Latest / The Living Conversation / Grit vs. Good Fortune: College, Careers, and Who We Become (SSU Philosophy Club)
Transcript
- 0:00Foreign.
- 0:15I'm
- 0:16Anthony
- 0:16Wright
- 0:16and
- 0:17I
- 0:17am
- 0:17your
- 0:17host
- 0:18today
- 0:18with
- 0:18my
- 0:18co
- 0:19host,
- 0:20Adam
- 0:20Dietz.
- 0:21Welcome.
- 0:21And
- 0:22Adam
- 0:22is.
- 0:25We
- 0:25are
- 0:25co
- 0:26hosts
- 0:26on
- 0:26the
- 0:27show
- 0:27that's
- 0:27called
- 0:28the
- 0:28Living
- 0:28Conversation
- 0:29and
- 0:29we'd
- 0:29like
- 0:29to
- 0:30welcome
- 0:30you.
- 0:30And
- 0:30we
- 0:31have
- 0:31guests
- 0:32today
- 0:32from
- 0:33the
- 0:33Sonoma
- 0:33State
- 0:34University
- 0:34Philosophy
- 0:35Club.
- 0:36And
- 0:36welcome
- 0:36Colette
- 0:37and
- 0:37Andrew
- 0:38and
- 0:38Peter.
- 0:40So
- 0:42Colette,
- 0:43you
- 0:43were
- 0:43saying
- 0:43before
- 0:44we
- 0:44got
- 0:44started
- 0:45that
- 0:46you
- 0:46had
- 0:47a
- 0:47topic
- 0:47you
- 0:47wanted
- 0:48to
- 0:48talk
- 0:48about.
- 0:48And
- 0:48what
- 0:49exactly
- 0:50did
- 0:50you
- 0:50want
- 0:51to
- 0:51talk
- 0:51about
- 0:51today,
- 0:51please?
- 0:53Yeah.
- 0:53So
- 0:54the
- 0:54last
- 0:54philosophy
- 0:55club
- 0:55meeting
- 0:56we
- 0:57were
- 0:57discussing
- 0:58whether
- 0:58suffering
- 0:59was
- 0:59essential
- 1:00to
- 1:00living
- 1:01a
- 1:01good
- 1:01life
- 1:01or
- 1:02not,
- 1:03which
- 1:03is
- 1:03kind
- 1:03of
- 1:04an
- 1:04interesting
- 1:04conversation.
- 1:08So
- 1:09what
- 1:09do
- 1:09you
- 1:10think,
- 1:10Adam?
- 1:12Me?
- 1:13I
- 1:13think
- 1:13that,
- 1:14you
- 1:14know,
- 1:15we
- 1:16come
- 1:16from
- 1:16a
- 1:17very
- 1:17strong
- 1:18background
- 1:18of
- 1:18Chinese
- 1:19philosophy.
- 1:20And
- 1:20in
- 1:20Chinese
- 1:21philosophy,
- 1:21suffering
- 1:22is
- 1:22when
- 1:22something
- 1:22is
- 1:22out
- 1:23of
- 1:23harmony.
- 1:24So
- 1:24the
- 1:25principle
- 1:25of
- 1:25life
- 1:27is
- 1:27should,
- 1:28should
- 1:28be
- 1:28in
- 1:28harmony.
- 1:29And
- 1:29there's
- 1:30a
- 1:30natural
- 1:30state
- 1:31is
- 1:31harmony.
- 1:31So
- 1:32when
- 1:32something,
- 1:32when,
- 1:32when
- 1:33someone
- 1:33gets
- 1:33sick
- 1:34or
- 1:34when
- 1:34someone's
- 1:35suffering,
- 1:35it's
- 1:35something
- 1:36that's
- 1:36out
- 1:36of
- 1:36harmony.
- 1:38So
- 1:38to
- 1:38think
- 1:39that
- 1:39suffering.
- 1:40The
- 1:40short
- 1:40answer
- 1:41would
- 1:41be
- 1:41in
- 1:41Chinese
- 1:41philosophy,
- 1:42is
- 1:42suffering
- 1:44necessary
- 1:45for
- 1:45a
- 1:46good
- 1:46life?
- 1:46They
- 1:46say
- 1:47no,
- 1:47actually
- 1:47suffering
- 1:48is
- 1:48the
- 1:48opposite
- 1:49of
- 1:49a
- 1:49good
- 1:49life.
- 1:50Suffering
- 1:51comes
- 1:51when
- 1:51something's
- 1:52out
- 1:52of
- 1:52harmony.
- 1:53So
- 1:53people
- 1:54should
- 1:54emphasize
- 1:55trying
- 1:55to
- 1:56let
- 1:56their
- 1:56original
- 1:57harmony
- 1:57come
- 1:57out,
- 1:58their
- 1:58natural
- 1:59self
- 1:59come
- 2:00out
- 2:01and
- 2:01revert
- 2:02to
- 2:02this
- 2:03kind
- 2:03of
- 2:03natural
- 2:03harmony.
- 2:04So
- 2:05this
- 2:05will
- 2:05have
- 2:05no
- 2:05suffering.
- 2:06Actually,
- 2:06it's
- 2:06very,
- 2:07very,
- 2:07very
- 2:08wonderful,
- 2:08very
- 2:09good,
- 2:09very
- 2:09happy.
- 2:11You
- 2:12know,
- 2:12one
- 2:12of
- 2:12the
- 2:12things
- 2:13also
- 2:13that
- 2:13I
- 2:14had.
- 2:17Thought
- 2:17about
- 2:18with,
- 2:18with
- 2:18suffering
- 2:20and
- 2:21certainly.
- 2:21Would
- 2:22you
- 2:22refresh
- 2:22my
- 2:23memory,
- 2:23Adam,
- 2:24about
- 2:25Was
- 2:25it
- 2:26Socrates
- 2:27who
- 2:27said
- 2:27the
- 2:28to
- 2:29live
- 2:29a
- 2:29good
- 2:29life,
- 2:29hey,
- 2:30you
- 2:30have
- 2:30to
- 2:30have
- 2:31an
- 2:31examined
- 2:31life?
- 2:32Yes,
- 2:33that's
- 2:33correct.
- 2:33Okay.
- 2:34Because
- 2:35one
- 2:35of
- 2:35the
- 2:35things
- 2:35that
- 2:37it
- 2:37was
- 2:37a
- 2:38real
- 2:38breakthrough
- 2:38for
- 2:38me
- 2:39to
- 2:39understand.
- 2:41And
- 2:41this
- 2:41was
- 2:42a
- 2:42Buddhist
- 2:42idea
- 2:43about.
- 2:45It,
- 2:46was
- 2:46what
- 2:46the
- 2:46Buddha
- 2:47saw
- 2:47when
- 2:47he
- 2:47looked
- 2:47over
- 2:48the.
- 2:48The
- 2:49edge
- 2:49of
- 2:49the
- 2:49palace
- 2:50he
- 2:50was
- 2:50living
- 2:50in
- 2:51and
- 2:51he
- 2:51saw
- 2:51old
- 2:51age
- 2:52and
- 2:52saw
- 2:52people.
- 2:55Dying.
- 2:57But
- 2:58what
- 2:59Alan
- 2:59Watts
- 2:59was
- 2:59talking
- 3:00about
- 3:00was
- 3:02that
- 3:03suffering
- 3:04comes
- 3:04from
- 3:05desire.
- 3:07And.
- 3:09That.
- 3:11You
- 3:12get
- 3:12into
- 3:12sort
- 3:13of
- 3:13a
- 3:13interesting
- 3:14paradox
- 3:15about.
- 3:17Desiring
- 3:17not
- 3:18to
- 3:18desire.
- 3:20And.
- 3:22The
- 3:23problem
- 3:24comes
- 3:24actually
- 3:25from
- 3:25the
- 3:26illusion
- 3:26of
- 3:26separateness
- 3:27because
- 3:27the
- 3:28desire
- 3:28is
- 3:28to
- 3:29separate
- 3:29yourself
- 3:29from
- 3:30something.
- 3:32And
- 3:32that
- 3:32was
- 3:32a
- 3:32real
- 3:33breakthrough
- 3:33for
- 3:33me
- 3:34because
- 3:34then
- 3:35I
- 3:37came
- 3:37to
- 3:37understand
- 3:38that
- 3:40if
- 3:40there's
- 3:40no
- 3:41separated
- 3:41individuality,
- 3:42then
- 3:43there's
- 3:43no
- 3:43suffering.
- 3:44Because
- 3:45this
- 3:46is,
- 3:47this
- 3:47body
- 3:47that's
- 3:48calls
- 3:48itself
- 3:48Anthony,
- 3:49is
- 3:49just
- 3:49what
- 3:49the
- 3:50universe
- 3:50is
- 3:50doing
- 3:51here
- 3:51and.
- 3:54For
- 3:54each
- 3:54of
- 3:54us
- 3:55is
- 3:55of
- 3:55course
- 3:56is
- 3:56a
- 3:56resonant
- 3:57node
- 3:57in
- 3:57the
- 3:57holographic
- 3:58field.
- 3:58If
- 3:59you
- 3:59want
- 3:59to
- 3:59get
- 4:01technical
- 4:01about
- 4:02it.
- 4:02But
- 4:02it
- 4:03was
- 4:03very
- 4:03useful
- 4:04for
- 4:04me
- 4:04to
- 4:04understand.
- 4:07That
- 4:08there
- 4:08wasn't
- 4:09any
- 4:09separated
- 4:09me.
- 4:10So
- 4:10it's
- 4:10just
- 4:10what
- 4:11the.
- 4:11What
- 4:11the
- 4:11cosmos
- 4:12is
- 4:12doing.
- 4:12What
- 4:13did
- 4:13you
- 4:13guys
- 4:13get
- 4:13into
- 4:14Colette?
- 4:15And.
- 4:15And
- 4:15what
- 4:16did
- 4:16you
- 4:16come
- 4:17to
- 4:17any
- 4:17conclusions?
- 4:19So
- 4:19it
- 4:20was
- 4:20pretty
- 4:2050,
- 4:2150
- 4:21by
- 4:21the
- 4:21end
- 4:21of
- 4:22the
- 4:22hour.
- 4:24But
- 4:25so.
- 4:26So
- 4:26I
- 4:26was
- 4:27on
- 4:27the
- 4:27side
- 4:27of
- 4:28like
- 4:29that
- 4:29we
- 4:29have
- 4:30to
- 4:30have
- 4:30suffering
- 4:31in
- 4:31order
- 4:31to
- 4:32have
- 4:32a
- 4:32good
- 4:32life.
- 4:33And
- 4:34Haley,
- 4:35who's
- 4:35not
- 4:35here
- 4:36this
- 4:36time,
- 4:37but
- 4:38she
- 4:38was
- 4:38talking
- 4:39about
- 4:39how.
- 4:42Like
- 4:43if
- 4:43you're
- 4:43suffering,
- 4:44then.
- 4:45Then
- 4:46when
- 4:46you
- 4:46come
- 4:47out
- 4:47of
- 4:47the
- 4:47suffering,
- 4:47then
- 4:48you
- 4:48appreciate
- 4:48the
- 4:49good
- 4:49moments
- 4:50even
- 4:50more
- 4:50because,
- 4:51well,
- 4:52at
- 4:52least
- 4:52it's
- 4:52not
- 4:52that
- 4:53bad,
- 4:53you
- 4:54know.
- 4:56And
- 4:56I
- 4:56think,
- 4:57Andrew,
- 4:57were
- 4:58you
- 4:58on
- 4:58the
- 4:58other
- 4:58side?
- 4:58I
- 4:59think.
- 4:59Right.
- 4:59Yeah,
- 5:00I'm
- 5:00on
- 5:00the
- 5:00other
- 5:01side
- 5:01basically
- 5:02completely
- 5:03is.
- 5:03Is
- 5:04that.
- 5:06I
- 5:07don't
- 5:07think
- 5:08suffering
- 5:08is
- 5:09necessary
- 5:09for
- 5:09a
- 5:09good
- 5:10life.
- 5:10And
- 5:10we
- 5:11were
- 5:11coming
- 5:11at
- 5:11it
- 5:12from
- 5:12many
- 5:12different
- 5:12angles.
- 5:13They
- 5:13were
- 5:13talking
- 5:13about
- 5:13both
- 5:14enjoyment
- 5:14and
- 5:14they
- 5:15were
- 5:15also
- 5:15talking
- 5:15about.
- 5:17It
- 5:17wasn't
- 5:17the
- 5:17angle
- 5:18I
- 5:18was
- 5:18trying
- 5:18to
- 5:18talk
- 5:18about,
- 5:18but
- 5:20I
- 5:20believe
- 5:20you
- 5:21were
- 5:21talking
- 5:21about
- 5:22like
- 5:23the
- 5:23like
- 5:23ethics,
- 5:24like
- 5:24in
- 5:24terms
- 5:24of.
- 5:26You
- 5:26have
- 5:27to
- 5:27have
- 5:27suffering
- 5:27to
- 5:28be
- 5:28a
- 5:28good
- 5:28person.
- 5:30Was
- 5:31that.
- 5:31Was
- 5:31that
- 5:31what
- 5:31you
- 5:32were
- 5:32saying
- 5:33or
- 5:33somebody
- 5:34was
- 5:34saying
- 5:34that
- 5:34I
- 5:35believe
- 5:35might
- 5:35not
- 5:35have
- 5:35been
- 5:35you.
- 5:36But
- 5:36do
- 5:36you
- 5:36remember
- 5:37that?
- 5:37I
- 5:38do
- 5:38remember
- 5:38us
- 5:39talking
- 5:39about
- 5:39that.
- 5:41Yeah.
- 5:42That's
- 5:42a
- 5:42toughie
- 5:43because
- 5:43like
- 5:43if
- 5:43you
- 5:43haven't
- 5:44experienced
- 5:46real
- 5:46suffering,
- 5:47then
- 5:47like
- 5:48it's.
- 5:48It's
- 5:49really
- 5:49difficult
- 5:49to.
- 5:50To
- 5:50feel
- 5:50for
- 5:51those
- 5:51people
- 5:51who
- 5:52are
- 5:52suffering
- 5:53and
- 5:53to
- 5:53be
- 5:54able
- 5:54to
- 5:54understand
- 5:54where
- 5:54they're
- 5:55coming
- 5:55from
- 5:55and
- 5:56really
- 5:56experience
- 5:57true
- 5:57empathy.
- 5:58So
- 6:00do
- 6:00it
- 6:00that
- 6:01what
- 6:01you
- 6:01will.
- 6:02So
- 6:02you're
- 6:02saying
- 6:02that
- 6:03suffering
- 6:03is
- 6:03a
- 6:04part
- 6:04of
- 6:04the
- 6:04human
- 6:04condition.
- 6:05Yeah.
- 6:07Okay.
- 6:07And
- 6:08I
- 6:08guess
- 6:09go
- 6:09ahead.
- 6:09I
- 6:09also
- 6:10thought
- 6:10somewhere
- 6:11along
- 6:11the
- 6:11same
- 6:11lines
- 6:12that
- 6:13sometimes
- 6:13it
- 6:13might
- 6:14be
- 6:14necessary
- 6:15to
- 6:15even
- 6:16see
- 6:16yourself
- 6:17become
- 6:18a
- 6:18better
- 6:18person.
- 6:19I
- 6:20really
- 6:20thought
- 6:20about
- 6:20this
- 6:21and
- 6:21I
- 6:21really
- 6:22do
- 6:22think
- 6:22that
- 6:22working
- 6:23deliberately
- 6:24toward
- 6:24personal
- 6:25goals
- 6:25in
- 6:25life
- 6:26can
- 6:26feel
- 6:26like
- 6:27suffering
- 6:27in
- 6:27the
- 6:27moment.
- 6:28Though
- 6:29I
- 6:29think
- 6:29to
- 6:29build
- 6:29meaning
- 6:30in
- 6:30life,
- 6:30there
- 6:30is
- 6:31an
- 6:31element
- 6:31of
- 6:31suffering
- 6:32that
- 6:32is
- 6:32needed
- 6:33for
- 6:33yourself
- 6:33to
- 6:33find.
- 6:34It
- 6:35and
- 6:36say
- 6:36suffering
- 6:36is.
- 6:37I
- 6:37believe
- 6:37that
- 6:38you're
- 6:38working
- 6:38toward
- 6:39goals
- 6:39in
- 6:40life.
- 6:41Yes.
- 6:42And
- 6:42I
- 6:42really
- 6:42do
- 6:43think
- 6:43that
- 6:44if
- 6:44you
- 6:45really
- 6:45work
- 6:45towards
- 6:45it,
- 6:46it
- 6:46can.
- 6:48Be
- 6:49derived
- 6:49from
- 6:49something
- 6:50that
- 6:50you
- 6:50invested
- 6:51a
- 6:51lot
- 6:51in
- 6:51to
- 6:51see
- 6:51yourself
- 6:52grow.
- 6:53There's
- 6:53one
- 6:53example
- 6:54that
- 6:54I
- 6:55have
- 6:55had
- 6:55where
- 6:55I've
- 6:56tried
- 6:56many
- 6:56work
- 6:56experiences.
- 6:57For
- 6:57instance,
- 6:58I
- 6:58wanted
- 6:58to
- 6:59go
- 6:59for
- 7:00after
- 7:00school
- 7:01and
- 7:01some
- 7:02of
- 7:02it
- 7:03my
- 7:03search
- 7:04for
- 7:04purposeful
- 7:05work
- 7:05experience
- 7:06that
- 7:06is
- 7:06meaningful
- 7:07for
- 7:07me
- 7:07spanned
- 7:08from
- 7:09first
- 7:10I
- 7:10wanted
- 7:10to
- 7:10shadow
- 7:11in
- 7:11a
- 7:11real
- 7:11Estate
- 7:12office
- 7:12to
- 7:12practice,
- 7:13an
- 7:13internship,
- 7:15then
- 7:15another
- 7:16experience
- 7:16for
- 7:17building
- 7:18websites
- 7:18within
- 7:19another
- 7:19place.
- 7:20And
- 7:20it
- 7:20seemed
- 7:21to
- 7:21me
- 7:21that
- 7:21in
- 7:21those
- 7:22experiences,
- 7:23to
- 7:23really
- 7:24get
- 7:24a
- 7:24meaningful
- 7:25reward
- 7:25toward
- 7:25finding
- 7:26something,
- 7:27there's
- 7:27an
- 7:28element
- 7:28of
- 7:28grit
- 7:29for
- 7:29that
- 7:29meaning
- 7:30to
- 7:30really
- 7:30blossom
- 7:31from
- 7:31it.
- 7:31And
- 7:32you
- 7:32really
- 7:32get
- 7:33more
- 7:33of
- 7:33a
- 7:33meaningful
- 7:34reward
- 7:34by
- 7:35building
- 7:35your
- 7:35goals
- 7:36out
- 7:36and
- 7:37making
- 7:37your
- 7:37personal
- 7:38meetings
- 7:38and
- 7:39career
- 7:39go
- 7:40greater
- 7:41than
- 7:41it
- 7:41was
- 7:41before.
- 7:42And
- 7:43those
- 7:43are
- 7:43some
- 7:43of
- 7:44the
- 7:44meanings
- 7:44of
- 7:45grit
- 7:45and
- 7:45self
- 7:46growth
- 7:47that
- 7:47have
- 7:47really
- 7:47started
- 7:48to
- 7:48develop
- 7:48greater
- 7:49from
- 7:50my
- 7:50various
- 7:51experiences.
- 7:53That's
- 7:53so
- 7:53interesting.
- 7:53That
- 7:54makes
- 7:54me
- 7:54think
- 7:54of
- 7:54like
- 7:55what
- 7:55you
- 7:55were
- 7:55saying,
- 7:57professor,
- 7:57right,
- 7:58is
- 7:59like
- 7:59when
- 8:00you
- 8:00were
- 8:00talking
- 8:00about
- 8:00desire.
- 8:03And
- 8:05like
- 8:05it's.
- 8:06You
- 8:06can
- 8:06equate
- 8:07it
- 8:07to
- 8:07yearning.
- 8:08It's
- 8:08like
- 8:08if
- 8:09you
- 8:09don't
- 8:09have
- 8:10something
- 8:10to
- 8:10yearn
- 8:11for,
- 8:12then
- 8:13like
- 8:14you're
- 8:14almost
- 8:15missing
- 8:15out
- 8:15on
- 8:17the
- 8:17human
- 8:18condition.
- 8:20You're.
- 8:20You're
- 8:21almost
- 8:21not
- 8:21living
- 8:22your
- 8:22life
- 8:22to
- 8:22the
- 8:22fullest
- 8:23if
- 8:23you
- 8:23don't
- 8:23have
- 8:23something
- 8:24to
- 8:24yearn
- 8:25for.
- 8:28What
- 8:29say?
- 8:29I
- 8:29think.
- 8:31Yeah,
- 8:31so
- 8:32interesting.
- 8:32Also,
- 8:33in
- 8:33Chinese
- 8:33philosophy,
- 8:33you
- 8:33should
- 8:34have
- 8:34a
- 8:34great
- 8:34goal,
- 8:35great
- 8:36will.
- 8:36So
- 8:37often
- 8:38in
- 8:38Chinese
- 8:39history,
- 8:40they
- 8:40would
- 8:40ask
- 8:41the
- 8:41students,
- 8:41okay,
- 8:42beginning
- 8:42of
- 8:43school,
- 8:43maybe
- 8:43like
- 8:43even
- 8:43kindergarten,
- 8:44what's
- 8:45your
- 8:45great
- 8:45goal?
- 8:46And
- 8:46the
- 8:46students
- 8:47will
- 8:47all.
- 8:48So
- 8:48many
- 8:48students
- 8:48will
- 8:49answer,
- 8:49I
- 8:49want
- 8:49to
- 8:49be
- 8:49a
- 8:50Confucius.
- 8:53Very
- 8:53high
- 8:54goal,
- 8:54very
- 8:55high
- 8:55goal.
- 8:56So
- 8:57yes,
- 8:57I
- 8:58agree
- 8:58that
- 8:58you
- 8:58should
- 8:59have
- 8:59a
- 8:59really
- 8:59high
- 9:00goal.
- 9:00And
- 9:00that's
- 9:00part
- 9:00of,
- 9:01that's
- 9:01part
- 9:01of
- 9:01growth
- 9:02experience
- 9:02as
- 9:02a
- 9:02human
- 9:03being.
- 9:03I
- 9:03agree
- 9:04100%.
- 9:05As
- 9:05far
- 9:06as
- 9:06the
- 9:06suffering
- 9:06goes
- 9:07though,
- 9:07there's
- 9:07things
- 9:08that
- 9:08are
- 9:08out
- 9:08of
- 9:08your
- 9:08control,
- 9:09right?
- 9:10There's
- 9:10those
- 9:11things
- 9:11you
- 9:11have
- 9:12to
- 9:12learn
- 9:12how
- 9:12to
- 9:14maybe
- 9:14go
- 9:14with
- 9:14the
- 9:15flow,
- 9:15right?
- 9:15And
- 9:16take
- 9:16care
- 9:16of
- 9:17yourself,
- 9:17protect
- 9:17yourself.
- 9:18Because.
- 9:18Because
- 9:20true
- 9:21happiness,
- 9:22true
- 9:22freedom
- 9:23is
- 9:24all
- 9:24inside
- 9:24you,
- 9:25right?
- 9:26Your
- 9:26mind,
- 9:27your
- 9:28heart,
- 9:28your
- 9:29soul.
- 9:29That
- 9:30is
- 9:30where
- 9:30happiness
- 9:30always
- 9:31exists.
- 9:31You
- 9:31can't
- 9:32have
- 9:32happiness
- 9:32without
- 9:33that.
- 9:33You,
- 9:34your
- 9:35happiness
- 9:35is
- 9:35within.
- 9:36So
- 9:38the
- 9:38better
- 9:39you
- 9:39are
- 9:39in
- 9:39touch
- 9:40with
- 9:40your
- 9:40mind
- 9:40and
- 9:40your
- 9:40heart
- 9:41and
- 9:41your
- 9:41soul,
- 9:41the
- 9:42more
- 9:42you
- 9:42can
- 9:42endure
- 9:43anything.
- 9:44Even
- 9:44in
- 9:44a
- 9:44difficult
- 9:45situation,
- 9:45even
- 9:46if
- 9:46it's
- 9:46something
- 9:46out
- 9:47of
- 9:47your
- 9:47control
- 9:47that
- 9:47is
- 9:48stressful,
- 9:48you
- 9:48can't.
- 9:49It's
- 9:49giving
- 9:50you
- 9:50trouble,
- 9:50it's
- 9:50giving
- 9:51you
- 9:51suffering
- 9:52inside
- 9:52your
- 9:52mind.
- 9:53If
- 9:53your
- 9:53mind
- 9:53is
- 9:54very
- 9:54cultivated,
- 9:55you
- 9:55can
- 9:55still
- 9:56be
- 9:56happy.
- 9:59As
- 9:59the
- 9:59Buddha
- 10:00said,
- 10:01there
- 10:01is
- 10:01suffering
- 10:02in
- 10:02the
- 10:02Four
- 10:02Noble
- 10:03Truths.
- 10:03There
- 10:04is
- 10:04an
- 10:04end
- 10:04to
- 10:04suffering,
- 10:06and
- 10:06the
- 10:06end
- 10:06of
- 10:07suffering
- 10:07is
- 10:08the
- 10:08Eightfold
- 10:09Path.
- 10:11And
- 10:11it's.
- 10:13I
- 10:13don't
- 10:13remember
- 10:13all
- 10:14eight
- 10:14of
- 10:14them,
- 10:14but.
- 10:17It'S
- 10:17right
- 10:18action.
- 10:20Right
- 10:21attitude.
- 10:23And
- 10:23I
- 10:24guess
- 10:25in
- 10:26complexity
- 10:26science
- 10:27terms,
- 10:27it
- 10:27would
- 10:28be.
- 10:31A
- 10:31coherence
- 10:32or
- 10:32a
- 10:32resonance
- 10:33with
- 10:33what?
- 10:33Whatever
- 10:34happens
- 10:35to
- 10:35be
- 10:35going
- 10:35on
- 10:36in
- 10:36the
- 10:37moment.
- 10:39And
- 10:39yet
- 10:39I
- 10:40do
- 10:40appreciate,
- 10:40Colette,
- 10:41what
- 10:41you're
- 10:41saying
- 10:42about.
- 10:43In
- 10:43order
- 10:43to
- 10:45have
- 10:45empathy
- 10:47for
- 10:47someone
- 10:48else
- 10:48who
- 10:48is
- 10:48having
- 10:49difficulty,
- 10:50it's.
- 10:53Really
- 10:54important
- 10:54to
- 10:54have
- 10:55had
- 10:55some
- 10:55difficulty
- 10:56yourself.
- 10:58Is
- 10:58that,
- 10:58is
- 10:58that
- 10:58what
- 10:59you're
- 10:59saying?
- 10:59Yeah.
- 11:01Okay.
- 11:03What
- 11:03do
- 11:03you
- 11:03think,
- 11:04Andrew?
- 11:07Well,
- 11:08so
- 11:08where
- 11:08I
- 11:09disagree
- 11:09is.
- 11:13A.
- 11:13Lot
- 11:14of
- 11:14that
- 11:14conversation
- 11:14is
- 11:15framed
- 11:15around
- 11:16what
- 11:16our
- 11:17lives
- 11:17currently
- 11:17are
- 11:18and
- 11:18not,
- 11:18I
- 11:19think,
- 11:19what
- 11:19they
- 11:19could
- 11:20be.
- 11:20And
- 11:21so.
- 11:26As
- 11:27hopefully,
- 11:28as,
- 11:28as
- 11:29most
- 11:29of
- 11:29human
- 11:30history
- 11:30has
- 11:30shown,
- 11:30people
- 11:31are
- 11:31generally
- 11:31trying
- 11:31to
- 11:32build
- 11:32a
- 11:32better
- 11:32future
- 11:33for
- 11:33the
- 11:33next
- 11:33generation.
- 11:33And
- 11:34so
- 11:34at
- 11:34some
- 11:34point.
- 11:37As
- 11:37long
- 11:38as
- 11:38we
- 11:38don't
- 11:38go
- 11:38extinct
- 11:39and
- 11:39as
- 11:39long
- 11:39as
- 11:40we
- 11:40that
- 11:40keeps
- 11:40holding,
- 11:41there
- 11:41will
- 11:41be,
- 11:41and
- 11:42I
- 11:42have
- 11:42no
- 11:42reason
- 11:42to
- 11:42believe
- 11:43we
- 11:43will
- 11:43go
- 11:43extinct
- 11:44anytime
- 11:45soon.
- 11:47Then
- 11:48I.
- 11:49There,
- 11:49there
- 11:50will
- 11:50come
- 11:50a
- 11:50point
- 11:50where
- 11:51the,
- 11:52the
- 11:53amount
- 11:53of
- 11:54bad
- 11:55things
- 11:56will,
- 11:57will
- 11:58reach
- 11:58an
- 11:58equilibrium.
- 11:59There
- 11:59will
- 11:59be
- 11:59like,
- 12:01yet
- 12:01the.
- 12:01Yes,
- 12:02there
- 12:02will
- 12:02be
- 12:02sometimes
- 12:03bad
- 12:03parents
- 12:04that
- 12:04don't
- 12:04get
- 12:04caught.
- 12:06And
- 12:07there
- 12:07will
- 12:07be
- 12:07some
- 12:08natural
- 12:08disasters
- 12:09that.
- 12:12We
- 12:12just
- 12:12don't
- 12:12see
- 12:12coming.
- 12:14But.
- 12:16We
- 12:16will
- 12:17reach
- 12:17a
- 12:17point
- 12:17where
- 12:19we
- 12:19have
- 12:19minimized
- 12:21suffering
- 12:22and
- 12:22there
- 12:23will
- 12:23be
- 12:23a
- 12:23large
- 12:24majority
- 12:24of
- 12:25the
- 12:25planet
- 12:25that
- 12:25does
- 12:25not
- 12:26have
- 12:26suffering.
- 12:27I
- 12:27mean,
- 12:27in
- 12:28the
- 12:28sense
- 12:28that
- 12:28we
- 12:28have
- 12:28today.
- 12:29I
- 12:29mean
- 12:29you
- 12:29just
- 12:30look
- 12:30at
- 12:30compared
- 12:30today
- 12:31to
- 12:31300
- 12:31years
- 12:32ago,
- 12:33right?
- 12:33Just,
- 12:33just
- 12:34for
- 12:34modern
- 12:34medicine,
- 12:34for
- 12:35example.
- 12:35And
- 12:35so.
- 12:38But
- 12:38the
- 12:38reason
- 12:38we
- 12:39developed
- 12:39the
- 12:39modern
- 12:39medicine
- 12:40is
- 12:40because
- 12:40we
- 12:40didn't
- 12:41like
- 12:41the
- 12:41way
- 12:41that
- 12:41we
- 12:41were
- 12:42dying.
- 12:43We
- 12:44didn't
- 12:44like
- 12:44the
- 12:44way
- 12:44we
- 12:45were.
- 12:45We
- 12:45were
- 12:45living
- 12:46either.
- 12:47And
- 12:48so
- 12:48the
- 12:48living
- 12:48is
- 12:48the
- 12:49experience
- 12:49of
- 12:50the
- 12:50suffering
- 12:50is
- 12:51going
- 12:51through
- 12:51stuff
- 12:52with
- 12:52scarlet
- 12:53fever
- 12:53and
- 12:54cholera,
- 12:54etc.
- 12:55And.
- 12:58So
- 12:58clearly
- 12:59there
- 12:59is
- 13:00suffering
- 13:01that
- 13:01we
- 13:01want
- 13:01to
- 13:01engineer
- 13:02out
- 13:02of
- 13:02society.
- 13:03And.
- 13:06Why
- 13:07should
- 13:07we
- 13:07stop
- 13:08it
- 13:08at
- 13:08any
- 13:08point?
- 13:09Why,
- 13:09why
- 13:09do
- 13:10we
- 13:10have.
- 13:12I
- 13:12remember
- 13:12one
- 13:12of
- 13:12the
- 13:13things
- 13:13we
- 13:13were
- 13:13talking
- 13:13about
- 13:13when
- 13:13we
- 13:14were
- 13:14on
- 13:14the
- 13:14grass
- 13:14talking
- 13:15about
- 13:15this
- 13:16is.
- 13:19One
- 13:19of
- 13:19the
- 13:19things
- 13:20that
- 13:20came
- 13:20up
- 13:20was
- 13:20like
- 13:20ice
- 13:21cream
- 13:21flavors,
- 13:21you
- 13:21know,
- 13:22like,
- 13:22well,
- 13:22I'll
- 13:23always,
- 13:23you
- 13:24know,
- 13:24I
- 13:24don't,
- 13:24I
- 13:25don't
- 13:25have
- 13:25to
- 13:25like,
- 13:25in
- 13:26order
- 13:26to
- 13:26have
- 13:26that
- 13:26perfect
- 13:27life.
- 13:27I
- 13:27don't
- 13:27have
- 13:27to
- 13:27have
- 13:28ice
- 13:28cream
- 13:28every
- 13:28day
- 13:28or
- 13:29whatever,
- 13:29but
- 13:29I'll
- 13:30always
- 13:30choose
- 13:30flavors
- 13:31I
- 13:31like.
- 13:32And
- 13:33people
- 13:33are
- 13:34saying
- 13:34like,
- 13:34well,
- 13:35what
- 13:35if
- 13:35you
- 13:35always
- 13:36have
- 13:36your
- 13:37favorite
- 13:37flavor?
- 13:37You
- 13:37know,
- 13:37you'll
- 13:38never
- 13:38know
- 13:38what
- 13:38bad
- 13:38ice
- 13:39cream
- 13:39is.
- 13:39Like.
- 13:39It
- 13:39was
- 13:39like,
- 13:40I
- 13:41don't
- 13:41need
- 13:41to
- 13:41have
- 13:42had
- 13:42bad
- 13:43ice
- 13:43cream
- 13:43to
- 13:44still
- 13:44like
- 13:44the
- 13:44ice
- 13:45cream
- 13:45that
- 13:45I
- 13:45like.
- 13:46You
- 13:46know,
- 13:47why,
- 13:48why
- 13:48do
- 13:49I
- 13:49have
- 13:49to
- 13:50taste,
- 13:52you
- 13:52know,
- 13:52like
- 13:53shoe
- 13:53flavored
- 13:54ice
- 13:54cream
- 13:55once
- 13:55in
- 13:55my
- 13:55life,
- 13:56you
- 13:56know,
- 13:57in
- 13:57order
- 13:57to
- 13:57know
- 13:58that
- 13:58I
- 13:58like
- 13:58chocolate?
- 13:58I
- 13:59don't
- 13:59have
- 13:59to.
- 14:01I'm
- 14:01thinking
- 14:02about
- 14:02all
- 14:02the
- 14:02jelly
- 14:02beans
- 14:03that
- 14:03Harry
- 14:04Potter
- 14:04was
- 14:04getting.
- 14:05Exactly.
- 14:06You
- 14:06know,
- 14:07we
- 14:07have
- 14:07to
- 14:07take
- 14:08a
- 14:08short
- 14:08break.
- 14:09I
- 14:09want
- 14:09to
- 14:09end
- 14:10this
- 14:10particular
- 14:11section
- 14:12with
- 14:12a.
- 14:13With
- 14:13a
- 14:13poem
- 14:15about
- 14:15anti
- 14:16fragility.
- 14:17So
- 14:18it
- 14:18goes
- 14:18like
- 14:19this.
- 14:20Since
- 14:20my
- 14:21house
- 14:21burnt
- 14:22down,
- 14:22I
- 14:23now
- 14:23have
- 14:23a
- 14:24much
- 14:24better
- 14:24view
- 14:25of
- 14:25the
- 14:25rising
- 14:26moon.
- 14:29So
- 14:29we
- 14:29have
- 14:29to
- 14:29take
- 14:30a
- 14:30short
- 14:30break
- 14:30and
- 14:31we'll
- 14:31be
- 14:31right
- 14:31back.
- 14:32So
- 14:32stay
- 14:32tuned.
- 14:49I'm
- 14:49Anthony
- 14:50Wright
- 14:50and
- 14:50I
- 14:51am
- 14:51your
- 14:51co
- 14:52host
- 14:52today
- 14:52with
- 14:54Adam
- 14:54Deeds.
- 14:55And
- 14:56Adam
- 14:56and
- 14:57I
- 14:57are
- 14:58co
- 14:58hosting
- 14:59a
- 14:59show
- 14:59that
- 14:59we
- 14:59are
- 14:59calling
- 15:00the
- 15:00Living
- 15:00Conversation.
- 15:01And
- 15:01today
- 15:02our
- 15:02guests
- 15:03are
- 15:04members
- 15:04of
- 15:05the
- 15:05Sonoma
- 15:06State
- 15:06University
- 15:06Philosophy
- 15:07Club.
- 15:08And
- 15:09welcome
- 15:09Colette,
- 15:10who
- 15:10is
- 15:10the
- 15:10president,
- 15:11and
- 15:11Andrew
- 15:11and
- 15:12Peter.
- 15:13And
- 15:13before
- 15:13the
- 15:14break,
- 15:14we
- 15:14were
- 15:14talking.
- 15:15About.
- 15:18I
- 15:19ended
- 15:19the
- 15:19last
- 15:20segment
- 15:20with
- 15:20this
- 15:20idea
- 15:21of
- 15:21antifragility.
- 15:23And
- 15:23do
- 15:24you
- 15:24know
- 15:24what
- 15:24I
- 15:24mean
- 15:24by
- 15:25that,
- 15:25you
- 15:25guys?
- 15:27A
- 15:27sense
- 15:28of
- 15:28that.
- 15:29You
- 15:29could
- 15:29explain
- 15:30it.
- 15:30Okay.
- 15:31It's
- 15:32more
- 15:32about
- 15:33that
- 15:33when
- 15:34adversity
- 15:35strikes
- 15:36that
- 15:37actually
- 15:38the.
- 15:40Working
- 15:41through
- 15:41the
- 15:42adversity
- 15:42only
- 15:43makes
- 15:43you
- 15:43stronger.
- 15:45So
- 15:45the
- 15:45example
- 15:46I
- 15:46gave
- 15:46was
- 15:46the
- 15:46poem
- 15:47about
- 15:47since
- 15:48my
- 15:48house
- 15:48burnt
- 15:49down,
- 15:49I
- 15:50now
- 15:50have
- 15:50a
- 15:50better
- 15:51view
- 15:52of
- 15:52the
- 15:52rising
- 15:52moon.
- 15:53And
- 15:53it's
- 15:53to
- 15:54reframe
- 15:55that
- 15:56adversity.
- 15:56Is
- 15:57that
- 15:57what
- 15:57your
- 15:57experience
- 15:57is,
- 15:58Colette?
- 15:59And
- 15:59understand
- 16:00that's
- 16:00actually
- 16:00exactly
- 16:01where
- 16:01I
- 16:01was
- 16:01going
- 16:02to
- 16:02go
- 16:02next
- 16:02with
- 16:03this
- 16:03conversation.
- 16:05Yeah.
- 16:06Because
- 16:06I
- 16:06like.
- 16:07Okay,
- 16:09I
- 16:09really
- 16:09like
- 16:10the
- 16:10phrase
- 16:10pressure
- 16:11makes
- 16:11diamonds.
- 16:12And
- 16:12I
- 16:13think
- 16:13it's
- 16:13true.
- 16:14Yeah.
- 16:16Like,
- 16:17what
- 16:17was
- 16:17the
- 16:18example
- 16:18I
- 16:18was
- 16:18thinking
- 16:19of?
- 16:22Because
- 16:23it's
- 16:23not
- 16:23all
- 16:24about,
- 16:24like,
- 16:25what
- 16:25your
- 16:26favorite
- 16:26ice
- 16:27cream
- 16:27flavor
- 16:27is
- 16:28or
- 16:28whatever,
- 16:29you
- 16:29know,
- 16:30okay,
- 16:30we
- 16:30always
- 16:30like
- 16:31to,
- 16:31to
- 16:31pick
- 16:31sides
- 16:32and,
- 16:32you
- 16:32know,
- 16:32it's
- 16:33all
- 16:33just
- 16:33good
- 16:33fun.
- 16:34Never
- 16:34any
- 16:35devils
- 16:36advocating
- 16:37too
- 16:37much.
- 16:38But.
- 16:39Like,
- 16:41you
- 16:41know,
- 16:41it,
- 16:42it's,
- 16:43it's
- 16:43never,
- 16:44it's
- 16:44never
- 16:45as
- 16:45simple
- 16:45as
- 16:45an
- 16:46ice
- 16:46cream
- 16:46flavor.
- 16:47It's
- 16:47usually
- 16:47a
- 16:47lot
- 16:47more
- 16:48than
- 16:48that.
- 16:48And
- 16:48so
- 16:49I
- 16:49think
- 16:49we
- 16:50need
- 16:50to
- 16:50redefine
- 16:52suffering
- 16:52as
- 16:53a
- 16:53term
- 16:54that
- 16:54we're
- 16:54using
- 16:54maybe
- 16:55because,
- 16:56like.
- 16:58Suffering
- 16:59in
- 17:00the
- 17:00context
- 17:01of
- 17:01ice
- 17:01cream
- 17:02is,
- 17:02is
- 17:03not
- 17:03too
- 17:03bad.
- 17:04You
- 17:04know,
- 17:04like,
- 17:04oh,
- 17:05dang,
- 17:05you
- 17:05get
- 17:05a
- 17:06bad
- 17:06flavor.
- 17:07Like,
- 17:07know
- 17:07your
- 17:08day
- 17:08is
- 17:08not
- 17:08completely
- 17:09ruined.
- 17:11And
- 17:11it
- 17:11can
- 17:11be
- 17:12the
- 17:12same
- 17:12thing.
- 17:13You
- 17:13can
- 17:13apply
- 17:13that
- 17:14same
- 17:14mentality
- 17:15to
- 17:15other,
- 17:16like,
- 17:17places
- 17:18of
- 17:18suffering.
- 17:19Like
- 17:20how
- 17:20Peter
- 17:21was
- 17:21talking
- 17:21about
- 17:22different
- 17:23job
- 17:23opportunities
- 17:24or.
- 17:26Different,
- 17:27different
- 17:27school
- 17:28opportunities
- 17:29too.
- 17:29You
- 17:30know,
- 17:30you
- 17:30have
- 17:30to
- 17:31have
- 17:31that
- 17:32element
- 17:32of
- 17:33suffering
- 17:34in
- 17:34order
- 17:34to
- 17:35perform
- 17:36better
- 17:36in
- 17:37school
- 17:37and
- 17:37to
- 17:38advance
- 17:38further
- 17:39so
- 17:39that
- 17:39you
- 17:39have
- 17:39the
- 17:40opportunity
- 17:40to
- 17:40learn
- 17:41more
- 17:41things.
- 17:41You
- 17:41know,
- 17:42there's,
- 17:42there's
- 17:42levels
- 17:43to,
- 17:43to
- 17:44getting
- 17:44there.
- 17:45And
- 17:45so,
- 17:45you
- 17:46know,
- 17:46you
- 17:46could
- 17:46look
- 17:47at
- 17:47it
- 17:47as
- 17:47suffering
- 17:49in
- 17:49that.
- 17:49Like,
- 17:50you
- 17:50know,
- 17:50oh,
- 17:51dang,
- 17:51I've
- 17:51got
- 17:51to
- 17:51do
- 17:51all
- 17:51this
- 17:52homework.
- 17:52I
- 17:52got
- 17:52to
- 17:53read
- 17:53all
- 17:53these
- 17:53books.
- 17:54There's
- 17:54so
- 17:54much
- 17:54to
- 17:54do.
- 17:55And
- 17:55that's,
- 17:55in
- 17:55a
- 17:56way,
- 17:56in
- 17:57a
- 17:57way
- 17:57that's
- 17:57suffering.
- 17:58But
- 17:59so,
- 18:00like,
- 18:01like,
- 18:01even
- 18:01though
- 18:01it
- 18:01is
- 18:02suffering.
- 18:04You
- 18:04could
- 18:04redefine
- 18:05it
- 18:05in
- 18:05your
- 18:05mind
- 18:06and,
- 18:06and
- 18:06just,
- 18:07like,
- 18:07the
- 18:07poem
- 18:07that
- 18:08you're
- 18:08talking
- 18:08about,
- 18:09professor,
- 18:10like,
- 18:10if
- 18:10you,
- 18:11if
- 18:11you
- 18:11reframe
- 18:12it,
- 18:12like,
- 18:13like,
- 18:13yeah,
- 18:13it's,
- 18:14it's
- 18:14a
- 18:14little
- 18:14bit
- 18:14of
- 18:14suffering,
- 18:15but
- 18:15I
- 18:15know
- 18:15I'm
- 18:15gonna
- 18:15get
- 18:16something
- 18:16good
- 18:16out
- 18:16of
- 18:16it
- 18:17eventually.
- 18:17Then
- 18:18it's
- 18:18like,
- 18:18good
- 18:19suffering,
- 18:20if
- 18:20that
- 18:20makes
- 18:20sense.
- 18:21Good
- 18:21suffering.
- 18:23My
- 18:24goodness.
- 18:24Do
- 18:24you
- 18:24think
- 18:26does
- 18:27if.
- 18:29If
- 18:29someone
- 18:30like
- 18:30Elon
- 18:30Musk
- 18:31doesn't
- 18:31make
- 18:31as
- 18:31much
- 18:32money
- 18:32as
- 18:32he
- 18:32wants
- 18:33to,
- 18:33does
- 18:33he
- 18:33suffer.
- 18:36From
- 18:37his
- 18:37perspective?
- 18:37Yeah.
- 18:40But.
- 18:42Okay,
- 18:43so,
- 18:43so
- 18:45there's
- 18:45many
- 18:45things
- 18:46that
- 18:46I
- 18:46want
- 18:46that
- 18:46I
- 18:47don't
- 18:47get,
- 18:47you
- 18:47know?
- 18:48Like,
- 18:48and
- 18:49are
- 18:49you,
- 18:49do
- 18:49you
- 18:49suffer?
- 18:51It
- 18:52depends
- 18:53on
- 18:53the
- 18:53thing.
- 18:53Like,
- 18:54there
- 18:54are
- 18:54things
- 18:54that
- 18:54I
- 18:54want
- 18:55that
- 18:55are,
- 18:55like,
- 18:56just
- 18:57unrealistically
- 18:58out
- 18:58of
- 18:58reach.
- 18:58So
- 18:58there's
- 18:58no
- 18:58emotional
- 18:59attachment
- 18:59to,
- 19:00like,
- 19:00not
- 19:00being
- 19:00able
- 19:00to
- 19:00get
- 19:01it.
- 19:01Okay,
- 19:02so
- 19:02it's
- 19:02like,
- 19:03does
- 19:04that
- 19:04make
- 19:04sense?
- 19:04Suffering
- 19:05has
- 19:05an
- 19:05emotional
- 19:06attachment
- 19:06to
- 19:06it.
- 19:08Well,
- 19:08yeah,
- 19:09I
- 19:09think
- 19:09by
- 19:09definition,
- 19:10because
- 19:10suffering
- 19:10is.
- 19:13It'S
- 19:13an
- 19:14experience
- 19:14of
- 19:15something
- 19:15that
- 19:15I
- 19:16don't
- 19:16want.
- 19:16I
- 19:16don't
- 19:16want
- 19:17to
- 19:17have
- 19:17this
- 19:17emotion.
- 19:19So
- 19:20I,
- 19:20I,
- 19:22I,
- 19:22I
- 19:22think
- 19:23that's
- 19:24just
- 19:24definitionally
- 19:26true
- 19:26or
- 19:26close
- 19:27to
- 19:27how
- 19:27I
- 19:27would
- 19:27define
- 19:27suffering
- 19:28is,
- 19:28is
- 19:28a
- 19:28feeling
- 19:29I
- 19:29do
- 19:29not
- 19:30want
- 19:31to
- 19:31experience.
- 19:33Okay.
- 19:34So
- 19:35it's
- 19:36not
- 19:36always,
- 19:36Always
- 19:37an.
- 19:38Does
- 19:38that
- 19:38always
- 19:38have
- 19:39an
- 19:39emotional
- 19:39component
- 19:40to
- 19:40it?
- 19:42I
- 19:42would
- 19:42say
- 19:42it
- 19:43fundamentally
- 19:43has
- 19:43to.
- 19:44Okay.
- 19:45Because
- 19:45I,
- 19:45I
- 19:46don't
- 19:46see
- 19:46how
- 19:47I
- 19:47could
- 19:47experience
- 19:48suffering
- 19:48and
- 19:49not
- 19:49have
- 19:49an
- 19:49emotional
- 19:50attachment
- 19:50to
- 19:50it.
- 19:51It,
- 19:51It.
- 19:52Because
- 19:53I
- 19:53wonder
- 19:53if
- 19:53people
- 19:53have
- 19:54an
- 19:54emotional
- 19:54attachment
- 19:55to
- 19:56not
- 19:56having
- 19:56enough
- 19:56to
- 19:57eat.
- 19:57For
- 19:57example,
- 19:58do
- 19:58you
- 19:58feel
- 19:59bad
- 20:00emotionally.
- 20:02Poorly.
- 20:04If
- 20:04you're
- 20:04hungry.
- 20:06Yeah.
- 20:06Or
- 20:07if
- 20:07you're
- 20:07injured
- 20:09or
- 20:10some
- 20:10other
- 20:10adverse
- 20:11condition,
- 20:12you're
- 20:12smiling
- 20:13at
- 20:13them.
- 20:13What
- 20:13do
- 20:13you,
- 20:14what
- 20:14do
- 20:14you
- 20:14have?
- 20:15Like,
- 20:16I
- 20:16like
- 20:16that
- 20:16Linder
- 20:16said.
- 20:17Yeah.
- 20:17He's
- 20:17like,
- 20:17yeah,
- 20:18I
- 20:18agree.
- 20:18I
- 20:18agree,
- 20:19Andrew.
- 20:19Yeah,
- 20:20you
- 20:21don't
- 20:21feel
- 20:21good
- 20:22about
- 20:22it.
- 20:22But
- 20:23I
- 20:23want
- 20:24to.
- 20:27Touch
- 20:27on
- 20:27something
- 20:27Colette
- 20:28was
- 20:28saying,
- 20:28and
- 20:28Andrew
- 20:29was
- 20:29kind
- 20:29of
- 20:29building
- 20:29off
- 20:30of
- 20:30this
- 20:30idea
- 20:31of
- 20:31good
- 20:31suffering.
- 20:34When
- 20:34I
- 20:34was
- 20:34a
- 20:34teenager,
- 20:36I
- 20:36was
- 20:36immature,
- 20:37and
- 20:38I
- 20:38was
- 20:38very
- 20:38attached
- 20:39to
- 20:40girls.
- 20:42So
- 20:43everything
- 20:43was
- 20:44heartsick
- 20:44puppy
- 20:45love
- 20:45all
- 20:45the
- 20:45time
- 20:46and
- 20:47was
- 20:47really
- 20:47suffering,
- 20:48suffering.
- 20:51So
- 20:51I
- 20:51made
- 20:51an
- 20:52effort
- 20:52to.
- 20:53I
- 20:53finally
- 20:53got,
- 20:53I
- 20:54got
- 20:54sick
- 20:54of
- 20:54being
- 20:54sick.
- 20:55Lao
- 20:55has
- 20:56a,
- 20:56has
- 20:56a
- 20:56line
- 20:57in
- 20:57the
- 20:57Dao
- 20:57De
- 20:57Ching,
- 20:58when
- 20:58you're
- 20:58sick
- 20:58of
- 20:58being
- 20:59sick,
- 20:59then
- 20:59you
- 20:59can.
- 20:59Then
- 21:00you
- 21:00can
- 21:01advance.
- 21:01So
- 21:02I
- 21:02was
- 21:02sick
- 21:02of
- 21:02being
- 21:03lovesick.
- 21:03I
- 21:03was
- 21:03sick
- 21:04of
- 21:04having
- 21:04this
- 21:04suffering.
- 21:05So
- 21:05I
- 21:05actually
- 21:06went
- 21:06out
- 21:06and
- 21:07one
- 21:08of
- 21:08the
- 21:08first
- 21:08places
- 21:08I
- 21:08drove
- 21:09to
- 21:09on
- 21:09my
- 21:09own,
- 21:09without
- 21:10any.
- 21:12Impetus,
- 21:13just
- 21:13on
- 21:13my
- 21:13own,
- 21:13was
- 21:14to
- 21:14go
- 21:14to
- 21:14the
- 21:14city
- 21:15library.
- 21:15Back
- 21:15before
- 21:16I'm
- 21:16so
- 21:16old,
- 21:16we
- 21:17didn't
- 21:17have
- 21:17Internet
- 21:17really,
- 21:18back
- 21:18then.
- 21:18So
- 21:19I
- 21:19went
- 21:19to
- 21:19the
- 21:19city
- 21:20library
- 21:20and
- 21:20looked
- 21:21up
- 21:21books
- 21:21on
- 21:21Buddhism
- 21:22and
- 21:22thought,
- 21:22I'm
- 21:23sick
- 21:23of
- 21:23being
- 21:23sick.
- 21:24I
- 21:24want
- 21:24to
- 21:24try
- 21:24and
- 21:24get
- 21:25out
- 21:25of
- 21:25this.
- 21:25This
- 21:25pattern,
- 21:27right?
- 21:27And,
- 21:28you
- 21:28know,
- 21:28that
- 21:28that
- 21:28was
- 21:28okay.
- 21:29It
- 21:29didn't
- 21:29really
- 21:29go
- 21:30anywhere,
- 21:30but
- 21:30over
- 21:30the
- 21:31years,
- 21:31it
- 21:32was
- 21:32a
- 21:32seed
- 21:33that
- 21:33kept
- 21:33building
- 21:33and
- 21:33building
- 21:34and
- 21:34building
- 21:34and
- 21:34building.
- 21:35So
- 21:35if
- 21:35I
- 21:36look
- 21:36at
- 21:36that
- 21:36example
- 21:37from
- 21:37when
- 21:37I
- 21:38was
- 21:38a
- 21:38teenager
- 21:38and
- 21:38I
- 21:38really
- 21:39did
- 21:39feel
- 21:39like
- 21:39I
- 21:39was
- 21:39suffering.
- 21:40And
- 21:41then
- 21:41I
- 21:41fast
- 21:41forward
- 21:42to
- 21:42a
- 21:42few
- 21:42years
- 21:42ago
- 21:43when
- 21:43I
- 21:43had
- 21:43a
- 21:43death
- 21:43in
- 21:44the
- 21:44family,
- 21:45very
- 21:45close
- 21:45family
- 21:46member.
- 21:47And
- 21:48this.
- 21:49Yes,
- 21:49I
- 21:50was
- 21:50mourning.
- 21:50Yes,
- 21:51I
- 21:51was
- 21:51crying.
- 21:52Yes,
- 21:53I
- 21:53was,
- 21:54you
- 21:55know,
- 21:56dealing
- 21:56with
- 21:57my
- 21:57other
- 21:57family
- 21:57members.
- 21:58But
- 21:58there
- 21:58was
- 21:59a
- 21:59joy
- 21:59in
- 22:00doing
- 22:00it
- 22:00right.
- 22:01You
- 22:01know,
- 22:02you're
- 22:03feeling
- 22:04this
- 22:04sadness,
- 22:05and
- 22:05you
- 22:06should
- 22:06be
- 22:06feeling
- 22:06it,
- 22:07and
- 22:07you
- 22:07can
- 22:07embrace
- 22:07it
- 22:08and
- 22:08fully
- 22:08feel
- 22:09it.
- 22:09And
- 22:09there
- 22:10was
- 22:10a
- 22:10joy
- 22:10in
- 22:11that.
- 22:12So
- 22:12I
- 22:12think
- 22:13that
- 22:13that's
- 22:13an
- 22:14example
- 22:14of
- 22:14having.
- 22:16Some
- 22:17suffering.
- 22:18But
- 22:18you
- 22:18have
- 22:18the
- 22:19perspective
- 22:20and
- 22:20you
- 22:20can
- 22:20really
- 22:21lean
- 22:21into
- 22:21it.
- 22:22And
- 22:22yes,
- 22:23it
- 22:23did
- 22:23make
- 22:23me
- 22:24much
- 22:24more.
- 22:26I
- 22:26want
- 22:27to
- 22:27say
- 22:27I
- 22:27developed
- 22:28from
- 22:28that
- 22:28you
- 22:28were
- 22:28talking
- 22:28about
- 22:29before,
- 22:29that
- 22:30you
- 22:30need
- 22:30suffering
- 22:30to
- 22:30develop.
- 22:31Well,
- 22:31I
- 22:32did
- 22:32because
- 22:33it
- 22:33was
- 22:33such
- 22:33a
- 22:33strong
- 22:33emotion.
- 22:34I
- 22:35did
- 22:35experience
- 22:36it.
- 22:37I
- 22:37did
- 22:37feel
- 22:37like
- 22:37I
- 22:37developed
- 22:38and
- 22:38grew
- 22:38as
- 22:39a
- 22:39person.
- 22:39But
- 22:40there
- 22:40was
- 22:40joy
- 22:41through
- 22:41the
- 22:41whole
- 22:42process.
- 22:42Deep
- 22:42inside
- 22:43I
- 22:43could
- 22:43see,
- 22:44yes,
- 22:44I'm
- 22:44crying.
- 22:45I'm
- 22:45choosing
- 22:46to
- 22:46cry.
- 22:46I'm
- 22:46choosing
- 22:47to
- 22:47mourn.
- 22:48I
- 22:48feel
- 22:48more
- 22:48connected
- 22:49to
- 22:49the
- 22:49person
- 22:49that
- 22:50I'm
- 22:50mourning.
- 22:51I
- 22:51feel
- 22:51like
- 22:51it's
- 22:52appropriate.
- 22:52And
- 22:53then
- 22:53over,
- 22:53of
- 22:53course,
- 22:53over
- 22:54time,
- 22:54those
- 22:54feelings
- 22:55lessen.
- 22:56But
- 22:56when
- 22:56I
- 22:56feel
- 22:56like
- 22:57when
- 22:57you're
- 22:57doing
- 22:57things
- 22:58that
- 22:58are
- 22:58appropriate
- 22:58and
- 22:59harmonious
- 22:59with
- 22:59your
- 22:59circumstances,
- 23:00there's
- 23:01joy
- 23:02deep
- 23:02within
- 23:02that.
- 23:04I
- 23:05think
- 23:05that
- 23:05just
- 23:06describes
- 23:07the
- 23:07whole,
- 23:07like,
- 23:08you
- 23:08need
- 23:08to
- 23:09let
- 23:09your
- 23:10emotions
- 23:11go
- 23:11free
- 23:12in
- 23:12order
- 23:12to,
- 23:13like,
- 23:13live
- 23:14them
- 23:14fully
- 23:14and.
- 23:15And
- 23:15move
- 23:15forward.
- 23:16Like,
- 23:16if
- 23:16you're
- 23:17feeling
- 23:17really
- 23:18terrible
- 23:18about
- 23:19something,
- 23:19you
- 23:19shouldn't
- 23:20box
- 23:20them
- 23:20up
- 23:21or
- 23:21bottle
- 23:21them
- 23:21up.
- 23:23You
- 23:23should
- 23:24really
- 23:24dig
- 23:25deep
- 23:25into
- 23:25it.
- 23:26And
- 23:26then
- 23:27in
- 23:27that
- 23:28process,
- 23:28you
- 23:28become.
- 23:30More.
- 23:31More
- 23:31whole.
- 23:32I
- 23:32want
- 23:32to
- 23:32say,
- 23:33like,
- 23:33more
- 23:33human.
- 23:34Yeah.
- 23:36By
- 23:36doing
- 23:36that
- 23:36really
- 23:37makes
- 23:37sense.
- 23:38I
- 23:38do
- 23:38think
- 23:39that
- 23:39there
- 23:39might
- 23:40be
- 23:40some
- 23:41biopsychological
- 23:42reasons
- 23:43we
- 23:43might
- 23:43have
- 23:43even
- 23:43evolved
- 23:44to
- 23:44feel
- 23:44these
- 23:45momentary
- 23:46states.
- 23:47And
- 23:47I
- 23:47really
- 23:48do
- 23:48think
- 23:48that
- 23:48if
- 23:49we
- 23:49experience
- 23:49them
- 23:50in
- 23:50the
- 23:50moment,
- 23:50then
- 23:51we're
- 23:52able
- 23:52to
- 23:52figure
- 23:52out
- 23:53ways
- 23:53we
- 23:53can
- 23:54improve
- 23:54our
- 23:55current
- 23:55circumstances.
- 23:56So
- 23:56then
- 23:57we
- 23:57can
- 23:57improve.
- 23:58Alleviate
- 23:58those
- 23:59temporary
- 23:59states
- 24:00and.
- 24:02Improve
- 24:02it
- 24:03so
- 24:03that
- 24:03we
- 24:03can
- 24:04move
- 24:04on
- 24:04from
- 24:04it.
- 24:05So
- 24:05they
- 24:05could
- 24:05be
- 24:06sort
- 24:06of
- 24:06like
- 24:07signifiers
- 24:08that
- 24:08we
- 24:09evolved
- 24:10with
- 24:10to
- 24:10help
- 24:10us
- 24:12develop
- 24:12from
- 24:12our
- 24:13temporary
- 24:13states.
- 24:15Interesting.
- 24:16I
- 24:16have
- 24:16a
- 24:16new
- 24:16idea,
- 24:17if
- 24:17that's
- 24:18okay.
- 24:19My
- 24:19new
- 24:20idea
- 24:20is.
- 24:22I
- 24:22think
- 24:24my
- 24:24generation
- 24:25is
- 24:26getting
- 24:26really
- 24:27good
- 24:27at
- 24:28digging
- 24:28into
- 24:29some
- 24:29emotions
- 24:29and
- 24:30not
- 24:30others,
- 24:31I
- 24:31think.
- 24:32And
- 24:32for
- 24:32example,
- 24:34I'm
- 24:34thinking
- 24:35about
- 24:35the
- 24:36horror
- 24:36film
- 24:37genre.
- 24:38I
- 24:38think
- 24:39that
- 24:39my
- 24:39generation
- 24:40is
- 24:40being,
- 24:41is,
- 24:42is
- 24:42training
- 24:43itself
- 24:43to
- 24:43be
- 24:44very
- 24:44good
- 24:44at
- 24:45responding
- 24:45to
- 24:46frightening
- 24:47things,
- 24:48but
- 24:48not
- 24:48very
- 24:48good
- 24:49at
- 24:49responding
- 24:50to
- 24:50sad
- 24:51things.
- 24:52So
- 24:52they're,
- 24:52they're
- 24:53letting
- 24:53themselves
- 24:54be
- 24:54scared
- 24:55over
- 24:55and
- 24:56over
- 24:56every
- 24:56time
- 24:56they
- 24:56go
- 24:56see
- 24:57a
- 24:57new
- 24:57horror
- 24:57film.
- 24:58And
- 24:58then
- 24:59they
- 24:59are
- 25:01almost.
- 25:03Dimming
- 25:03their,
- 25:04their
- 25:04insides
- 25:05because
- 25:05of
- 25:05it.
- 25:06And
- 25:06so
- 25:06then
- 25:07they,
- 25:07they
- 25:07don't
- 25:07react
- 25:08as
- 25:08strongly
- 25:09the
- 25:09next
- 25:09time
- 25:09they
- 25:09see
- 25:09something
- 25:10scary.
- 25:10They're.
- 25:11I
- 25:12can't
- 25:12think
- 25:12of
- 25:12the
- 25:12word
- 25:12right
- 25:12now,
- 25:13but.
- 25:14And
- 25:15then
- 25:15like
- 25:15in
- 25:15contrast
- 25:16the.
- 25:16They're
- 25:17like
- 25:17really
- 25:18bad
- 25:18at
- 25:18dealing
- 25:19with
- 25:19their
- 25:19sadness.
- 25:22So
- 25:22that,
- 25:23that's
- 25:23my
- 25:23new
- 25:23thought.
- 25:26You
- 25:26know,
- 25:27one
- 25:27of
- 25:27the
- 25:27points
- 25:28that
- 25:28I
- 25:28recall
- 25:29in
- 25:29this
- 25:30context
- 25:31was
- 25:31that
- 25:32I
- 25:32was
- 25:32in
- 25:32a
- 25:32relationship
- 25:33in
- 25:332000.
- 25:35With
- 25:36a
- 25:36woman
- 25:36and
- 25:38after
- 25:38a
- 25:38very
- 25:38short
- 25:39time
- 25:40she
- 25:40left.
- 25:40And
- 25:40I
- 25:41was
- 25:41in
- 25:41grief
- 25:42for
- 25:42a
- 25:42long
- 25:43time.
- 25:43And
- 25:44part
- 25:44of
- 25:44the
- 25:45thing
- 25:45that
- 25:45I
- 25:45had
- 25:45learned
- 25:46about
- 25:46grief
- 25:47was
- 25:47the
- 25:48fastest
- 25:49way
- 25:49out
- 25:50of
- 25:50it
- 25:50was
- 25:50straight
- 25:51through
- 25:51it.
- 25:52And
- 25:53that
- 25:53was,
- 25:54that
- 25:54was
- 25:54very
- 25:54useful.
- 25:55And
- 25:55actually
- 25:56the
- 25:56end
- 25:56of
- 25:57it
- 25:57was
- 25:59this
- 25:59idea
- 25:59that
- 25:59I
- 26:00got
- 26:00from
- 26:00Alan
- 26:00Watts
- 26:01again.
- 26:04Was.
- 26:04And
- 26:05again
- 26:05to.
- 26:05To
- 26:06speak
- 26:07about
- 26:07it
- 26:07in
- 26:07a
- 26:08Zen
- 26:08Buddhist
- 26:09way.
- 26:09It's
- 26:09a
- 26:09mosquito
- 26:10biting
- 26:10an
- 26:10iron
- 26:11bull.
- 26:12And
- 26:12the
- 26:12mosquito
- 26:13has
- 26:13to
- 26:13bite
- 26:14and
- 26:14the
- 26:15iron
- 26:15bull
- 26:15can't
- 26:16be
- 26:16bitten.
- 26:17And
- 26:18the,
- 26:19that's
- 26:19the
- 26:19illusion
- 26:20of
- 26:20separateness,
- 26:20that
- 26:21I
- 26:21am
- 26:22me
- 26:22and
- 26:22you
- 26:22are
- 26:23you,
- 26:23and
- 26:23I
- 26:23want
- 26:24you
- 26:24and.
- 26:25But
- 26:26for
- 26:26some
- 26:26reason
- 26:26you
- 26:27don't
- 26:27want
- 26:27me.
- 26:27And.
- 26:28But
- 26:28wait,
- 26:29what's,
- 26:30what's
- 26:30the
- 26:31sum
- 26:31total
- 26:31of
- 26:32all
- 26:32this
- 26:32in
- 26:32a
- 26:32larger
- 26:33context?
- 26:34And
- 26:34it
- 26:35is
- 26:35just,
- 26:35oh,
- 26:36this
- 26:36is
- 26:36what
- 26:36the
- 26:36cosmos
- 26:37is
- 26:37doing
- 26:37here.
- 26:39So
- 26:39there
- 26:39isn't
- 26:39any
- 26:39separated
- 26:40Anthony
- 26:41or
- 26:42the
- 26:42person
- 26:43that
- 26:44I
- 26:44cared
- 26:44for.
- 26:45It
- 26:45was
- 26:45just
- 26:46that
- 26:46the
- 26:46cosmos
- 26:46was
- 26:47doing
- 26:47that.
- 26:49And,
- 26:49and
- 26:49that
- 26:49made
- 26:50it
- 26:51much
- 26:53more
- 26:54on.
- 26:58Comprehendable
- 26:59to
- 26:59me
- 27:00in
- 27:00that
- 27:01I
- 27:01could
- 27:01just
- 27:02let
- 27:02go
- 27:02and
- 27:02say,
- 27:03oh,
- 27:03okay,
- 27:04that's
- 27:04what
- 27:04the
- 27:04cosmos
- 27:05is
- 27:05doing.
- 27:08So
- 27:08the
- 27:08other
- 27:08thing
- 27:09that
- 27:09the
- 27:09cosmos
- 27:10is
- 27:10doing
- 27:10is
- 27:10that
- 27:10we
- 27:10have
- 27:11to
- 27:11take
- 27:11a
- 27:11short
- 27:11break.
- 27:12I'm
- 27:12Anthony
- 27:13Wright.
- 27:13And
- 27:13I
- 27:14am
- 27:14your
- 27:14co
- 27:14host
- 27:15today
- 27:15with
- 27:17Adam
- 27:17de.
- 27:18Adam
- 27:18Dees.
- 27:19And
- 27:19we
- 27:20are
- 27:20on
- 27:21the
- 27:22show
- 27:23that's
- 27:23called
- 27:23the
- 27:23Living
- 27:24Conversation
- 27:25with
- 27:25the
- 27:25Sonoma
- 27:26State
- 27:26University
- 27:27Philosophy
- 27:27Club.
- 27:28And
- 27:28how
- 27:28can
- 27:28people
- 27:29contact
- 27:29you
- 27:29guys?
- 27:31Yeah,
- 27:31so
- 27:31we're
- 27:31just
- 27:32on
- 27:32Instagram
- 27:33@SSU
- 27:34Philosophy
- 27:35Club.
- 27:35Check
- 27:35us
- 27:35out.
- 27:36Reach
- 27:36out
- 27:36anytime.
- 27:37And
- 27:37I'll
- 27:37be
- 27:37the
- 27:37one
- 27:37answering.
- 27:39Great.
- 27:40All
- 27:40right,
- 27:41we'll
- 27:41be.
- 27:41We'll
- 27:42take
- 27:42a
- 27:42short
- 27:42break
- 27:42and
- 27:42be
- 27:42right
- 27:43back,
- 27:43so
- 27:43stay
- 27:43tuned.