way. Wow, over half in some studies.
44:37
Yes. While acute pain typically decreases rapidly
44:40
within the first two weeks post -injury, a notable
44:43
percentage between 5 % and 33 % still report
44:46
some level of pain even at one -year follow -up.
44:49
This powerfully highlights that simply getting
44:52
over the acute pain is by no means indicative
44:55
of full recovery or resolution of the underlying
44:57
issue. A significant and often overlooked cause
45:00
of persistent chronic pain following an ankle
45:03
sprain is actually a missed initial injury. These
45:06
are often subtle but clinically significant pathologies
45:08
that weren't picked up in the acute phase. Exactly.
45:12
This can include missed fractures, such as those
45:14
to the base of the fifth metatarsal, the anterior
45:16
process of the calcaneus, or more subtle fractures
45:18
of the lateral or posterior process of the talus.
45:21
Osteochondral lesions, which are areas of damage
45:23
to the articular cartilage and the underlying
45:25
bone, most commonly affecting the talus. These
45:28
can cause persistent pain, catching, or locking
45:31
sensations. Injuries to the coronial tendons,
45:33
which are key dynamic stabilizers. These can
45:35
involve tenosynovitis, subluxation, or even full
45:38
ruptures. An undiagnosed or inadequately treated
45:41
syndesmosis injury, high ankle sprain, which
45:44
as we discussed is far more severe and takes
45:46
much longer to heal. Tarsal coalition, which
45:48
is an abnormal fibrous, cartilaginous, or bony
45:50
connection between two or more bones in the hindfoot.
45:53
It can predispose to sprains and become symptomatic
45:55
after trauma. Various impingement syndromes,
45:57
such as anterior or anterolateral synovitis,
46:00
inflammation of the joint lining in the front
46:01
of the ankle, or impingement of the anterior
46:04
or inferior tibiofibular ligaments from scar
46:07
tissue. Interlying hindfoot varus malalignment,
46:10
which places chronic stress on the lateral ankle
46:12
structures. Or even stretch neuropraxia. where
46:15
a peripheral nerve, often the superficial peroneal
46:18
nerve, has been stretched or compressed during
46:20
the spraying, leading to neuropathic pain or
46:23
altered sensation in its distribution. Quite
46:25
a list of potential missed problems. It requires
46:28
a high index of suspicion. A truly thorough clinical
46:32
evaluation is thus paramount to prevent these
46:35
crucial oversights. The overall prognosis for
46:38
ankle sprains is generally positive with proper
46:40
treatment and dedicated rehabilitation. However,
46:44
the ultimate success of recovery is highly dependent
46:46
on the initial sprain grade, the presence or
46:49
absence of any other associated injuries, both
46:51
diagnosed and those that might have been initially
46:53
missed, and, critically, the patient's unwavering
46:56
commitment to their rehabilitation program. Patient
46:59
compliance is vital. Absolutely vital. Incomplete
47:02
rehabilitation is, without doubt, the most common
47:04
single cause of chronic ankle instability and
47:07
subsequent re -injury. Patients who discontinue
47:10
their strengthening and balance exercises prematurely
47:13
will inevitably find their injured ligaments
47:15
and the surrounding dynamic stabilizers weaken,
47:18
putting them at exceedingly high risk for future
47:20
sprains. It's also crucial to counsel patients
47:23
that while surgical interventions are sometimes
47:25
absolutely necessary for chronic instability
47:28
or other associated complications, they do carry
47:31
their own inherent risks. These can include the
47:33
general risk of surgery like infection or nerve
47:35
damage, a potentially prolonged recovery period
47:38
with strict immobilization, and the unfortunate
47:40
possibility of some residual loss of ankle range
47:43
of motion postoperatively, even with the best
47:45
surgical technique. Surgery isn't without its
47:47
own issues. Never. So the decision for surgery
47:50
is always a careful considered one, weighing
47:52
these risks and potential benefits against the
47:54
patient's individual circumstances and goals.
47:57
Our aim is always to guide the patient to the
47:59
best long -term outcome, whether that's with
48:01
or without a scalpel. often long -term impact
48:06
of seemingly simple injuries and highlights the
48:09
absolute imperative for comprehensive, diligent,
48:12
and patient -centered care. Prof. Moimam, you've
48:15
guided us through an incredibly detailed and
48:18
remarkably insightful deep dive into ankle sprains.
48:21
From the foundational anatomical understanding
48:23
and nuanced classification through to the comprehensive
48:26
treatment strategies and crucially, those vital
48:29
prevention methods, you've provided an invaluable
48:32
actionable overview for all of us as mid -senior
48:35
medical professionals. What really stands out
48:38
from our conversation today is the absolute importance
48:40
of a thorough clinical approach right from the
48:42
outset, meticulously ruling out those missed
48:45
injuries, coupled with an unwavering commitment
48:47
to comprehensive and often prolonged rehabilitation.
48:50
These elements are unequivocally key to mitigating
48:53
those potential long -term complications we've
48:55
discussed, ensuring our patients don't get caught
48:57
in that frustrating cycle of chronic pain and
48:59
instability. We genuinely hope this deep dive
49:02
has offered you some new perspectives, perhaps
49:03
at clarified some complex areas or reinforced
49:06
critical best practices in your own clinical
49:08
encounters. If you found this deep dive valuable,
49:11
please consider rating and sharing it with your
49:12
colleagues. It truly helps us reach more professionals
49:15
like you. My pleasure entirely. To leave you
49:17
with a final thought. While ankle sprains are
49:21
indeed ubiquitous and almost daily occurrence
49:23
in our clinics, our continually evolving understanding
49:26
of ankle biomechanics, the sophisticated rehabilitation
49:29
principles we now have at our disposal, and the
49:32
advanced surgical techniques available offer
49:34
us genuinely significant opportunities. The true
49:38
challenge for us as orthopedic professionals
49:40
lies not just in knowing these advancements,
49:42
but in the consistent, meticulous, and diligent
49:45
application of these principles in every single
49:47
clinical encounter. Because ultimately, this
49:49
isn't just about treating an injury, it's about
49:51
fundamentally preventing debilitating long -term
49:53
consequences, and more broadly, significantly
49:56
enhancing our patient's overall quality of life.