Latest / The Virtual Couch / Genuine Curiosity: Not All Questions Are Equal – Are You Trying to Understand, Defend, Manipulate, or Control?
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:22Welcome to another episode of Virtual Couch Presents. I am your host, Tony Overbay.
- 0:26I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist, certified mindful habit coach,
- 0:30writer, speaker, husband, father of four, and host of several podcasts about
- 0:34mental health, relationships, emotional maturity, navigating faith crisis,
- 0:38you name it, all those wonderful things.
- 0:39But today we're going to dive into a topic that I will guarantee,
- 0:44I'm not a big all or nothing guy, but I believe everyone has experienced this,
- 0:48whether you realize it or not.
- 0:49So here's a quick question to start us off. Have you ever been in a conversation
- 0:52where somebody asked you a question that the words were words that sounded like a question?
- 0:58And if you were writing this out, there would be a question mark at the end.
- 1:02Technically, it sounded like they were being curious, but something just felt off.
- 1:07Like maybe your partner said, so you really thought that outfit was a good choice
- 1:11for dinner with my parents?
- 1:12Or your boss asks, I'm very curious about why you would actually approach a
- 1:17client presentation like that and assume that they would like it,
- 1:21that they would appreciate it, or that you would get that deal.
- 1:24Or maybe it was something subtle, like a friend saying, so that's your opinion. That is fascinating.
- 1:29That is interesting, really. So that's honestly how you feel.
- 1:32Or one of my personal favorites, this one is guaranteed to not land well.
- 1:36So you already cleaned up this. So is this like what you call clean. So that kind of thing.
- 1:42That's what I want to talk about today. The difference between genuine curiosity
- 1:46and then performative or even defensive questioning.
- 1:51Because I see this so often in my work as a couples therapist and just as a human being.
- 1:56And I think that understanding and being genuinely curious can be a very big
- 2:02game changer in a relationship.
- 2:04Let me start with a story that I think taught me a lot about curiosity.
- 2:08And more about what it wasn't, it was many, many years ago.
- 2:12I was at one of my daughter's high school track meets. And at that point in
- 2:15my life, I won't say embarrassingly so, but I would say definitely so,
- 2:19my identity was pretty wrapped up in being a runner and not just a casual one.
- 2:24Now I realize what was I running from? But this is when I had run over 100 marathons
- 2:29and ultra marathons and done 24-hour fundraising events on the high school track
- 2:33to bring in money for the local schools.
- 2:36And I had competed in the famed Super Bowl of 100 milers, the Western States
- 2:41100 miler, which was kind of in my backyard at the time around Auburn,
- 2:46California, not once, not twice, but three times.
- 2:49And running wasn't just something that I did. It was really a part of who I was.
- 2:53Whenever I would interact with others, we would pretty much talk about running
- 2:56and I would even sometimes feign frustration of, oh my gosh,
- 3:00is that all that they want to talk about? But let me keep talking about it.
- 3:03But here I am, I'm standing on the infield of a track and I'm watching the events unfold.
- 3:07And a guy that I kind of knew, one of those that in small towns,
- 3:11you feel like you think, I've seen this guy around. I know who he is,
- 3:15but we've never really talked. We just give each other the head nod.
- 3:18And he comes up to me and our kids were both running and I thought,
- 3:21okay, this is cool. Here's a chance to connect.
- 3:23Now, while my identity was firmly planted in being a runner,
- 3:26I was also well into now my career as a therapist, which I truly believe saved my life.
- 3:32I can honestly say I believe that I was genuinely becoming more curious about people's experience.
- 3:37And I think that was part of this cognitive dissonance of my identity as a runner,
- 3:41but somewhat feeling annoyed that that was all we were going to talk about,
- 3:43but probably pretty insecure that I really wasn't exactly sure what else to
- 3:47talk about other than running.
- 3:48So I start by asking him about his son. How long has his son been running?
- 3:53What does he really enjoy? What kind of events he enjoys doing?
- 3:56Because his kid was a pretty good athlete. And then casually,
- 3:59I asked if this guy was a runner too.
- 4:01And he seemed a little bit more bulky, looked like more of a weightlifter.
- 4:05And so honestly, I didn't really know.
- 4:06And then he lit up and he told me, oh, I am a runner. And I did a lot of sprints in high school.
- 4:12I could have ran in college. I love that one. But I don't know,
- 4:15something got in the way. and he had done a couple of 10Ks, a half marathon,
- 4:20and he had tried one full marathon, but had gotten injured, wasn't his fault.
- 4:25Somebody had probably advised him incorrectly of training. I was genuinely curious about his story.
- 4:30And now I will be honest, at that point, there was probably a small part of
- 4:33me that then hoped he would ask me about my running because that was a big part of my identity.
- 4:39And he did acknowledge it because
- 4:41I know that he had been at my 24-hour fundraising events a time or two.
- 4:45And I think he had even ran around the track. People would come do that with
- 4:49their kids at odd hours of the night.
- 4:52And most of them would usually stop by, say hi, or I would run with him for
- 4:55a little bit, but he didn't. I remember he would stay on the opposite end of the track.
- 4:58But he did acknowledge that. He said, hey, I know you're a runner.
- 5:02And I thought, okay, here we go. This will be nice. And then he starts to give
- 5:06me a lot of running advice.
- 5:08Specifically, things that he had noticed when I was doing my 24-hour events
- 5:11when I had been running for 18 hours or so, 20 hours.
- 5:15And these were specific tips on fueling and then pacing.
- 5:18And then he started suggesting some things that I could probably do different
- 5:21in the longer ultra marathons.
- 5:23I thought to myself, so based on what? This is gonna sound egotistical for a moment, bear with me,
- 5:28but based on watching me from the other side of the track or maybe from the
- 5:32bleachers at those school fundraising runs, I don't really remember exactly
- 5:35what his advice was because I think I was so, I don't want to say blown away.
- 5:39It sounds so, so dramatic, but I think I was just so fascinated that that just
- 5:45didn't really make much sense to me that my brain kind of glitched.
- 5:48I think he named some sort of food that he thought might help me around hour
- 5:5120 of a 24 hour run. and I remember nodding and smiling and thought,
- 5:57okay, that would probably be one of the worst foods that I could eat.
- 6:00I don't remember what it was.
- 6:01I don't remember if it was, let's say that it was a curry or something like
- 6:04that, spicy curry, when in reality you're wanting bland bananas and then gels.
- 6:10And as he walked away, he said, this has been really nice. I've always wanted
- 6:15to pick your brain about running. And I remember thinking, okay,
- 6:19I don't think my brain was picked. I don't think that is what curiosity actually is.
- 6:23I wonder that feels more like an insecurity dressed up in a curiosity costume,
- 6:29or maybe that's some emotional immaturity, or that's a need for validation.
- 6:33And let me go on this tangent for a minute. Let's talk about insecurity.
- 6:37Perhaps, and I know I'm making assumptions, he may have been feeling a little
- 6:40unsure about his own running identity.
- 6:42And offering advice may have been his way of trying to level the playing field.
- 6:46So instead of asking about my experience, He presented himself as somebody who
- 6:50probably had something to teach me.
- 6:52Now, if we're talking about emotional immaturity, one of my favorite things these days,
- 6:55rather than being comfortable with his position as a learner,
- 6:58if he was truly interested in ultra marathons or someone who had his own experiences
- 7:02as a half marathoner or just basically as somebody who hasn't run ultras.
- 7:07Is, instead, he needed to show up with something to contribute,
- 7:10even if it meant assuming an expert role in a space that he wasn't trained in,
- 7:15which without knowing, I knew immediately based off the things he was saying
- 7:20that he honestly didn't know what he was talking about, which did not build
- 7:25trust or connection or emotional intimacy between he and I.
- 7:30If we look at this, like from a validation seeking standpoint,
- 7:32he might've been hoping that I would go, oh my gosh, I have not thought of spicy
- 7:36Indian curry at mile 80 when my stomach is already being really, really wild or odd.
- 7:43That sounds amazing. You've got great insights or some way to make him feel
- 7:46affirmed or maybe make him feel like he is an impressive individual. Here's the key though.
- 7:51None of those are genuinely curious. Genuine curiosity asks to understand.
- 7:57Not to be seen as smart or helpful.
- 7:59It's more rooted in openness, not in the outcome.
- 8:03And here's one of the big takeaways that we'll explore today.
- 8:06We're going to talk about emotions and all kinds of things. People feel that difference.
- 8:10There's a huge difference between asking somebody a question to understand and
- 8:14asking a question to defend yourself, to prove a point, to win an argument,
- 8:18or to tee yourself up so that then you can tell your stories.
- 8:22So let me go back to that. People feel the difference. They may not be able
- 8:26to put it into words, but their nervous system knows what's up because we are wired for connection.
- 8:31We're also wired to detect threats. And so even a question can feel like a threat
- 8:36if it's loaded with judgment or wrapped up in sarcasm.
- 8:39So back to this guy at the track meet, what he wasn't doing was being genuinely
- 8:43curious. He was asking questions.
- 8:45Again, they would have question marks after them, but it felt like more of just a setup to make a point.
- 8:50He was more of a, hey, let me show you what I know. then, hey,
- 8:53tell me what it's like to do what you've done.
- 8:55Now, as a therapist, especially when it works with couples, I'm even more aware of this dynamic.
- 8:59And lately I've been noticing what I'm almost looking at like a big old confirmation
- 9:03bias cocktail when it comes to how rarely we practice genuine curiosity in our relationships.
- 9:07We're just not that great at wondering about each other anymore.
- 9:11We're really good at talking, talking at someone, telling them what I think
- 9:15that they are feeling or thinking, great at advising, great at correcting, but pausing.
- 9:21Being genuinely curious, asking from a place of truly admitting that I don't
- 9:26know or that I don't understand, that seems to be really difficult because real
- 9:31curiosity, I think, requires a few things. It requires humility.
- 9:34It means admitting that we don't have the answer, that we have not necessarily
- 9:38walked in another person's shoes, which makes sense because they are the only
- 9:41version of them. You're the only version of you.
- 9:43We have to admit that their experience might be completely unfamiliar.
- 9:46And I think if we're being honest, that can feel really uncomfortable,
- 9:50Especially if we are tying our self-worth or if our self-worth is tangled up
- 9:55in being right or being helpful or needing to contribute.
- 9:59Here's the secret, though. Real connection, I believe, starts when you can get rid of certainty.
- 10:05Real connection starts when certainty ends. So let's go a little deeper.
- 10:09Why is it so hard to be genuinely curious? Let's take a look at how that shows
- 10:13up in our relationships and then what it looks like to lead from humility.
- 10:17And we're going to even talk about different types of humility instead of from our ego.
- 10:20My friend Preston used to say our ego is this adorable security guard that sits
- 10:24on the porch and just protects you.
- 10:25But sometimes it's a little over protective or it's barking at somebody that is not really a threat.
- 10:31Because I think if we're talking about ultra marathons or emotional gridlock
- 10:35in our marriage, one thing is true.
- 10:36You cannot guide someone through terrain that you've never crossed yourself.
- 10:41So then why is it so hard to simply be curious, genuinely curious about somebody
- 10:44else's life that they are the ones living before jumping in with advice or opinions or directions?
- 10:51Okay, story time. I was in a couple session. It was just a few days ago and
- 10:55we were talking through some dynamics as the couple started figuring out a few things.
- 11:00The husband said something that honestly, I really appreciated.
- 11:03He said that he wanted to be called out on his emotional immaturity.
- 11:07And that, that sounds great. It's a huge step.
- 11:10But then the very next line out of his mouth was, yeah, and you can call me
- 11:14out. I really want to know what I'm not getting.
- 11:17Again, sounds, sounds wonderful. But then it got really interesting after that.
- 11:20I told the couple that I really admire when somebody in session has the courage
- 11:25to say those things like, hey, old man, slow down, or I lost you there,
- 11:29or that's a lot of jargon, or I honestly don't know what that means.
- 11:33You seem pretty excited about it, Mr. Therapist, but what am I missing?
- 11:37What does that mean to you? Because here's what that means to me,
- 11:41because part of that therapeutic process, hopefully,
- 11:43if you've got a good therapist, it's not about them just waxing on therapeutic
- 11:48and you are there to just sit at their feet and learn, it's an interactive process.
- 11:53So yes, I have a certain set of skills, I think as Liam Neeson says,
- 11:58but I want to understand what you are understanding or what you're not understanding.
- 12:03And I know that that can take time as well.
- 12:05That's vulnerable. That is very real. But then the husband added,
- 12:09he said, yeah, because sometimes, and he said, no offense, which I love because
- 12:14that means something he's about to say, he's worried it will be offensive.
- 12:19And then the husband adds, yeah, because sometimes I don't think you realize
- 12:23that you're not really making a lot of sense.
- 12:26And I thought, okay, that is a fair point, but let's break it down.
- 12:30Because what I just heard was, sometimes when you are talking that I,
- 12:36your client, I actually have a better understanding of what you're trying to say than you do.
- 12:41And therefore, I reserve the right to tell you when you're not explaining yourself well.
- 12:48And again, on the surface, if you take out my passive aggressive tone,
- 12:52that sounds reasonable.
- 12:53But what it feels like is, okay, I now have to work even harder to make sense
- 12:58to you on your terms of something that you may not really understand.
- 13:05And it's almost like he gets to sit back and his arms are folded and he's saying, no, try again.
- 13:12I am going to actually stay defensive until you put together the exact right
- 13:17combination of words, facial expressions, and tone that feel good to me.
- 13:21And honestly, trust me, I've done that dance plenty of times when it was more
- 13:25about, oh my gosh, I don't want them to think I'm a bad therapist or I really
- 13:28want validation. I want them to tell me the way you explain things is amazing.
- 13:32But genuine curiosity, it requires active participation, not some sort of passive resistance.
- 13:39You know, it sounds more like, hey, help me understand.
- 13:43Not necessarily, I don't understand. Because that comes with maybe a side order of, so keep trying.
- 13:49Or it looks like, okay, what am I not getting?
- 13:52Instead of me putting out this energy, if I'm the client here,
- 13:55I need you to keep trying.
- 13:57I need you to keep guessing, almost like a game of charades,
- 13:59until then I can finally get it, until you make sense to me.
- 14:02Because underneath that, you need to make it make sense energy.
- 14:05That's often where the emotional immaturity lives.
- 14:09Because that's the need to be made to feel better. That's the hidden win-win
- 14:14for the more emotionally immature.
- 14:16If I finally say something that clicks for you, then you get to say, well done.
- 14:20You may now comfortably exist in my presence and we may continue.
- 14:24But if I don't, if it doesn't land, and that could even be a variety of things.
- 14:29Let's say that you are bored, you are hungry, you are lonely,
- 14:32you are angry, you are tired, you are anxious, you're scrolling through your
- 14:35own emotional filters of life, then that could very well be an impossible task for me.
- 14:41Are you genuinely trying to understand me, especially in the case of,
- 14:46let's say you're going to go visit your doctor or maybe it's the attorney,
- 14:50the dentist, the therapist, the auto mechanic, someone that that is what you are going there for.
- 14:55There's a somewhat of an assumption that, okay, they most likely do know at
- 15:00least some of what they're talking about or possibly more than me,
- 15:04the person coming to them for their services.
- 15:05So now if I'm sitting back saying, I ultimately need to be made to understand,
- 15:11and then I am not trying at all to try and understand, then maybe you can see
- 15:16where all these other factors can come into play.
- 15:18So it could be an impossible task. And then here's the kicker.
- 15:22Now, if I, let's say as a therapist, if I get frustrated trying to explain myself,
- 15:26now I even look more like the unstable one.
- 15:29Or let's say that you're in a marriage with an emotionally immature partner
- 15:32and they're the ones that are saying, I still don't get it, keep dancing, keep going, try again.
- 15:38Then eventually I may get frustrated because you're not actively trying to understand.
- 15:42You actually get to stay calm, even concerned. And it eventually shifts into,
- 15:47geez, I was just trying to understand you. Sorry for caring, nevermind.
- 15:50And now you, the person in that position of trying to explain to the person
- 15:54who is not genuinely curious, now you start to feel like the crazy one,
- 16:00And now the person that is not actively participating or actively being genuinely
- 16:05curious, now you get to look like the victim.
- 16:07So what does the person that is trying to explain in a way that you will understand,
- 16:13what will they eventually do then? They will apologize.
- 16:16Okay, no, you're right. I'm sorry. I'm just losing my cool. Without really understanding
- 16:20this, I'm continually trying to explain something to you that I don't view you
- 16:25as trying to genuinely understand. So this is a bit of a fool's errand.
- 16:31But then that person, typically, I would then apologize.
- 16:34You would forgive me. And you stay in that one-up position.
- 16:38And then before we even try to have another, hopefully real intimate conversation,
- 16:42you may have already planted the landmine of, hey, can you just promise me you
- 16:46won't freak out this time like you did last time when all I was trying to do was understand you?
- 16:51And then that just sends the other person walking into the conversation with
- 16:55just a big old backpack full of anticipatory rejection and that cycle will continue.
- 17:00So back to this couple. So I brought a little more than gentle awareness to
- 17:03the fact that it's actually more of his job and it would mean more to him,
- 17:08It would resonate more to him if he can be the one that can ask for clarification.
- 17:15Now, if I sense that either of them in this couple setting detaches,
- 17:20shuts down, looks confused because I am reading body language,
- 17:23then absolutely, I'll check in.
- 17:24I might ask, hey, I noticed a little sudden shift in energy or it appears that
- 17:29you shut down right now. Tell me what you're hearing or help me understand.
- 17:33What does that mean to you? Now, that's part of my job.
- 17:36Here's where the real growth happens, though. It takes courage to be vulnerable
- 17:40for that person in that chair that is interacting with the therapist.
- 17:44Or if you're the person and you are talking with someone and you really don't
- 17:48understand, to be able to say, I don't know, especially when you think you should know.
- 17:55And again, nobody likes to be should on, especially shooting on themselves,
- 18:01which speaking of running, I don't know why this just came to mind.
- 18:05Well, actually, because I'm talking about shooting on oneself,
- 18:08an unfortunate trail pooping incident somewhere around mile 90 of this aforementioned
- 18:13famed Western States 100 mile endurance run.
- 18:15I believe it was the second year that I ever ran. I came upon a runner who was
- 18:20he was squatting right next to the trail, but he was yelling, look, look.
- 18:24And I thought, OK, honestly, I'd rather not because it appears that he's doing
- 18:28his business and not even that successfully right now. But man, I hear you, brother.
- 18:33We're in this together. 90 miles does a number on those quads. Am I right?
- 18:36But it turns out he was actually screaming, don't look, to which I thought,
- 18:40well, then honestly, don't drop your compression shorts a half an inch off of
- 18:43a six inch mile rutted single track trail.
- 18:46But I digress. Anyway, back to the point. Are you actually trying to understand?
- 18:50Maybe you're even trying to understand why did I just...
- 18:53Tell that story. Or you might even be trying to make someone else rearrange
- 18:58their words until you feel good about what they said.
- 19:02I would just love to challenge you to be more aware of the difference.
- 19:06That is where the growth begins.
- 19:08Because let's talk about real curiosity. Real curiosity requires self-regulation.
- 19:13Let's start here because without this piece of self-regulation,
- 19:16curiosity doesn't even stand a chance.
- 19:18Because real curiosity, it requires you to be able to calm your own anxiety, soothe yourself.
- 19:23If you can't manage that inner urge to just react, defend, interrupt,
- 19:29correct, or educate the other person, then curiosity is hijacked.
- 19:34It gets swallowed up by reactivity.
- 19:36I'm a big fan of David Schnarch's work of his four points of balance and differentiation.
- 19:41And his second point of balance is really important. And it comes into play
- 19:45here, quiet mind and calm heart.
- 19:48If you're not familiar with Schnarch's model of differentiation of self.
- 19:51It is all about being able to hold on to your autonomy, your own sense of self
- 19:55in close emotional connection with others, especially when there's tension.
- 20:00Because it is much easier, but you're losing your sense of self when you just
- 20:05acquiesce, you give in, you fold into what the other person wants you to do
- 20:10to make them feel better.
- 20:11Differentiation is that ability to stay you without needing the other person
- 20:15to become a mirror or a validator of your self-worth.
- 20:20And let me take one step back the first point of balance that of Schnarch's
- 20:24four points of balance of being differentiated is having a solid but flexible sense of self.
- 20:30You know who you are, what you value, what you stand for, and you're not rigid or reactive about it.
- 20:37And you move away from this need for others to tell you you're okay,
- 20:42that concept of external validation.
- 20:45The second point of balance, quiet mind and calm heart, is what allows you to
- 20:49stay in connection with others, even when you start to become emotionally activated.
- 20:53Because you can calm your own nervous system without needing the other person
- 20:58to do it for you. I don't need them to tell me it's okay because I can tell myself it's okay.
- 21:04I can ground myself. I can come into the present moment.
- 21:07I can build in that pause because that paves the way for Shnarch's third point
- 21:12of balance of differentiation, which is a grounded response.
- 21:15That's where you can stay emotionally present. You can show up honestly and
- 21:18you can respond instead of react.
- 21:20You don't have to go too big, but also you don't have to play small.
- 21:25You can respond. You can come from this place where you are okay.
- 21:29So you know it is okay for you to stay in this conversation.
- 21:34So then if we're talking again about genuine curiosity, then this is sort of the engine.
- 21:40Self-regulation creates this pause. And in that pause, that's where you can
- 21:44notice. You can say, okay, I'm feeling defensive.
- 21:48But I wonder what they're really trying to say versus what I am thinking I am
- 21:54hearing, the assumptions I'm making. Or that pause is where you can say,
- 21:58I'm noticing this feels like an attack, but maybe they're hurting.
- 22:02And or maybe it is honestly, I am just misunderstanding what might be happening here underneath.
- 22:07It's not necessarily about the literal words, but more about just this energy
- 22:12or this feeling that I have.
- 22:14That's not being passive. That is an internal type of strength.
- 22:18So I've been on two cruises in my entire life and I loved them both.
- 22:23You throw a little bit of Dramamine in me and suddenly I am floating through
- 22:26life with soft serve ice cream in one hand. and absolutely no idea what day it is in the other.
- 22:32I guess you're not holding that in your hand, but regardless, it is a perfect reset.
- 22:36And I also absolutely love what I do as a therapist.
- 22:39So when you put me on a cruise with people who would like to talk about things
- 22:44like mental health or parenting or relationships or faith crisis or emotional
- 22:48immaturity or ADHD, that along with the soft serve is my dream vacation.
- 22:53So if you were to see me on one of these cruises and you have a question,
- 22:57you are absolutely not bugging me.
- 22:59And true, I'm diagnosing you, but it's in the most lovable way.
- 23:03Now, that is why I am truly excited to be the special guest on the I See You
- 23:09Living Cruise, a five-night Western Caribbean cruise, January 24th through the 29th.
- 23:152026, with my good friend and cruise mastermind, headliner, and I guess we could
- 23:20technically say maybe cruise director, Julie DeJesus.
- 23:24And this is honestly the best of all worlds because you're going to be able
- 23:28to get away from the day-to-day grind, connect with people who care about personal
- 23:32growth, mental health, all the things that really matter.
- 23:35Plus, again, you've got ice cream, lava cake.
- 23:38So whether you're working on your mental health or your relationship or looking
- 23:41to just boost your resilience, or you just need an excuse to finally take a
- 23:45vacation, this cruise is exactly what you need.
- 23:48And parents, good news, kids set sail on this one for free. So you don't even
- 23:53have to hunt down a babysitter.
- 23:54So go to julie-dejesus.com slash cruise, or you can look in the show notes of
- 24:01this podcast episode or in my link tree or anywhere to get all of the details.
- 24:05You can lock in your early bird special.
- 24:07You can reserve your spot for some exclusive dining and conversation with Julie and me.
- 24:11You can bring your spouse, bring a partner, your friends, any of your favorite
- 24:15overthinkers, or just bring yourself.
- 24:17We would love to have you there. Let's go with a couple of examples.
- 24:19Let's start in a marriage. If your partner says, you never listened to me.
- 24:22If your initial reaction is, are you kidding me? I always listen.
- 24:27As a matter of fact, you're the one that doesn't listen. I think you're just
- 24:30being overly sensitive.
- 24:31It's pretty obvious that's reactive. That's trying to protect yourself rather than understand them.
- 24:36That is coming from a place of being offended. But if you've built your this
- 24:41self-regulation muscle, that's where you get to take a breath.
- 24:46Ground yourself, pause, and
- 24:47then, OK, can you help me understand what you're feeling unheard about?
- 24:51Now you've shifted from defensiveness to curiosity, and that opens a door for
- 24:57connection, for more communication.
- 24:59Or think of this in the terms of parenting. If your teenager says,
- 25:03you know what, nobody in this family even cares about me.
- 25:05You guys all stink. then you might want to say, really, none of us care for you?
- 25:10Please, we do everything for you. Who pays for your car insurance?
- 25:13Who pays for your phone? That's just ridiculous.
- 25:16That is not going to build connection. That is not going to provide emotional
- 25:20consistency, emotional safety, secure attachment for your kid to learn how to grow and thrive.
- 25:25But with self-regulation in place and you build that pause in,
- 25:29you do feel this rising anxiety. I'm noticing that I am starting to get a little
- 25:35frustrated, but then you don't let that hijack or steer the conversation.
- 25:40You might then be able to find yourself saying something like,
- 25:42hey, that sounds like a pretty heavy thing to feel.
- 25:45Help me understand. Take me on your train of thought. What's happening that's
- 25:47made you feel that way like none of us really understand or support you?
- 25:52You have then created a moment of safety. Now, does it guarantee that the teenager
- 25:56will melt and some really cool music plays in the background?
- 26:00And then you have a connection and you eventually hug it out?
- 26:03Not necessarily, but you are starting to provide consistency.
- 26:06You've created a moment of safety. You've made space for a deeper conversation.
- 26:10That's the gift of this self-regulation paired with genuine curiosity.
- 26:14Plus, you're modeling that for your kid as well.
- 26:17Curiosity requires humility. This is a pretty important piece.
- 26:22Now, let's define humility because I'm so curious what that means to you.
- 26:28Because humility, in my opinion, is not weakness.
- 26:31It's not being passive. It's not about being walked on or being a pushover.
- 26:36And it's definitely not the, we'll call it the victim energy version of humility
- 26:41that sounds like, oh, I guess I'm just an idiot. I guess I'm just stupid.
- 26:44I know I shouldn't be thinking that. I never get anything right.
- 26:47Or, hey, I'm so sorry. Again, I know I'm probably wrong.
- 26:50That's not humility. I really believe that's more like a shield.
- 26:54It's a disarming tactic. And it's often used by the more emotionally mature
- 26:57people to avoid accountability or to elicit some sort of reassurance or validation.
- 27:02It may sound humble. It might even feel somewhat humble.
- 27:06But it actually places the burden back on the other person to now comfort and validate or tiptoe.
- 27:12Real humility. The kind that comes from differentiation, the kind that leads
- 27:17to genuine curiosity, looks like.
- 27:20Someone who says, hey, I didn't know that. Thank you for explaining.
- 27:23I really appreciate that. Or, hey, you're right.
- 27:26That's my misunderstanding. That's my bad.
- 27:29Or I can really see how that landed a lot differently than I had intended.
- 27:33And I am so sorry that that came out the way that it did. But thank you for
- 27:39bringing that to my attention.
- 27:40That version of humility is more from a place of strength and confidence.
- 27:44It builds trust. because when you can admit that you are a human being,
- 27:49imperfect, growing, learning, the other person starts to feel safer to be those things too.
- 27:55And in relationships, that really starts to become a turning point.
- 27:59Humility says, my ego doesn't need to win this round. I would rather understand you.
- 28:04And this is, we're in this relationship for the long haul and I'm secure enough
- 28:08or I'm working on it to not know something and not believe that you are now
- 28:13going to run away screaming and leave me.
- 28:14That's a doorway to connection, a doorway to intimacy and curiosity.
- 28:20Curiosity lives on the other side of that door.
- 28:23Curiosity also requires a secure sense of self.
- 28:26That first point of balance of David Schnarch's four points of balance of differentiation.
- 28:31Because the truth is, you will hear things like, oh, I thought everybody knew that.
- 28:35To which there's going to be a defensive answer to that. No, no, we don't all.
- 28:39I'm sure there are things that you don't know as well. And when one is truly
- 28:44secure in themselves, their response may sound something like,
- 28:48oh no, I didn't know that. Period.
- 28:52Guilt and shame. I'm often impressed more by the people who tell me that they
- 28:57actually don't know the difference because that's okay.
- 29:00Guilt, I have done something wrong or bad.
- 29:05Shame, I am bad. even though
- 29:08to me personally they are
- 29:10so significantly different that it truly
- 29:13is something that i i truly wish that everyone knew
- 29:17and understood because i don't believe that shame is productive at all i haven't
- 29:22worked with anyone where shame has been the true driver of change even though
- 29:26we continually shame ourselves or come from a place of shame because we think
- 29:32that That must be what will help.
- 29:34If shame was healing, then we would all be healed because we're really good
- 29:38at beating ourselves up.
- 29:41Genuine curiosity requires a willingness to not be the expert.
- 29:45I often refer back to this article that I've shared from Eleanor Greenberg from
- 29:49psychologytoday.com titled The Truth About Narcissistic Personality Disorder.
- 29:52And what I think is fascinating is she talked about something that probably
- 29:56sounds pretty crazy right now, and that is when there was a view or a concept of healthy narcissism.
- 30:03So I like co-opting her definition of normal, healthy narcissism,
- 30:08and I'm going to insert instead of the word narcissism, ego.
- 30:11And then we'll talk about the opposite of that. And I think you can see where
- 30:15one is going to lead to genuine curiosity and the other not so much. Normal, healthy ego.
- 30:21This is a realistic sense of positive self-regard that's based on the person's
- 30:25actual accomplishments.
- 30:26It's relatively stable because the person has assimilated into their self-image
- 30:31their successes that came as a result of their actual hard work to overcome real-life obstacles.
- 30:36And because it's based on real achievements, normal, healthy ego,
- 30:40it's relatively impervious to the
- 30:42minor slights and setbacks that we all experience as we go through life.
- 30:46Normal, healthy ego causes us to care about ourselves, do things that are in
- 30:51our real self-interest, and it's associated with genuine self-respect.
- 30:54One can think of it as something that is inside of us.
- 30:58Why I think that is significant is that when you can start to operate from this
- 31:02place of, I know what I know because I have really worked hard to know it,
- 31:07then that also comes with, so there are obviously things I don't know,
- 31:12and I don't know them because I don't know them.
- 31:15And it's okay to not know everything.
- 31:17And that can lead to me being curious. What it also leads to over time is while
- 31:23I say, hey, this is something I know, I am also leaving the door open to,
- 31:28I learned about this thing that I know.
- 31:31From a time when I didn't know it. So, I'm reserving the right to continue to
- 31:34learn and know more, but I'm going to stand in this healthy ego of the things
- 31:40I know, and I'm going to acknowledge the things I don't know.
- 31:42The opposite of healthy ego from this Truth About Narcissistic Personality Disorder
- 31:47article is pathological defense of narcissism.
- 31:51This is a defense against feelings of inferiority. The person dons a mask of
- 31:55arrogant superiority in an attempt to convince the world that he or she is special.
- 31:59But inside the person feels very
- 32:02insecure about his or her actual self-worth and this
- 32:05facade of superiority is so thin that it's like
- 32:08a helium balloon one small pinprick is going
- 32:11to deflate it and this makes the person hypersensitive to
- 32:14minor slights that somebody with healthy ego wouldn't even notice so instead
- 32:18somebody with this type of defensive narcissism is easily wounded they frequently
- 32:23take any form of disagreement as a serious criticism and they are likely to
- 32:28lash shout and devalue anybody who they think is disagreeing with them.
- 32:31They're constantly on guard trying to protect their status.
- 32:35Pathological narcissism can be thought of as a protective armor that is on the outside of us.
- 32:38The significance is the opposite of healthy ego. This pathological defensive
- 32:42narcissism is from a deep well of insecurity.
- 32:45If I think that I am supposed to know something about everything or you will
- 32:49think less of me or you will abandon me or you will leave me,
- 32:53then I'm going to make things up and hope that it goes over well.
- 32:56But over time, it does not build connection.
- 32:59It does not build genuine intimacy between humans when they try to communicate or connect.
- 33:04And healthy ego comes from a place of competence, of security.
- 33:10And I think this ties into this concept of curiosity because when someone, they lack curiosity,
- 33:17it's typically coming from this place of insecurity because they are afraid
- 33:21to ask questions because they may have to admit that they don't know something
- 33:26or that this other person might have a knowledge or a trait or some talent that
- 33:33is different than the person asking.
- 33:35And when we dip into the world of true emotional immaturity,
- 33:39even getting into the world of narcissistic traits, tendencies,
- 33:42and personality disorder,
- 33:43the problem here is that when someone has an opinion that is different than
- 33:47yours, then from this immature place, they think that they are right and I am wrong.
- 33:53As if there There's only one opinion that can be had.
- 33:56So now they must defend their opinion and break down mine.
- 33:59So back to curiosity. Hopefully you're starting to pick up on this vibe that
- 34:04it's not just a nice trait to have.
- 34:06It's not just something to think about every once in a while.
- 34:09It's not something that, hey, we value this in small kids. They're just so darn
- 34:13curious before the life's knocked the wind out of their sails.
- 34:15It's actually a milestone of emotional maturity.
- 34:19When we are stuck in this situation.
- 34:21Place of emotional immaturity, when we're operating from these younger frozen
- 34:25parts of ourselves, then curiosity feels scary or dangerous.
- 34:29It feels like saying, if I say, I don't know, that could open the door to judgment,
- 34:32rejection, feeling small.
- 34:34So instead I'm going to pretend to know, and I'm going to fill the space.
- 34:37I'm going to emotionally filibuster.
- 34:39I'm going to explain, I'm going to advise, I'm going to narrate,
- 34:41and I'm going to try to control the moment often without even realizing it.
- 34:45The truth is real curiosity comes from a place of security.
- 34:50If you are interacting with someone and they are being genuinely curious,
- 34:52that is somebody that is pretty secure.
- 34:55You cannot be genuinely curious and then desperate to protect your ego at the same time.
- 35:01Now, let's talk emotion. It's important to recognize emotion is not the opposite of reason.
- 35:08Emotion actually provides us the information that then reason can use.
- 35:13Let's get a little nerdy. modern neuroscience shows that
- 35:16emotions are processed in the brain even before
- 35:19the thoughts are they fire faster so before
- 35:22we even have a chance to rationalize something we've already felt it
- 35:25and often we've reacted to it i love the
- 35:28example of walking down a road and seeing something out of the corner of my
- 35:32eye that is just a length a long object and we react a visceral reaction of
- 35:38oh my gosh is that a snake then nope that's a stick that is miraculous that
- 35:43i was already reacting before I even had an idea of what that was.
- 35:47So here comes the psychology nerd alert. In a now pretty famous 2008 study,
- 35:54neuroscientist John Dylan Haynes and his team at the Max Planck Institute used
- 35:59functional MRI technology, fMRI brain scans, to explore the timing of human decision making.
- 36:05So the big question they had was, when do we actually make a decision?
- 36:08Is it in the moment that we think that we've decided or does the brain decide
- 36:13before we're even aware.
- 36:15Participants in this study were asked to press a button with their left or right
- 36:18hand, whichever one they felt the urge.
- 36:20And the researchers with these brain scan devices connected watched what was
- 36:26happening in their brains in real time. And this is just so wild.
- 36:30Haynes team found that the brain showed patterns that were predicting the person's
- 36:34choice up to seven seconds before they consciously reported making the decision.
- 36:39Just kind of let that one sink in a little bit. Your brain is already leaning one way.
- 36:43It's already preparing to act before you're consciously aware that you've decided.
- 36:48So in other words, the body, your nervous system, your emotional center, new first.
- 36:53So when we say that emotions are faster than thoughts, we're not just talking metaphorically.
- 36:58Your brain is already processing, reacting, queuing up, shaping behavior before
- 37:02your thinking brain may even catch up.
- 37:04And that's why curiosity and slowing things down is so powerful.
- 37:10It's so necessary because most of the time we're reacting before we're even
- 37:14aware that we've reacted.
- 37:16So being aware of that and learning to build in that pause, to notice that I'm
- 37:21starting to react and then taking that time, building that space in to then
- 37:26even be curious with myself first.
- 37:28Ooh, check that out. I was about to say this thing, but now I'm gonna put that
- 37:31aside, step outside of my ego and now ask questions.
- 37:36Now let's talk about some emotions because emotions are not all the same.
- 37:40They do show up in layers, primary, secondary, and one that I haven't really
- 37:43talked about, instrumental.
- 37:44So primary emotions, those are these gut, real time, raw responses to life,
- 37:48they are often about survival or expressing something that is very important
- 37:52that's been impacted, like sadness from loss or fear from threat,
- 37:55or even anger when a boundary's been crossed.
- 37:58Secondary emotions come from then how we interpret those primary feelings, how we react to them.
- 38:02Often they're layered on top, like shame on top of sadness or anger on top of fear.
- 38:07The example I love on this one is when my kids would scare me when they were little.
- 38:11If they jumped out and scared me and I was like, geez, guys, come on.
- 38:15And I express anger, That's actually more of a secondary emotion to embarrassment,
- 38:18that these tiny little human beings just made me lose my mind and potentially
- 38:23drop or spill something.
- 38:24But these secondary emotions, they're the emotions that we learn or we absorb
- 38:28based on how safe we feel expressing what's underneath.
- 38:31I cannot stop the jokes in my inner monologue.
- 38:36And I know that humor is typically a secondary emotion.
- 38:40That's why so many comedians have a little bit of a, maybe a darker,
- 38:44more tortured past because they've had to joke to make up for the feelings of
- 38:50sadness or not feeling like they are seen or understood.
- 38:53I have a theory, that's all this is, that then over time, if your secondary
- 38:58emotion of humor is so consistent, then does it move into your primary emotion?
- 39:04That then your immediate reaction is a joke.
- 39:08Instrumental emotions are pretty fascinating. They're used more strategically,
- 39:12and these are the ones that we might not even realize that we're using to influence
- 39:16somebody or gain control.
- 39:17Think of a kid who cries to get out of a task, and you sense that it's a little bit fake.
- 39:23My grandson, Red, who's barely over a year old, can do little cry eyes,
- 39:27sad eyes, and it's adorable, but it's his way you can already see of wanting to get attention.
- 39:32Or I don't know if it's to necessarily get out of something or maybe to get something.
- 39:35Or an adult who might use passive aggressive sighs or tears,
- 39:39not from primary pain, but to shift the mood.
- 39:42I am still very fascinated by interrogation videos.
- 39:45A lot of times my social media feeds show them. I watched one not long ago,
- 39:50and it was a woman in court, and she was making the faces of someone that was very sad.
- 39:56And the person that was in charge of this YouTube channel pointed out that she
- 40:01would even grab a tissue, but there's no moisture coming out of her eyes.
- 40:06And then when a question would be asked it was amazing how quickly she could
- 40:11just be right back in the present moment that these and I will sound judgmental
- 40:15but I will own this one but it did not appear to be how a really truly sad empathetic.
- 40:23Weeping person would react but it looked like this person was using these instrumental
- 40:29emotions as a way to try and shift the mood to move it over to about them And to be fair,
- 40:36they're not always manipulative, but they're often less about what's being truly
- 40:40felt and more about what results someone hopes to get.
- 40:43And not long ago, I was overhearing an adult who needed help with something.
- 40:48And instead of just saying, hey, is there any way that you could help me?
- 40:52They said, oh, I don't know what I'm going to do. And it just didn't even sound like this person.
- 40:57And the people that they were talking to helped them.
- 41:00It is fascinating to see that it was rewarded. Let me talk about anger for just
- 41:03a second before we move on past emotions because I really find anger very fascinating.
- 41:08Anger is a big one in relationships and anger is one of these that can be either
- 41:11a primary or a secondary emotion.
- 41:14Primary anger comes from something real, being wronged, being violated,
- 41:18being betrayed, a sense of injustice. If your partner is unfaithful and you
- 41:23say, I'm so angry at you, I didn't deserve this.
- 41:25That's primary, it's vulnerable, it's honest, it invites connection.
- 41:28Even if it's hard, it says I'm hurt and I need you to see that.
- 41:32Secondary anger, though, is more like armor. It's the lashing out in reaction
- 41:36to something that happened.
- 41:37Let's go back to this example of if I am embarrassed, if I am scared,
- 41:41and then I get angry. Knock it off, you guys. It's not funny.
- 41:44I'm angry because I'm embarrassed. It's not about trying to share this pain
- 41:50or be heard. It's about shielding it.
- 41:52And so then that one doesn't build bridges between people. It's going to burn
- 41:56the bridge down. It's going to put more distance between two people.
- 42:00Now, when we confuse the two, I'm talking again about primary and secondary
- 42:04emotions, or when we act from secondary emotion and then we'd call that our
- 42:07truth, we can start to do some damage in our relationships.
- 42:10It's so important to learn to recognize these emotional layers and then being
- 42:15honest about where your emotions are coming from because that will help you
- 42:18show up with more clarity and less reactivity.
- 42:20And as we have identified, when we can be more authentic, when we can eliminate
- 42:26that reactivity, when we can do that, then you can show up with more genuine curiosity.
- 42:32You ask better questions, ones that are rooted in genuine, wanting to know and
- 42:37understand somebody instead of some emotional defensiveness or trying to prove
- 42:41somebody wrong or defend your own fragile ego.
- 42:43So let's talk a little bit about how you can feel the difference.
- 42:47And this is where I go back to wanting you to trust your gut.
- 42:51Now, in the world of emotional immaturity, I covered a concept that I was talking
- 42:55about, emotional reasoning, or if I feel it, it must be true.
- 42:59And on that episode, it was part two of my exploring all things emotionally mature podcast series.
- 43:07I did make a distinction that I want you to start from a place of trusting your gut.
- 43:13The thing that I want people to be aware of, though, is that that is a childhood adaptation.
- 43:19That for kids, if I think mom and dad are mad at me, then they are mad at me.
- 43:22So then when a parent is even being very kind and gentle and saying things the
- 43:26kid doesn't want to hear, the kid will often say, stop yelling at me.
- 43:30And if you are a parent, you've inevitably got to the point where you're like, I'm not yelling.
- 43:34And they're saying, yes, you are. And you're so mad. I'm not mad,
- 43:36bud. And I'm not yelling.
- 43:38And then eventually you are mad and you say, I'll show you what yelling is.
- 43:41So that's the immature version.
- 43:43But I do want to start from a place of, okay, I feel it. I want to acknowledge
- 43:47that something seems off.
- 43:49So when somebody says something and you can, you start from a place of,
- 43:53you can tell this just feels, something feels off. You know,
- 43:56when there's genuine connection.
- 43:57And I think the genuine curiosity is just, it feels safe.
- 44:01Let's say we're starting from a place of you, you can tell there's a hidden
- 44:05agenda because that's not you being paranoid.
- 44:08We start from a place of that is your brain doing its job? Because our social
- 44:12brains are wired with a thing called mirror neurons.
- 44:15And while I am not a neuroscientist, I love the concept around mirror neurons.
- 44:20I'm acknowledging the fact that there may be parts of this that I don't even know, that I don't know.
- 44:24But my understanding is that these mirror neurons do help us sense what other people are feeling.
- 44:28It's like we're looking into a mirror or we're trying to read the room.
- 44:32We're trying to pick up on their energy, the subtle nuances that are there to protect us initially.
- 44:39So when somebody is being performative or they're being sarcastic or they're
- 44:42being defensive, we don't just hear it because we might definitely hear it, but we will feel it.
- 44:47And we want to start from that place of, I do feel it. I want to make space
- 44:50for that. I want to acknowledge that this something feels off.
- 44:53And that's why people do shut down when they sense that your curiosity maybe isn't genuine.
- 44:59Now, I hope that we're going to be able to have the tools to say,
- 45:03hey, I'm noticing that something feels off here.
- 45:05Tell me more about why you're asking that question or help me understand.
- 45:10Because your body is telling you this isn't safe.
- 45:14So let's build a pause in here and let's just put our guard up a little bit.
- 45:17Because I don't want to hand away buttons that this person can push,
- 45:21especially if they're in the world of emotional immaturity or even all the way
- 45:24up to narcissistic traits or tendencies.
- 45:27Because handing those buttons over, it might feel good in the moment.
- 45:30But then if you are in relationships where that person comes back and then uses
- 45:33those against you down the road, then it turns out that your,
- 45:36this internal radar or internal GPS of emotions was correct.
- 45:41Hey, everybody, let me take a quick minute to talk to the guys who are listening to this episode.
- 45:46I want to really hone in on the guys who are starting to wake up to the fact
- 45:50that something in your life just isn't quite right. Let me ask you this.
- 45:53Have you ever caught yourself thinking things are going to get better?
- 45:56Things will be better when the kids grow up or when you get in better shape
- 46:00or when you get the promotion or when you finally have a little more time or
- 46:04after you finish all eight seasons of this Netflix show that you are invested in.
- 46:09That is magical thinking. It'll get better later.
- 46:12And that's what gets people to this place where they'd feel like they're not
- 46:16living their very best life.
- 46:18So welcome to later. It is now later. It is time to do something about it.
- 46:24Yeah your life maybe isn't playing out the way that you thought it would and you
- 46:27don't know why or maybe you think that you do but nothing that you
- 46:30try seems to work or it actually seems to make things worse and now
- 46:32you're stuck kicking the can down the road and at this point you've kicked
- 46:35that can so far down the road that you might qualify for a guinness world record
- 46:40in emotional deflection but here is the truth it is time to stop letting your
- 46:44job your marriage your bank account your kids your fear your ego dictate how
- 46:48you show up in your own life i have been fortunate to work with men from all walks of life,
- 46:53athletes and politicians and doctors and lawyers and engineers and salesmen, you name it.
- 46:58And the truth is, our struggles are far more alike than you think.
- 47:02The key is not getting older or wealthier or more shredded at the gym.
- 47:06It's admitting that you need help.
- 47:08Now, this may sound like a riddle, but I promise you it's not because I'm actually
- 47:11not a very big fan of riddles.
- 47:13So hear me out. You don't know what you don't know. And that's okay,
- 47:16because how could you know what you don't know?
- 47:19And the things that you've learned in your life up to this point were also things
- 47:22that you did not know until you learned them.
- 47:24So it would only make sense that as you continue on life's path as a human,
- 47:28there is a lot more to learn. That can be an awesome thing.
- 47:33But for some reason, men in particular have a tough time admitting or understanding
- 47:37this, but it is the key to the next phase of your life.
- 47:39And I can guide you down that path because real change doesn't come from chasing more.
- 47:43It comes from learning to look inward and confronting something inside of you
- 47:47that I promise you, you're probably not even aware of.
- 47:50So that is where my emotional architects men's group comes in.
- 47:53I promise that I do have the tools. You just have to show up.
- 47:56Whether it's business, marriage, parenting, intimacy, health,
- 47:59finances, or friendships, the root of most of our struggles as men in particular
- 48:04is emotional immaturity. And guess what?
- 48:06We are all emotionally immature. But when you learn what it is,
- 48:09when you learn what it looks like, how it shows up in all the areas of your
- 48:12life, when you learn how to embrace it instead of running from it,
- 48:15everything starts to shift.
- 48:17So for less than the cost of one therapy session a month, you will get access
- 48:20to two group calls a month with like-minded men, guys who are ready to grow,
- 48:25with a clear, well-crafted roadmap that teaches you the things that you didn't
- 48:28even know that you were missing, as well as you'll have one-on-one access to yours truly.
- 48:33That's me. And a place to ask every question you've ever wanted answered.
- 48:36You name it, we'll answer it.
- 48:38So if you have been waiting for some sort of a sign, well, this is it.
- 48:42So go to TonyOverbay.com or email me at contact at TonyOverbay.com and ask about
- 48:46the Men's Emotional Architects group later is today.
- 48:50And character transforming, life-altering change is ready and waiting for you.
- 48:54Now let's get back to the show. Let me throw some real-life examples and we'll
- 48:57try to make more sense of this. So let's look at a marriage.
- 49:01Say partner number one says, I'm just kind of feeling overwhelmed lately with
- 49:05everything at home and everything at work.
- 49:07So if we've got their partner who is not being so curious, then these words
- 49:12might sound curious. Really, what exactly are you overwhelmed by?
- 49:15And then they might even jump in and say, I mean, I've been trying to do more
- 49:18around the house. I did the dishes last night.
- 49:19So that question can sound like an engagement, but really it's somewhat of a
- 49:24defensive counterattack because then it becomes about you expressing your emotions.
- 49:29That person saying words that could put a question mark behind them,
- 49:33but then it slips into their validating their own effort.
- 49:36They're really not trying to understand you. Now, a more curious version of
- 49:39that might be the partner saying, oh, you're feeling overwhelmed.
- 49:43Hey, tell me more about that. What has that felt like? What are you experiencing?
- 49:47Or tell me what's the hardest part about what you've been going through lately.
- 49:51That's curiosity. And hopefully you can even feel that. That's a little safer.
- 49:55It's more open. It's coming from a place where the person asking the questions is more grounded.
- 50:00Now let's, let's jump into this world of parent, teen, I don't know, showdown.
- 50:05So teenager, and I want to jokingly say, this is all hypothetical.
- 50:08I'm sure no one's ever experienced this exactly.
- 50:10Teenager saying, you know what?
- 50:11I just think school is pointless and I'm never going to use any of this.
- 50:14Parent, not being so curious. Oh, really? So you think everybody should just
- 50:18drop out and become an influencer or a YouTuber?
- 50:21So that is sarcasm disguised as curiosity.
- 50:25The more curious version is, oh man, that sounds hard. First of all,
- 50:28tell me how I can show up for you.
- 50:29Is there anything I can do right now? I really want to understand what part
- 50:33of school feels the most pointless right now.
- 50:36Let's move into example three. We will say that you're all gathered around the
- 50:40dinner table and you're with your friends.
- 50:42And somebody just says, honestly, I don't even think that college is worth it
- 50:45for everybody these days.
- 50:46Now, if you are being more performative and not curious, really,
- 50:50should people just drop out and then just hope for the best?
- 50:52I mean, I'm so curious what you mean by that.
- 50:54They've even said the word curious in there. And again, you could put a question
- 50:57mark at the end of that, but that sounds more like it's being accusatory.
- 51:01If you were being genuinely curious, then that is interesting.
- 51:04Take me on your train of thought. I'd love to know why you came up with that conclusion.
- 51:08Tell me what your experience is. The shift in tone and intention and emotional
- 51:12safety becomes everything.
- 51:14Let's talk about maybe a litmus test for genuine curiosity. So how do you know
- 51:20which kind of curiosity you are bringing?
- 51:24Because we will never exactly know what the other person is going through.
- 51:28So this is about you. It is a you thing. It's a you thing to determine whether
- 51:33or not the person who is asking you questions is being genuinely curious because
- 51:36that will go a long way with, do you feel safe enough to open up?
- 51:40Or even I might open up and I have to accept the fact that if that person wasn't
- 51:44genuinely curious, then that could come back to bite me.
- 51:47But if you are the person that is in a relationship.
- 51:51And you are the one now that is listening, I would love to help you understand,
- 51:56am I trying to understand this other person or am I trying to win?
- 52:01Am I okay if their answer challenges what I believe? Because it's okay for us
- 52:05to already have beliefs.
- 52:07We're human beings. We need to be able to check those beliefs.
- 52:11Step outside of that ego so that I can become more genuinely present and curious
- 52:16because I want to know this person.
- 52:18Would I ask this question even if I knew that I wouldn't get the response that I want?
- 52:24Because if the answer is yes to those, then congratulations because you are
- 52:27locked into genuine curiosity mode.
- 52:29That is where you are going to have a potential for genuine emotional intimacy
- 52:33and connection with another human.
- 52:35And the good news is you can rewire this. Even if your default mode has been
- 52:39performative or defensive, the fact you're listening to this is amazing and
- 52:45you can retrain your brain to show up differently.
- 52:47Just like these emotional styles, they're not fixed in stone,
- 52:51neither is your questioning style.
- 52:53Because every time that you learn how to pause, that you choose to pause,
- 52:58regulate your emotions, then ask a question from a place of openness,
- 53:02you're starting to rewire the way that you connect with other people.
- 53:05You're starting to build emotional safety. It's going to start to feel more
- 53:09genuine and authentic, and it will come from a place of confidence.
- 53:13And then you become somebody that people feel safe talking to.
- 53:16And that safety is what allows people to be more vulnerable and more growth
- 53:23minded. And it just gives you this opportunity for real connection.
- 53:28Let's walk through how emotional immaturity and genuine curiosity show up out in the wild.
- 53:33I'll give you four real life narratives and each one is going to start with a knee-jerk reaction.
- 53:38And then let's explore how curiosity would lead to a better path. Parenting.
- 53:43From explosion to exploration, you walk into your teenager's room and it's a mess. It's a disaster.
- 53:48Clothes, dishes. How many times have you said, hey, can you not bring dishes into your room?
- 53:54Or there's just empty soda cans. you could basically do like an entire archaeological
- 53:59dig and find things that you haven't seen for years.
- 54:03And there might even be new species of things that are growing or happening under their bed.
- 54:08So your first reaction might be, seriously, I have told you so many times to
- 54:12clean this up. And I just feel like you don't respect me.
- 54:14You don't respect this house. And you take advantage of me.
- 54:17That is this concept of emotional reasoning. It's black and white thinking.
- 54:21You feel disrespected. So you assume it is disrespect. This is what they are doing. Case closed.
- 54:25Now, curiosity would look like. You walk in there.
- 54:28Here's my opportunity for growth. I pause. I take a breath.
- 54:31It's necessary. I got to slow down my heart rate. I got to lower the cortisol, the adrenaline.
- 54:37I have to be able to be grounded in order to be genuinely curious.
- 54:40Hey, how's your day? Tell me what's going on here in your room.
- 54:44Or if you feel so bold, hey, I'm noticing your room seems a little bit disheveled.
- 54:48Help me understand what's going on for you today. Because you might learn that
- 54:51they had a brutal test. They might have had a fight with a friend,
- 54:53or they're just feeling overwhelmed.
- 54:55And now it doesn't excuse the mess, but now you're in a conversation instead
- 54:59of a power struggle. Tell me more, help me understand.
- 55:01In that scenario in particular, parenting becomes the long game, if we're being honest.
- 55:05Now let's talk about that in the context of marriage. Your partner walks in
- 55:09and they don't greet you and you react.
- 55:13No kiss, no hey, or are we not even doing eye contact now?
- 55:16So your brain probably jumps in with that observation. You make a judgment,
- 55:20they're mad at me. And you might even say that out loud. Okay, what did I do this time?
- 55:24What is going on so much that you can't even say hi to me?
- 55:26So maybe even, I don't know, slam a drawer or you, now make it about you and
- 55:31huff and puff your way out of the room.
- 55:33Passive aggressive. That's mind reading. That's magical thinking.
- 55:37That's emotional immaturity. Now, curiosity would look like this.
- 55:39Hey, you seemed quiet when you came in. How was your day? Take me on your train
- 55:43of thought. One of my favorite phrases.
- 55:45Is everything okay? Now, you may discover that they're just in their own head
- 55:48about work. It's not about you. They may not be angry at all about you.
- 55:53They could be ruminating or overthinking. And,
- 55:57The tension then has this potential to lift almost instantly and you didn't
- 56:01have to read their mind or play defense.
- 56:03What can be difficult is if you are an anxiously attached person like myself,
- 56:07it can be difficult to not check in if they aren't completely better in your
- 56:11opinion in five or 10 minutes.
- 56:13That's when you're going to want to check yourself and not continue to say, are you sure?
- 56:18Because you sure seem like you're still off. I have to trust that I provided
- 56:22them space to engage or talk with me. And if that is something that they don't
- 56:27feel safe doing or want to do right now, that's okay because we're playing the
- 56:31long game. We're in a relationship here.
- 56:33Let's turn it into the workplace setting. So you're in a meeting and a project
- 56:37that you worked on gets brought up, but only your coworker gets credit.
- 56:41And so then you stew all day. That guy's trying to make me look bad.
- 56:45I can't believe that no one noticed
- 56:48that I did anything about that or how could he take all that credit?
- 56:51That's emotional fusion. I'm wanting these people to recognize my efforts and
- 56:55I don't want them to think this or I don't want to say it because I don't want
- 56:59them to think that I'm being an egomaniac or so I'm managing people's emotions.
- 57:03I'm wanting somebody to read my mind.
- 57:06Now, what would curiosity look like? Hey, I noticed the project came up in the
- 57:10meeting and I didn't hear my name
- 57:11mentioned. Can we talk about how we're presenting things moving forward?
- 57:14You're not accusing, you're clarifying, you're not demanding,
- 57:17you're trying to have a dialogue. That does not guarantee that the other person
- 57:20is going to say, oh my gosh, you're so right.
- 57:22But at some point you're beginning to be more curious and learn to be grounded
- 57:27in these interactions because that's the person that you want to be.
- 57:31Let's talk about an interaction with a neighbor. You wave at your neighbor,
- 57:34then wave back. Maybe that's been a pattern over time. You begin to think,
- 57:38man, what's their problem?
- 57:39So then you avoid, and I'll show them. I'm not going to wave at them for a while
- 57:42either. And then they will see something.
- 57:45Curiosity might even be going over and approaching them.
- 57:48And hey, I waved and said hi, and I didn't see, it seemed like you looked at
- 57:53me and didn't wave back, which is fine, but I'm so curious. How are you doing?
- 57:57Is everything okay? Or what's going on in your life?
- 58:00This is based on a real story. And in that scenario, the guy didn't have his glasses on.
- 58:05Honestly, he was a little bit older. He also didn't have his hearing aids in.
- 58:07And so that helped my client make a lot more sense of what was happening.
- 58:11But I've had situations as well where somebody was grieving a loss or they honestly didn't see you.
- 58:15But either way, you were able to not only just clear the air so that you didn't
- 58:19sit there and make up stories and ruminate, but you also were able to have a
- 58:24genuine connection with another human.
- 58:27Curiosity is a muscle and you have
- 58:29to practice it curiosity isn't passive it's not
- 58:32pretending that everything's fine it's not avoiding conflict
- 58:36curiosity is it's a maturity skill and
- 58:38it takes regulation it takes reflection and it takes a lot of reps it's saying
- 58:43i may not know the full story but i care enough about myself and this other
- 58:48person to find out and like any skill it's going to be pretty wobbly at first
- 58:52and it might be wobbly for quite some time because you'll still fall into these
- 58:55old patterns. You'll overcorrect.
- 58:56You'll catch yourself sometimes mid-reaction and wish you could rewind.
- 59:00And while you can't literally pull a Superman and go around the globe backwards
- 59:04a few times and rewind time, you can ask for a do-over. That's okay. It's growth.
- 59:09Because over time, the fact that you're aware of this, the fact that you're
- 59:13trying to be more genuinely curious and you're getting these reps in,
- 59:16then you'll start to notice when the story in your head isn't really matching the moment.
- 59:21And you'll be able to catch these assumptions before they even escape your mouth.
- 59:25Staying grounded is such a key component of being more genuinely curious.
- 59:30If you can stay grounded long enough to learn to respond.
- 59:34Instead of react. And that's where you begin to lead with curiosity.
- 59:38And what it feels like to be you is I am genuinely curious.
- 59:41I have my thoughts, I have my opinions, but I really want to know.
- 59:44I really want to understand what this other person's experience is.
- 59:47And before we wrap this up, I do want to throw a couple of acceptance and commitment
- 59:51therapy tools in here that I think are important.
- 59:53Your brain's job is narrating. It's to narrate, it's to judge, it's to predict.
- 59:58That's not a flaw. It's just wiring. It's just the way it is.
- 1:00:02But the challenge is if you believe every thought that you have is true,
- 1:00:06now you're at the mercy of that script and your brain is just going to think
- 1:00:09a whole lot of words, a whole lot of thoughts.
- 1:00:12Instead of things like, man, I'm just so awkward. Everybody thinks I'm annoying.
- 1:00:16It is very powerful just to put a little bit of space there.
- 1:00:19Oh, check that out. I'm noticing I'm having the thought that I'm awkward.
- 1:00:21And the story my brain is telling me is that people find me annoying.
- 1:00:25It creates space. It slows the spiral. It gives you a chance to step back and
- 1:00:28say, is that helpful? Is that a productive thought or is it just the familiar?
- 1:00:32And in ACT, there's a concept called self as context.
- 1:00:36One of the best ways to think about this is you're the sky. You're not the weather.
- 1:00:40You are not your anxiety. You are not your worst day. You're not your best performance.
- 1:00:44You're not even the role that you're playing right now, a parent or partner,
- 1:00:47me as a therapist, podcaster, friend.
- 1:00:49You're the one observing it all. Your thoughts and feelings,
- 1:00:52they are the weather. They roll in, they roll out.
- 1:00:54You, you are the big, beautiful sky. And when you remember that,
- 1:00:59curiosity comes a lot easier because you're no longer defending the storm,
- 1:01:02you're watching it, you're learning from it and choosing how to respond to it.
- 1:01:06And that way you can attach more meaning to the parts of the weather that you
- 1:01:10really appreciate and you can tolerate the parts that you don't.
- 1:01:15Because another key concept in acceptance and commitment therapy is this conversation.
- 1:01:19Term psychological flexibility. It is about growing in real time.
- 1:01:23Because I cannot stress enough, every single moment is new.
- 1:01:27Every conversation that you're having is the first time you're ever having that
- 1:01:30conversation, even if the words sound familiar and the person is the same.
- 1:01:34It is uncharted territory. You've never been this version of you in this very
- 1:01:39moment with this person right now before.
- 1:01:43Because when you maybe were talking to this person in the past, It was in the past.
- 1:01:47So of course, you don't need to have all the answers, but your brain is this
- 1:01:52predictive engine and it is seeking certainty.
- 1:01:55And so it is going to start to make predictions. Psychological flexibility says,
- 1:01:59I'm going to stay with what's here right now. I'm going to accept what I feel
- 1:02:02and I will make this choice, this choice point and choose my next move based
- 1:02:07on who I want to be, not what I want to avoid.
- 1:02:10And that's where the work becomes, the good work. That's where the emotional maturity lives.
- 1:02:15I've got my four pillars of a connected conversation. And one thing that I don't
- 1:02:19talk enough about is when I'm working with individuals, I will call it the one
- 1:02:22person four pillared conversation.
- 1:02:23So even if the other person that you're interacting with isn't equipped with
- 1:02:26these tools, you can be, you can still show up with the four pillars.
- 1:02:29You can provide somebody the benefit of the doubt or that there's a reason why
- 1:02:32they are showing up this way or they're saying the things that they're saying,
- 1:02:35which allows you to then accept their perspective. Their view makes sense to them.
- 1:02:39My pillar two, you cannot tell somebody else that that is ridiculous,
- 1:02:42wrong, or I don't believe them. Even if I think what they're saying is ridiculous,
- 1:02:46I do believe it's wrong and I don't believe them because that is their perspective.
- 1:02:51That is their view, which then leads to pillar three, which is questions before comments.
- 1:02:55Now's your time to seek to understand. Here's where the genuine curiosity comes from.
- 1:02:59It's asking more. It's trying to understand. It's putting my ego aside.
- 1:03:04It's reacting less. It's responding more.
- 1:03:07And then fourth pillar, not going into any kind of victim mindset or victim mentality.
- 1:03:11I'm going to embrace the conversation. I'm going to stay in it. I'm not going to tap out.
- 1:03:15So if I go to someone and I say, hey, tell me about your day.
- 1:03:20Help me understand what's been going on for you. And they say,
- 1:03:22I've really been in my head.
- 1:03:24And I just, it seems like nobody's there for me. and that is hard for you because
- 1:03:28you're literally right here for them right now.
- 1:03:31I'm assuming good intentions. I'm giving them that benefit of the doubt.
- 1:03:34I'm accepting that their view of what is going on right now is their view.
- 1:03:38So I'm not gonna tell them they're wrong. And then I'm gonna go into that third pillar.
- 1:03:42I am going to say, tell me more, help me understand. What's that feel like for you?
- 1:03:46And as they express themselves, now I'm understanding more about them and I'm
- 1:03:49gonna stay present, pillar four.
- 1:03:51Now, at that point, when they feel heard, then I
- 1:03:54can say I appreciate you sharing that
- 1:03:57that helps me understand you I think one of the traps
- 1:03:59we're into is they're saying I know exactly how you feel which nobody truly
- 1:04:03knows exactly how we feel but I'm a I'm grateful that
- 1:04:05you've shared that with me and that helps me understand your experience more
- 1:04:08now first of all that does sound difficult and how can I show up for you because
- 1:04:12sometimes when you put it that way somebody can say things like I guess I just
- 1:04:16really need to be heard or I really do want your opinion on what you if they
- 1:04:21say think I should do then that's Well,
- 1:04:23I can give you my opinion on what I'm assuming that I would do if I were you
- 1:04:28in that situation, but I don't know what it feels like to be you.
- 1:04:31But all of that comes from a place of leading with curiosity.
- 1:04:33You are holding on to yourself. You stay differentiated.
- 1:04:36And even if the other person doesn't meet you there, you will walk away knowing
- 1:04:40that you showed up the best way that you could.
- 1:04:43More emotionally mature, kind, clear.
- 1:04:46Let's wrap this thing up. True vulnerability means, it does mean owning what
- 1:04:50you assume. Sometimes the most vulnerable thing that you can say is.
- 1:04:53Hey, I think I made an assumption here. I assumed that you meant this.
- 1:04:57Or I thought I understood, but I might have missed something.
- 1:05:00I would love to hear you. I would love for you to be able to clarify.
- 1:05:03Or I was so sure I was right, but I am so open to hearing more.
- 1:05:07Because that kind of vulnerability builds trust. It doesn't weaken your authority.
- 1:05:11It earns your respect. Because curiosity does not mean giving up your voice.
- 1:05:14It means making room for someone else's. And that's where emotional connection
- 1:05:18starts to begin. And let me give you just a couple of takeaways that you can
- 1:05:22leave today and start to do.
- 1:05:24Catch your reaction. And if you can, name the thought.
- 1:05:27Start paying attention to your initial reaction in these moments of tension.
- 1:05:30The next time that you feel defensive or dismissed or rejected,
- 1:05:32pause and ask yourself, what is this story my brain's telling me right now?
- 1:05:36And try to use the language like, I'm noticing that I'm having a thought that
- 1:05:41they don't respect me instead of, they don't respect me.
- 1:05:44Or, oh, check that out. I'm noticing that I'm starting to feel anger instead of I'm angry.
- 1:05:49That simple shift helps you step back from the thought and it does start to
- 1:05:53open doors to curiosity instead of reactivity.
- 1:05:56And I would highly recommend that you practice this one person four pillar conversation.
- 1:06:00Choose an interaction this week, maybe with a partner or a child,
- 1:06:02a coworker, or even the neighbor who didn't wave and then intentionally walk
- 1:06:06through the four pillars.
- 1:06:06Give that person the benefit of the doubt or there's a reason why they're doing
- 1:06:09what they're doing. Accept their perspective because it's valid to them.
- 1:06:12And if you are telling them that isn't what I said or that isn't what I remember,
- 1:06:17then I've just told them what their experience is wrong.
- 1:06:19Now, I can still hold on to what my experience was, but first I want to seek
- 1:06:24to understand them with an open-ended question.
- 1:06:26And I'm going to embrace the conversation instead of shutting down,
- 1:06:30instead of trying to avoid it.
- 1:06:31And then even if the other person doesn't reciprocate, notice how different
- 1:06:34you feel when you lead with emotional maturity and you lead with curiosity.
- 1:06:38And maybe the most difficult thing, but it could be the most powerful,
- 1:06:43is say the vulnerable thing.
- 1:06:44At least once or twice this week, practice real humility by saying one thing
- 1:06:47that reflects emotional ownership. And that might sound like,
- 1:06:50I think I made an assumption or, hey, that's on me, my bad.
- 1:06:54Or I might not have been seeing this because clearly, can you help me understand?
- 1:06:57I really want to know you or that's on me.
- 1:07:00I thought I was being clear, but I'm sure that something that I said might have
- 1:07:06been taken the wrong way.
- 1:07:08Saying something that shows openness and a willingness to be wrong builds trust
- 1:07:12and it reinforces the identity of somebody who values growth over their ego.
- 1:07:18Okay, hey, thank you for sticking with me. That's all I have for you today.
- 1:07:21If you ever caught yourself asking a question with a little bit of an edge or
- 1:07:24hoping the other person gives you the right answer so that you feel better,
- 1:07:26just remember you, you are not alone.
- 1:07:29That's part of being a human being, but you can start to shift it.
- 1:07:32And that shift starts with being curious, genuinely curious.
- 1:07:35I would be grateful if you subscribe and leave reviews and share this with somebody
- 1:07:39who you think might benefit from maybe softening their questions into true, genuine curiosity.
- 1:07:45Until next time, I encourage you all keep showing up with presence. Be present.
- 1:07:50Not necessarily feeling like you have to protect that ego. Be curious.
- 1:07:54And I will see you next time on the Virtual Catch.
- 1:07:59Music.