Latest / The Lila Rose Show / E33: Change, Surgery, and Regret, A Story of Detransition with Chloe Cole
Transcript
- 0:00If somebody just told me like, this isn't going to make you
- 0:02into a boy, and there's no guarantee that doing any of this
- 0:06is going to resolve your distress, you're perfect as you
- 0:09are as a woman. The issue isn't your body, it's
- 0:13the way that you think of it. And no matter what you do, what
- 0:16you do to yourself, what drugs you take, what, what surgeries
- 0:19you get, you're always going to be a woman and you are enough.
- 0:23I won't be dealing with any of this right now.
- 0:25Did anyone say that to you? Chloe, thanks for coming on the
- 0:37podcast. Yeah, thank you for having me.
- 0:39I've admired you from afar, I think for the last maybe almost
- 0:42a year since you started really do it being public with your
- 0:44advocacy. So I'm excited for the
- 0:47conversation today. So First off, I think you and I
- 0:51have a lot actually in common being we're both from California
- 0:55and similar area. So tell me about where you're
- 0:57from and how you grew up. Yeah.
- 0:59So I'm from the the Central Valley area of California.
- 1:02I'm from Antica and born and raised there.
- 1:06Never never really been out of the area.
- 1:10And what was your what was life like growing up for you?
- 1:16I mean, I'm the youngest of the five kids.
- 1:19I've got two older sisters, two older brothers, and so I kind of
- 1:22had influence from both sexes, but I was a kind of in between
- 1:26on being like a girly girl and a tomboy in a lot of ways.
- 1:29Like I like playing dress up with my older sisters and
- 1:32pretending that we were characters from shows.
- 1:34And I loved when they would put makeup on me and I stole like
- 1:41their their Bratz dolls and their Barbie dolls and stuff.
- 1:43And I also like playing video games with my older brothers and
- 1:47and playing outside and getting dirty.
- 1:53I I've always kind of been on technology using the Internet,
- 2:02and part of that is I kind of struggled a lot socially growing
- 2:09up, especially as I got older, hit purity and went into middle
- 2:13school. I was bullied quite a bit in
- 2:17elementary school and after one school year when I finally
- 2:21managed to, to make friends, I was back at square one because I
- 2:26had to move neighborhoods and then move schools.
- 2:28And that was when all my older siblings started to move out.
- 2:32There's a pretty significant age gap between me and my older
- 2:34siblings, about 7 to 8 years. So I for a lot of my childhood,
- 2:39I was kind of almost like an only, only child.
- 2:42And so I just turned to the Internet.
- 2:45And what was the Internet? What was that like?
- 2:47Turning to the Internet, what happened?
- 2:50I mean, mostly when I first started, before I got a phone, I
- 2:54got my first computer when I was about nine years old.
- 2:58It was a pre built like gaming computer that my dad had for a
- 3:01while and they're just kind of sitting around.
- 3:02He didn't really have any use for it and so he just decided to
- 3:06to give it to me. And I like doing artwork on
- 3:11there. I started with Microsoft Paint
- 3:13in a mouse and then eventually one year for Christmas, I got a
- 3:17giant a drawing tablet and I was really into communities having
- 3:22to do with artwork. And I also watched, I played
- 3:26video games on my PC and I watched streamers and I mean, I
- 3:31was kind of a nerd. So I, I really like stuff like
- 3:33that. And I was really interested in
- 3:35online communities having to do with stuff with that.
- 3:37So when I got my first phone, I mean, everybody else my age was,
- 3:44was using the cell phone. Many of them had gotten phones
- 3:49as young as like second grade. How old were you at?
- 3:51This I was 11 and now everybody's using social media
- 3:56apps like Instagram and Snapchat.
- 3:58And so I wanted to see, yeah, I wanted to see what I was missing
- 4:02out on. So of course I decided to make
- 4:04my first accounts on on those platforms.
- 4:07And Instagram was the one that I used the most.
- 4:11It was the most engaging to me because I mean, it's very image
- 4:14oriented and because I like seeing, I like browsing
- 4:17communities around like art and the shows and anime that I
- 4:23watched and manga and video games that I played.
- 4:29And that was actually my introduction to the trans
- 4:32community. It wasn't right away.
- 4:34It wasn't directly into that, into the LGBT community, but a
- 4:38lot of users in these communities were people who
- 4:42identified as LGBT and especially like transgender or
- 4:45non binary. And many of those individuals
- 4:49were girls around my age, anywhere from like 12 to maybe
- 4:55like their early 20s. And these people were quite like
- 4:59me and that they were kind of nerdy, had always been on the
- 5:04boys side from a very young age and often feel like they didn't
- 5:07really fit in and they're opposed.
- 5:09They would make that were sometimes just not really
- 5:12related to the media that we were that they were that they're
- 5:16offensive. It was about take their personal
- 5:18lives. And I just felt like I really in
- 5:23some way that I connected to these people.
- 5:25Had you? Did you?
- 5:25Had you known anyone like that in school, or had you ever met
- 5:28anyone like that? No, I, I knew there was a girl I
- 5:33knew who was a lesbian. But other than that, it was
- 5:37really new to me because I, I've, I heard the, the word
- 5:40transgender a few times being used by like adults in their
- 5:45conversations or on the TV, but I never really cared about it.
- 5:49And so it was in my face. So what was the moment when you
- 5:54first began to think, well, maybe I'm transgender?
- 5:58Yeah, I mean, I was 11-12 years old, so I was already at a point
- 6:05in time where naturally I started to to wonder about what
- 6:12I wanted to be in the world, who I was and what my role would be.
- 6:18And at first it started with, well, I've always kind of liked
- 6:25girls a little bit. So maybe I'm not entirely
- 6:28straight, maybe I'm bisexual or or pansexual.
- 6:32And then eventually I just kept switching between labels, trying
- 6:37to figure out which one felt right.
- 6:39And it wasn't just about my sexuality or who I, who I like
- 6:44now, it was about my gender. Because I mean, I never really
- 6:48100% felt like the other girls, you know, I had, I had different
- 6:54interests from them. I acted differently from them
- 6:57and I felt like I even looked differently from them.
- 7:00I had somebody image issues. I started developing at a really
- 7:04young age. I was around 8 or 9, just going
- 7:07into 4th grade when my breasts started to visibly develop and I
- 7:11had to start wearing bras. And that was a really, that was
- 7:14a really difficult thing for me to adjust to, especially at a
- 7:17young age. I grew up with older sisters.
- 7:23So I would, sometimes I would see them watching shows or like
- 7:28they would have magazines around that were very like, I would
- 7:31often talk about things like relationships or like having
- 7:38like having how you, how you look.
- 7:40And so from a very young age, I was very cognizant of of things
- 7:45like that. And I often felt like I just
- 7:47couldn't match up to these images that I would see in the
- 7:50media. And social media was really
- 7:51exacerbating that, especially on Instagram, where there's a lot
- 7:54of images of girls wearing a lot of makeup, wearing bikinis and
- 7:59very sexualized poses and in situations.
- 8:04And on one hand, I didn't really want to be like that, but it was
- 8:09also like, if that's what being a girl is supposed to be like,
- 8:13why aren't I like that? I, I just don't think I match up
- 8:17to other women. And I mean, I thought that all
- 8:25being a woman had to offer was just hardship because that was
- 8:29all that I was taught. I would always hear about how
- 8:32how terrible periods are, how scary the possibility of getting
- 8:37pregnant and then actually being pregnant, and then how painful
- 8:40childbirth is, and then how scary menopause is and other
- 8:46girls accounts of being sexually abused or assaulted or stopped
- 8:52growing up. And it got to the point that I
- 8:55was like, well, is something like that going to happen to me
- 9:00when I'm an adult? Is, is this all that being a
- 9:06woman chalks up to? If it is, then I I don't want
- 9:09any part of that. It's a pretty bum deal if that
- 9:14is all it is. And why would anyone want part
- 9:16of that? I thought it was.
- 9:19So you're online, you're seeing this other, you know, you're
- 9:23seeing people that say they're transgender online doing part of
- 9:26the art that you love and video games and things that you're
- 9:29already interested in. And you're having this sort of
- 9:32interior maybe conflict about what it means to even be a
- 9:35woman. So what happens next?
- 9:41Yeah. So as I know further and further
- 9:46into the trans community and saw what it was all about, I wasn't
- 9:50really up until after the beginning of my medical
- 9:56transition, I wasn't really interacting directly with any
- 9:59individuals within the community.
- 10:01But I started seeing things about how people have sex
- 10:07sprints, how if somebody experiences gender dysphoria or
- 10:14even acts more like the opposite sex, then that probably means
- 10:20that very likely means actually that they have a brain that is
- 10:23more like the opposite sex. And that is what's making them
- 10:25feel that way or behave that way.
- 10:27And, you know, there's always I, I always felt like there was
- 10:31something separating me from other kids my age and especially
- 10:34other roles. And the more I read up into it,
- 10:38the more it made sense to me. And eventually I just felt like
- 10:44there's just no way that I could be a girl.
- 10:46I think that I was actually supposed to be a boy this whole
- 10:50time. And did you?
- 10:56I'm going to, I'm going to start pursuing that.
- 10:57And. Did you feel very unhappy during
- 10:59that time? Like you, you said you wanted to
- 11:02figure out as an 11 year old, like what is, what's my role in
- 11:05the world or how do I, what is my future like?
- 11:08Did you feel like a deep discontent or unhappiness or
- 11:11anxiety? Or what was that feeling like as
- 11:13you were having that logical progression of, well, if these
- 11:16things don't add up and this is what this, you know, research
- 11:19says, then I or these people online are saying, and this
- 11:22means that I must be, I must not be a girl.
- 11:26But what was going on inside your, your, I guess your
- 11:28emotions in your heart? I mean, I was at a new school.
- 11:32I'd been there for a few years, but I just didn't really fit in
- 11:35and it was kind of cliquey and I didn't really have a lot of
- 11:40close friends. So I was, I was kind of lonely.
- 11:44But I feel like that's pretty normal at that age.
- 11:51I think most kids that age feel like that.
- 11:55So when you after you went through this sort of thought
- 11:58process, what did you do with, what did you do with the
- 12:00conclusion that you reached? I'm a boy.
- 12:05I thought that I believe that I was actually a boy and that I
- 12:13was actually my parents son and not their daughter.
- 12:17And so I started pursuing that and I started to experiment a
- 12:23little with my expression, started cutting my hair shorter
- 12:26slowly and slowly over time. Whenever I'd go shopping, I'd
- 12:30start going for the boys section more often.
- 12:34And I mean, it wasn't unusual for me to do that, but I was
- 12:40trying. I was starting to get rid of all
- 12:42my skirts and dresses and pinks and bright colors and swap it
- 12:47out for a more masculine wardrobe.
- 12:49And I started telling my some of my friends, my closer friends at
- 12:57school, that I was going to transition, that I wanted to, I
- 13:04wanted them to refer to me by a new name, by new pronouns and as
- 13:07a boy. And most of them actually
- 13:10responded pretty negatively. The the love bombing didn't
- 13:13really come right away. The affirmation didn't really
- 13:16come right away and I actually got bullied for a little bit.
- 13:21There are a lot of people who picked on me for it, but I
- 13:26waited a little bit and tell my parents about it because I, I
- 13:30was really, I was scared of how they would react.
- 13:34I didn't know if they were going to be supportive of me doing
- 13:38this, but I knew that I, I mean, if I wanted to go through
- 13:44transition, I couldn't keep them in in the dark for long.
- 13:48What was it like telling your parents?
- 13:51It was something that I'd been wanting to do for some time, but
- 13:56I just wasn't sure of how they would react.
- 13:59I didn't know if, I mean, I'd heard stories from from other
- 14:03transgender people about their their parents almost hating them
- 14:08after they told them that they were transgender.
- 14:12Even some kids getting, getting kicked out or moving to a new
- 14:17home and just being in a really rough home situation.
- 14:21And I didn't really expect anything like that out of out of
- 14:24my own parents. I knew that they would love me
- 14:26still, but it made it a little bit more tense.
- 14:30And so I decided that I would write them a letter so that I
- 14:35didn't have to bring it up face to face that I could give them
- 14:39some time to, to think about it. Because I, I knew that as a
- 14:43parent, that's got to be a hard thing to hear from your own kid.
- 14:47I don't think anybody would really expect that.
- 14:51So I gave them some time. I just told them that I had
- 14:54something important tell them that I left on the coffee table.
- 14:56And I was looking forward to how they would respond.
- 15:02And when they read it, they were, they were supportive at
- 15:08first. They wanted me to, they wanted
- 15:12to be supportive of me. And to help me get through this.
- 15:17But at the same time, they were also very cautious and they
- 15:23didn't really know where this feeling was coming from.
- 15:28They didn't know what to do about this.
- 15:31So they decided that, I mean, we're not experts on this, so
- 15:36we're going to get a professional involved instead
- 15:39and we're going to get you a therapist.
- 15:43And did you go to a therapist? Yeah, I did.
- 15:46This was the first time you were going to you.
- 15:48You've been to therapy? Yeah, I mean, I, I've been to a
- 15:52psychiatrist before I was a kid and gotten diagnosed with ADHD
- 15:57before, but not like a like a personal therapist or anything
- 16:03like that. Did you feel like you still had
- 16:04ADHD at this point and how is that affecting you?
- 16:11I mean, I didn't doubt the diagnosis for a while.
- 16:17I was a kid who was pretty inattentive in a lot of my
- 16:19classes. I didn't often just skipped out
- 16:21on my school work and didn't really pay attention because I
- 16:25just didn't really see any meaning in in doing doing any of
- 16:29it. And I, I had, I had really bad
- 16:37organization skills growing up and it's still something that I
- 16:41kind of struggle with. But I also had some social
- 16:46difficulties growing up, which I've I've heard is common for
- 16:49people with ADHD. But it was really hard for me
- 16:52growing up. And I thought that, I think part
- 16:56of it is that I was so heavily pathologized as a kid that I
- 16:59just accepted that all of my, my hardships came down to clinical
- 17:05issues. But I think that I think now
- 17:09that the ADHD diagnosis was actually false and that I'm
- 17:14actually on the spectrum, but they just refused to to diagnose
- 17:21me with it. Almost like the word is word
- 17:23autism is too scary to say out loud.
- 17:26Like I, I had a screening for it when I was about four or five
- 17:31because I wasn't really my teachers in preschool and
- 17:35kindergarten noticed that I wasn't really interacting
- 17:37normally with other kids and that I was kind of just aloof
- 17:40and in my own world. And I had some symptoms of it
- 17:45that they thought was, they told my parents like, you should
- 17:48probably get your, your kid. You should probably get a
- 17:51screening for your kid. And they did.
- 17:54And the physician just told them, I think your kids too
- 18:00smart to be on the spectrum. She's she's very smart.
- 18:03She's very smart for age. It's so crazy because so many
- 18:07autistic people with autism can be so smart.
- 18:11Right. And so.
- 18:13That's just kind of a a weird thing to say.
- 18:15Yeah, I had a second series of screenings when I was 17 years
- 18:21old, and it was pretty much the same response.
- 18:24Like, well, you're really well spoken and you're really
- 18:27intelligent. It's it's not impossible, it's a
- 18:33possibility, but let's let's wait a little bit.
- 18:37What blows my mind with all this, and we're obviously going
- 18:39to get into like what happens with this crazy thing that you
- 18:42endured with Kaiser and, and, and all of that, But even what
- 18:45you just said earlier, you felt pathologized.
- 18:48It was like very insightful what you said, like you felt
- 18:51pathologized as a kid. I think the words you used and I
- 18:55think our society is so unable to deal with just people that
- 19:01are just different. Like we have this expectation of
- 19:04the way you have to be. So if you just act different
- 19:06socially, because I grew up homeschooled, I grew up because
- 19:09kind of like, you know, a nerd among nerds.
- 19:11My dad, you know, my mom jokes, my dad might be on the spectrum,
- 19:14you know, things like that. And it's like, I don't know if
- 19:16that's a joke, but he's just highly bright and a little bit,
- 19:19you know, interact socially, just different than other
- 19:21people. And just like all this
- 19:23pathologizing of kids just because they're different when
- 19:26everyone's different in different ways, right?
- 19:29So not to like over generalize, but I think we do our disservice
- 19:32to kids and authentic diversity like diversity of personality
- 19:38and talent by making medical issues out of all of it, you
- 19:43know, calling all a medical. Issue Yeah.
- 19:44And I was also diagnosed with disruptive behavior disorder.
- 19:51What does that mean? Well, for me, I mean, I really
- 19:56struggled with making friends and I was getting bullied quite
- 20:00a bit in elementary school. And I would often take it out
- 20:02physically on my bullies. I would often hit them, like
- 20:05push them to the ground, like throw things at them.
- 20:09I would often throw tantrums in class and I didn't really know
- 20:13how to emotionally regulate myself.
- 20:14And I would take it out externally I guess.
- 20:18How old are you? I was, I think like 5 to 8 years
- 20:22old when when I was like that. Do you think if you hadn't been
- 20:28bullied and if you had been in a learning environment that was
- 20:31more suited to you, where you weren't feeling bored all the
- 20:34time, you would have? Is obviously a huge
- 20:36hypothetical, but you would have.
- 20:38You might not have acted out as much.
- 20:40Absolutely. Because you were just forced to
- 20:42sit in the classroom with your bullies.
- 20:44Yeah. And you're like, this is boring.
- 20:46Yeah, that was that was a big part of it.
- 20:48I didn't really feel like I had much of A community and I didn't
- 20:50because my older siblings were so much older than me.
- 20:53Like I didn't, I felt like I just didn't really have anybody
- 20:56to relate to. And I growing up, I felt like
- 20:59there was something wrong with me.
- 21:01Like I, I thought as a kid even that I was evil and that's why
- 21:05nobody liked me. It probably also didn't help
- 21:10that they started medicating me for my for my ADHD diagnosis
- 21:14when I was about 11:10 or 11:00. What kind of medication it was.
- 21:19They started with long release medication but they're
- 21:23constantly switching me between meds.
- 21:24Like different doses, different different medications.
- 21:28To try to get you to what do your homework.
- 21:30Yeah. You just didn't like your
- 21:34homework. I didn't.
- 21:35The screen was more entertaining.
- 21:37I'd rather I'd rather draw or play video games.
- 21:39I had. I had.
- 21:40Should have been homeschooled. I had sketches all over my
- 21:43school work all the time and I always get in trouble for it.
- 21:45Because you're an artist. Right.
- 21:47And sometimes I my teachers would even get me in trouble for
- 21:49it like they would I would get like a perfect score on a test
- 21:52but I would Draw Something silly on the side of it and they would
- 21:56just give me a 0 for it. No way.
- 21:58Yeah, and I also wasn't allowed to draw outside because it was
- 22:02dangerous to have a pencil out of out of the classroom.
- 22:07What school did you go to? I I won't name the school but.
- 22:14It was a public school. Yeah, it was.
- 22:16And it was kind of California. Yeah, it was very, it was kind
- 22:19of out in the country, but it was one of the oldest schools in
- 22:21the district and they were kind of kind of stingy, very clicky.
- 22:27So you weren't allowed to color outside meaning or to draw
- 22:30outside meaning? If you wanted to take your art
- 22:32notebook and do sketching of a tree, you weren't allowed to do
- 22:36that. Yeah, because why?
- 22:38Because it's dangerous to have a pencil.
- 22:40What if I What if I get stabbed in the eye?
- 22:43How old are you? The school that said that I went
- 22:49there from 5th to to 8th grade. So you're like 11 years old.
- 22:56Yeah. Wow.
- 22:57All right. So you're you're going through
- 22:59all this and you're basically feeling like you're different.
- 23:03Understandably so, because the world is asking you to be this
- 23:06particular kind of person that fits in this very rigid academic
- 23:12category and even I would say gender stereotype category
- 23:16because that you were saying it was magazines and makeup and
- 23:19this idea of like women are this way and because you're not that
- 23:23way, then maybe I'm not a woman. And eventually I did end up
- 23:26liking those things, but I mean, for a while I just didn't want
- 23:32anything to do with those things.
- 23:33And there's still a lot of, I feel like in in some ways, I
- 23:37still have some traditionally more masculine leaning
- 23:40behaviours. And it's just one of those many
- 23:48things that made me feel like there's something separating me
- 23:52from other women. Like I was just watching from
- 23:57the outside while the women got to.
- 23:59I felt like they got to interact with each other and relate to
- 24:02each other and I didn't feel like I was that way at all.
- 24:04So were you looking to fit in somewhere?
- 24:06Yeah, absolutely. And you thought I have a better
- 24:09shot of fitting in with the boys than the girls?
- 24:11Yeah, I mean, I also struggle to socialize with boys a little
- 24:18bit, but sometimes I found it easier to relate to like boys
- 24:24sense sense of humor and love their interests and even the way
- 24:30that we've we felt about about the world.
- 24:35Yeah, I think boys in a way can be easier to get along.
- 24:40I remember growing up, I mean, obviously there's a lot of
- 24:42differences, but I had a lot of brothers and it was like, for a
- 24:45while I didn't feel like I knew how to interact with girls.
- 24:48And I kind of figured it out. But because I didn't grow up
- 24:50with sisters, I didn't have a sister till I was nine years
- 24:53old, so. Yeah, I growing up, I had a kind
- 24:57of offensive sense of humor that a lot of girls just didn't
- 25:01really like it all. Meaning just jokes that were
- 25:05not. Yeah, little off colored.
- 25:09That's very funny from like being five years old.
- 25:11Off colored jokes were there. Did you have a favorite joke?
- 25:20Not a particular favorite joke, but I remember in kindergarten
- 25:26up to like first or second grade, we would have assignments
- 25:29where we would learn about important historical figures and
- 25:32we'd have to like, color them in.
- 25:34I'd like, I'd draw like band aids on their faces and like
- 25:39give them notes, give. Them noise run.
- 25:43Give them like give them like running makeup, blushing,
- 25:48Nosebleed, just ran just random stuff just like your.
- 25:53Teacher's like she's definitely a boy.
- 25:59Did you save any of that artwork?
- 26:02It's probably somewhere in my closet.
- 26:03It's pretty hilarious. OK, so you're just a very funny,
- 26:11quirky girl who's like tough and figuring out and smart and
- 26:15figuring out our place in the world.
- 26:16And then you end up with this therapist.
- 26:19Well, you went to the psychiatrist, you gave you the
- 26:21meds as an 8 year old because you don't like to sit in your
- 26:23chair all day and it's boring school.
- 26:25And then you end up, I'm not making fun of it.
- 26:27I'm just it, there's an absurdity to the way that our
- 26:30systems don't make space for diversity, quite frankly,
- 26:36diversity of personality and talent, I would call it anyway.
- 26:40So, but then you tell your parents, OK, I must be a boy and
- 26:42you're seeing the stuff on transgender stuff online and you
- 26:46can go to this therapist. Tell me, tell me what happens
- 26:48there and how old are you? Yeah, I was.
- 26:52I was. This was just before my 13th
- 26:56birthday so I was 12 going on 13 and by.
- 26:59The way have you started? You started puberty already
- 27:01because you started early. Yeah.
- 27:02So is that very uncomfortable? But I know for me puberty was
- 27:04very uncomfortable. Yeah, I was about three to four
- 27:07years in already and it was really uncomfortable because I
- 27:15there is like that stress of developing early and like
- 27:18knowing that other people can see these changes and that
- 27:21they'll have whatever thoughts about that and then feeling like
- 27:25I have to look a certain way and to meet a certain expectation.
- 27:29And also it was just, it's hard as a kid dealing with that sort
- 27:33of change and so rapidly. Did you feel?
- 27:36Did that come with a feeling of shame?
- 27:39Yeah, absolutely. On one hand, it was like, I'm
- 27:43really excited to develop and look pretty, but I also felt
- 27:46like that just wasn't happening, that I wasn't.
- 27:49I thought that my life was over because I didn't look like a
- 27:52supermodel at age 12, you know? So it's so toxic what the
- 27:58supermodel weirdo culture has done.
- 28:01Yeah, I mean, I grew up in the age of like.
- 28:04Because you're on Instagram. Yeah, Yeah.
- 28:06I grew up in the age where you're expected to be thick,
- 28:09curvy, have the big voluptuous body.
- 28:12And I just wasn't like that. You know, I was skinny, kind of
- 28:16on the athletic side. My breasts were pretty.
- 28:21They're a little bit on the smaller side.
- 28:22And my hips weren't very developed yet.
- 28:24And I mean, I was just a kid, but I didn't really understand
- 28:27that. But I also like having my hair
- 28:31short and I had bigger shoulders, a little bit of
- 28:33muscle. And sometimes what people would
- 28:36like, make comments about like the like how muscular I was.
- 28:41And I was really conscious of that.
- 28:43And I felt like I didn't even look like a woman.
- 28:47But I I'd been through several therapists over the years.
- 28:50The first one I had was especially lousy.
- 28:52He just didn't, really. This was after you told your
- 28:55parents I think I'm a boy. Yeah, I, I didn't, I didn't
- 28:58realize how much these these body image issues were bothering
- 29:00me. I mean, I think and for the
- 29:04women listening, I want to hear what they have to say in the
- 29:05comments about their experience with this.
- 29:07Because for me as a teen girl, when I first hit puberty,
- 29:10probably 11 years old or maybe 10 actually, I started.
- 29:14But I remember feeling so much shame when someone told my mom,
- 29:19Oh, Lila needs a bra because my breasts were developing.
- 29:21And instead of it feeling like, oh, this is a beautiful thing
- 29:25and every female, every woman's body is unique and I need to
- 29:28uniquely embrace mine. There was just like straight up
- 29:30shame. And when my period came shame.
- 29:34And that's not the way it's supposed to be or has to be.
- 29:37And I'm not saying it's my mom's fault or my parents fault.
- 29:39They, I was the first daughter. They were figuring out my, my
- 29:41mom, her experience of going through puberty growing up
- 29:44wasn't like, you know, done in the maybe the best way.
- 29:48And so there was just this inability to like, know how to
- 29:52deal with it. And so I developed an eating
- 29:54disorder because I started to hate my developing body.
- 29:57It didn't look the way I thought it should look.
- 29:58And so that's part of my story. And people can, you know, I've
- 30:01shared it before, But so I relate to those feelings.
- 30:04Obviously you have additional things going on too, but it's a
- 30:07vulnerable place to be in. Right.
- 30:10I mean, I wouldn't say that I was shamed for it, really.
- 30:17People didn't shame you, right? But you still felt.
- 30:20Shame, right? I still felt that.
- 30:21People shamed me either, but you feel ashamed because you don't
- 30:25know what to do with this experience.
- 30:26Yeah, I kind of my parents never really had like, the talk with
- 30:30me growing up. And I feel like if they just
- 30:34talked to me about it and they taught me about it, it would
- 30:36have helped greatly. Like, I know that's a really
- 30:38uncomfortable, almost kind of like compromising situation for
- 30:42both the parent and the kid, but it's important.
- 30:45Like growing up isn't comfortable.
- 30:49And there's like the parents who like who are hush hush about it,
- 30:53thinks it's shameful. And then on the other end of the
- 30:55spectrum, there's like the the adult woman who are like, oh,
- 30:58it's such a beautiful experience.
- 31:00It's going to feel great. Like, and you should be proud of
- 31:03it. You should put it up on a
- 31:05billboard, Yeah, that you're having periods and free bleed
- 31:10and whatever else, but. But maybe somewhere in between?
- 31:15Yeah. I mean, I think it's important
- 31:17to be objective about it because it's it's not going to feel
- 31:22great, but it's a necessary part of becoming an adult.
- 31:26And it's beautiful because it can bring your puberty at once
- 31:30you've sexually developed, can bring life into the world, can
- 31:33lead to like all of these beautiful things.
- 31:35It's all for a good reason. Yeah, and it, and it's, it's not
- 31:38supposed to have shame, but shame can be part of it because
- 31:40we're in a broken world navigating how to deal with our
- 31:43own emotions. But.
- 31:44It's just a part of our design. Yeah, yeah.
- 31:47I think that's a very like realist and mature and and
- 31:51loving view because it's actually like seeing the
- 31:54humanity of the person and their biology and accepting it instead
- 31:57of over dramatizing it in one way or the other basically.
- 32:04So what happened with this first therapist that you went to?
- 32:06What did you tell them? What did they tell?
- 32:07What did they tell you? Well, I mean, once gender was
- 32:11brought up and that was my focus because I didn't really realize
- 32:14just how much my other, the other things going on in my life
- 32:17were affecting me. It was like, oh, OK, so we're
- 32:21going to focus on that. What's your preferred name?
- 32:25What's your gender identity? What do you identify as, and
- 32:29what pronouns do you want us to refer to you as?
- 32:33So did the therapist explore with you whatsoever your
- 32:36discomfort with your with puberty and like just the
- 32:39process of becoming a woman because you're going through
- 32:45puberty still, Yeah. Now, now as a boy, I was feeling
- 32:50uncomfortable with the fact that I had a feminine form and that I
- 32:53was skinny and I didn't want to, I wanted to have more muscle.
- 32:57I didn't want my breasts to be visible.
- 32:58And I wanted I didn't want to have any curves whatsoever
- 33:04because I just wanted to look like all the other boys my age.
- 33:07And they're like, OK, so you have the stress around your
- 33:10secondary sex characteristics and you feel like you don't
- 33:14really fit in with other girls. You've always felt like you've
- 33:17been more boyish so. So there is no there is no
- 33:24exploration, I guess. Not at all.
- 33:26There's no exploration of other issues you had even as a child,
- 33:32your experience of being just different and challenged in
- 33:36connecting with most girls and many boys.
- 33:39It was more just that you came out to this therapist.
- 33:41You said I think I'm a boy or am a boy.
- 33:43And it was just accepted as fact, yeah.
- 33:48And they didn't. They didn't even.
- 33:49But it's curious that it's one thing to just accept it as fact,
- 33:52it's another thing to accept it as fact and not be interested to
- 33:54understand how you came to that conclusion.
- 33:58Yeah, I mean the things I would tell them, like around my
- 34:01discomfort, around my body and not not really fitting in.
- 34:04It was just accepted as part of me being a boy of my destiny.
- 34:10I find that peculiar. I'm curious your thoughts on
- 34:12this because it's almost like this to say, you know, for a
- 34:18young person to say I'm they're a girl and they say I'm a boy or
- 34:20they're a boy and they say I'm a girl and there's no, and the
- 34:24evidence for it is that they think it and that they're
- 34:26uncomfortable with their body, right?
- 34:29And then the therapist or the psychological, you know, this,
- 34:32the medical community just accepts it as a fact.
- 34:34It almost feels like a sort of like religious belief in this
- 34:41destiny belief that the child has or the person has like their
- 34:47destiny is. I think that's what it really
- 34:50comes down to, honestly. The belief in a gender identity
- 34:54isn't really too dissimilar from a belief in a soul and that it's
- 34:57like this in it. Part of a person or innate I
- 35:02should say. Yet it's disembodied, it's not
- 35:10actually a part of the body, and yet somehow it influences who
- 35:14the person really is. Yeah, it's a belief in a soul,
- 35:19in a different kind of soul that hates the body that it's been
- 35:22given. And then the therapist chooses
- 35:25and the medical community chooses to listen to this soul
- 35:29as opposed to the reality of the body and the person in front of
- 35:32them. So what happens next?
- 35:39Eventually I I became dissatisfied with my therapist
- 35:45because I had stuff going on at school and not home that he just
- 35:49wasn't really addressing at all. And like what I mean, I had all
- 35:56my electronics taken away for some time and.
- 36:00By your parents. Yeah, why it's happened so far
- 36:09back, I can't really remember the specific details.
- 36:11But no, I think it was because I had like AI had online friends
- 36:19and I gave some of them my number.
- 36:21And I guess like I got a text that was associated with some, I
- 36:29don't know, it was just some, some name that my dad, he just
- 36:31woke me up one day asking like who who this person was and why
- 36:39I was messaging them. And I didn't know who he was
- 36:42talking about. I guess it was like an old
- 36:44number associated with a different name.
- 36:46But I didn't want him to know that I had friends online that I
- 36:49gave them, that I gave out my number to them.
- 36:52And so I was very adamant about not letting him check my phone.
- 36:55They just decided to take it away.
- 36:57Because were they afraid? Do you think that you were
- 36:59talking to people that were maybe predators?
- 37:01Probably, yeah, do. You think that's a valid
- 37:03concern? Absolutely.
- 37:05I mean, I could have been in that situation.
- 37:06I actually was a few times over the years.
- 37:09In what situation? Speaking to to predators.
- 37:14How could you? How did you find out there were
- 37:16predators? I mean, I think a better way of
- 37:24wording that would be. Weirdos.
- 37:29Yeah, I mean, I, there were a few people online inside and
- 37:36outside the trans community that I, that I had like online
- 37:42relationships with. And many of them were much, much
- 37:44older than I was. That's a predator.
- 37:48Yeah. And your parents kind of were on
- 37:52to this a little bit. And so they're like, we're just
- 37:53going to cut this off because. Well, this is it's actually
- 37:55happened quite a while before that actually started to happen.
- 37:59Are these men that you were? Most of them were.
- 38:02So you're a girl who's having all these other issues, things
- 38:06you're experiencing. You're having is online
- 38:09relationships with these older men who are basically praying on
- 38:12probably your vulnerabilities on the Internet.
- 38:15And. But you still thought you were a
- 38:17boy at that point. Yeah.
- 38:19So did you think you were a gay boy?
- 38:21Yeah, I just, I mean, I was like they.
- 38:29Think you were a girl or a boy? My parents.
- 38:32No, no, the people, these, these relate these on these older men
- 38:35on the Internet. Well, they just affirmed my
- 38:39identity and just went along with me calling myself a boy.
- 38:42So they knew you were a young girl who was struggling with
- 38:45gender dysphoria. And do you, did you know
- 38:49anything about them? Do you think there there's a
- 38:50particular sort of psychological type you were talking to that
- 38:53found you particularly attractive because you were
- 38:56going through this? I mean, it was all sorts of
- 38:59different people, but a lot of them were identifying as LGBT.
- 39:03A lot of them called themselves like gay or bisexual.
- 39:05Some of them were trans identified males.
- 39:08And what does that mean? They're trans women.
- 39:12They call themselves they're they're biological males
- 39:14identify as women. So a biological male identifying
- 39:18as a woman who is attracted to a young woman identifying as a
- 39:22young boy. So it's still biological male to
- 39:26biological woman. It's just a very roundabout way
- 39:29of having a straight relationship, basically.
- 39:32It's a lot of work for a straight relationship.
- 39:35So how old were you when you had your first online relationship
- 39:38with somebody who was much older and how much older approximately
- 39:41were they? I was probably 14 ish 1314 and a
- 39:52lot of them weren't necessarily like relationships.
- 39:54Some of them were just like short, I guess you'd call them
- 39:58flings or like I would just like exchange like like sex or like
- 40:03nudes with them. And how old were they?
- 40:07Anywhere from like my age to like late teens, maybe early
- 40:1320s. There's actually one person who
- 40:16was he was in his mid 20s and he was in the military.
- 40:20OK. And, and in most of those cases
- 40:24where they it was all different kinds of men in like some men
- 40:28who identified as women, but otherwise just some were them
- 40:30for. The most part it was just, it
- 40:33was just men, OK, and a lot of them would call themselves like
- 40:36gay or bisexual, but. Because you thought you were a
- 40:39boy. Yeah, Yeah.
- 40:40I think that they kind of did that to lure me in a little bit,
- 40:44to ease me a little bit by affirming my addendi, but they
- 40:51were still attracted to women and it was just part of their
- 40:53ploy to exploit me sexually. Have you heard of
- 40:57autogynophilia? Yeah.
- 40:59What do you think about it? It's kind of a it's a very
- 41:03open-ended question. I mean, do you think that that
- 41:05it's a do you think that affected you or do you think
- 41:07that it affects a lot of people who struggle with gender
- 41:11dysphoria? I mean, I probably to an extent
- 41:15had like a female equivalent of it, which I guess would be
- 41:18called auto androphilia. I mean, I was mostly attracted
- 41:24to men, but sometimes I would have like fantasies where that
- 41:30that involved women and that I was the male in the situation
- 41:36and that might have been part of it.
- 41:41And I think that's really just like a normal part of, I
- 41:47wouldn't want to call it like exploration or experimentation,
- 41:51but I wouldn't say that's really something that's like clinically
- 41:54significant. But I also had research like
- 42:01medical transition and taking testosterone a little bit.
- 42:04And I really liked imagine the way that I would look on
- 42:10testosterone. I liked having, I was looking
- 42:13forward to like having more muscle and looking more
- 42:16masculine and having some of the changes of testosterone on my
- 42:19body. But none of that was really
- 42:25explored. Like they would ask like what my
- 42:28sexuality was, who I was attracted to, but they would
- 42:31never really, they would never really factor that into how that
- 42:36might affect my gender dysphoria or my desire to transition.
- 42:41They meaning the therapist. Yeah, and I was still mostly
- 42:45attracted to men, but I was just too young and too deluded to
- 42:50know how this would affect my ability to get into relationship
- 42:54with a man. Nobody had really brought that
- 42:56up with me. Meaning for you to transition
- 43:01and we're going to talk about what that what those exact steps
- 43:03were for you, but for you to transition.
- 43:04It was never really discussed what that would mean in a future
- 43:09relationship or even a marriage to a man.
- 43:11Yeah, I mean, but endocrinologist told me like
- 43:15while you might experience vaginal atrophy, she told us to
- 43:20a 13 year old expecting her to know what that meant.
- 43:22And what I knew of it was like, OK, it causes the walls, the
- 43:30lining of the vagina to thin out a little bit and dry out a
- 43:33little bit and not produce as much lubrication.
- 43:35And it might cause some pain if I were ever to have sex, but
- 43:39that's OK because I could just use lubrication or if it got bad
- 43:45enough, or I could prevent the I could prevent it from getting
- 43:48bad enough by taking topical estrogen at some point to
- 43:52counteract. The testosterone.
- 43:53Yeah, yeah. And it only effects that area of
- 43:57the body, maybe like a little bit of the estrogen would get
- 43:59into the bloodstream, but not enough to really affect the rest
- 44:01of the body. But I did that.
- 44:06I wasn't informed that this atrophy actually would affect
- 44:09the general pelvic region and I I started getting really bad
- 44:16cramps in my uterus from time to time and the topical estrogen
- 44:20made that go away for the most part.
- 44:21But I was also having some issues with my urinary tract and
- 44:26I started getting a lot of infections and sometimes I would
- 44:32even get like blood or towards the end of my transition tissue
- 44:36in my urine. From taking testosterone.
- 44:40Yeah. And it got a little bit, it got
- 44:42worse for a little while after I stopped taking it.
- 44:44It's gotten better since, but I still have some issues with my
- 44:48urinary tract. Like I don't really get
- 44:49infections or anything like that anymore.
- 44:51No blood clots, no tissue. But it's still kind of difficult
- 44:56to like fully like empty my bladder or I have to use
- 44:59restroom a little bit more frequently than the average
- 45:03woman. And I was also told that it
- 45:09might affect my fertility. Again, I was 13.
- 45:14I wasn't thinking about having kids.
- 45:17So it was just like, I don't want to do that.
- 45:19I don't want to have kids. And if I wanted to in the
- 45:22future, I mean, I could just use like a like a surrogate or IVF,
- 45:26right? Because I thought it was that
- 45:28simple. I thought those technologies
- 45:31were flawless and that there would always be another option
- 45:36for me. Did they explain what that
- 45:38really meant? Like this could kill your
- 45:40fertility, so that means you will never be able to bear,
- 45:44carry, gestate, deliver, birth your own child.
- 45:49There was never a. Discussion of that she.
- 45:51Didn't really go into detail at all.
- 45:52And before my my mastectomy, I was told like, I'm not going to
- 45:57be able to breastfeed my kids ever.
- 45:58But I was living in the mindset of being a male.
- 46:01Why would I want to breastfeed a kid, right if I was, if I wanted
- 46:05to be a father rather than a mother?
- 46:07Because what father does that? That's the mother's will.
- 46:10And I'm not. I'm not a mother.
- 46:12But you still were attracted to men, right?
- 46:15Yeah. So if you got married, in your
- 46:17mind, maybe you're thinking, well, I would marry a man.
- 46:21Yeah, as I got older, it was like, well, if I were to have
- 46:25kids one day, what would they call me?
- 46:28It would kind of confusing to call both parents dad I mean.
- 46:35And you thought you would just have someone else a surrogate?
- 46:38You'd have a child through IVF and surrogacy.
- 46:40Yeah, I thought they could just, I wanted to have biological kids
- 46:43still, but I thought they could just like extract the eggs from
- 46:46my body and then plant in another woman's body and it
- 46:49would just be that simple because I was naive.
- 46:52I was an adolescent. Yeah.
- 46:55How old are you when you had a double mastectomy?
- 46:57I was 15. OK, that's such a crazy thing to
- 47:01so many people listening. And who did the double vasect
- 47:05double mastectomy? I had it with a with a surgeon
- 47:10in my healthcare provider. What was the healthcare provider
- 47:13that approved this? Kaiser Permanente?
- 47:15OK, which one? Which Kaiser?
- 47:20The hospital that I underwent surgery at was in San Rafael, so
- 47:23in like the Oakland, San Francisco area.
- 47:27It's so crazy because I have family that has used Kaiser in
- 47:31that area and I've been to Kaiser in that area because I
- 47:34used to live in the East Bay. What year was it when you had
- 47:36the double mastectomy? It was 2020.
- 47:39So during COVID, yeah. So they were doing double.
- 47:43So they were delaying hold on. During COVID they were delaying
- 47:49like knee surgeries for people in chronic pain because of
- 47:53COVID, Right. But they were giving a 15 year
- 47:56old healthy girl double mastectomy.
- 48:03Yep, this was in June so most of the lockdowns were only barely
- 48:09starting to to open back up again and they also.
- 48:17Women who delivered children during that time couldn't even
- 48:20have their husband in the room. What that was a thing that was
- 48:25AI knew about the knee surgery thing, but not.
- 48:27And you had to wear a mask the whole time.
- 48:29I mean there was you couldn't. If someone was dying, your loved
- 48:32one was dying in the hospital, you couldn't go see them.
- 48:35But they gave a healthy 15 year old girl.
- 48:38Right. Anything considered elective or
- 48:41unnecessary wasn't done during this time, but apparently this
- 48:45was necessary. It was life saving care.
- 48:48They said even though they did examinations of my breast tissue
- 48:53before and after and when they actually looked at the tissue
- 48:57afterward, after taking it out, they, I remember in the
- 49:01appointment afterward, they told me, like they told me
- 49:03specifically that there weren't any signs of, of cancer.
- 49:07And even though that wasn't the reason why I underwent the
- 49:09surgery, it was just part of the protocol to tell me that.
- 49:13So I was perfectly healthy. It was healthy tissue that it
- 49:15took out of me. Do you think about was that now
- 49:21from the vantage point that you have now looking back on that,
- 49:25Is it traumatizing to think about?
- 49:27Absolutely. It's horrifying.
- 49:31Like I, I just shouldn't have been able to.
- 49:37This shouldn't have been an option for me.
- 49:42It hurts knowing like I I could have just grown up without any
- 49:51intervention and I could have been completely normal and I
- 49:57wouldn't be dealing with all this stuff that I am now.
- 49:59I'm having some pretty serious complications from my surgery on
- 50:04top of all the the trauma that it's caused me.
- 50:08And if somebody just told me like this isn't going to make
- 50:13you into a boy and there's no guarantee that doing any of this
- 50:17is going to resolve your distress.
- 50:21You're perfect as you are as a woman.
- 50:25The issue isn't your body, it's the way that you think of it.
- 50:31And no matter what you, what you do to yourself, what drugs you
- 50:34take, what, what surgeries you get, you're always going to be a
- 50:38woman and you are enough. I won't be dealing with any of
- 50:45this right now. Did anyone say that to you?
- 50:51I mean, there were times when growing up when my mom would
- 50:54tell me like, oh, I was a tomboy, too.
- 50:57It's OK, like I eventually grew up and I'm the way that I am
- 51:05now. So you'll, you'll probably be
- 51:08just like me. But I, I was, I was a kid and I,
- 51:12there is still something, even hearing stuff like that, I still
- 51:16felt like there was something wrong with me because I still
- 51:18had a lot of other stuff going on.
- 51:21I thought that this is the only answer I had and it was the only
- 51:25one that was presented to me. So the first therapist you went
- 51:28to immediately tells you, immediately starts the
- 51:32affirmation, which in the state of California, my understanding
- 51:35is you have to. Affirm the one legal approach.
- 51:39And and the word affirm is so deceptive because affirm what?
- 51:44You're not actually affirming them.
- 51:46So you're actually. We're just letting them believe
- 51:49that there's something that they're not.
- 51:51And it's not just a delusion, though it's it's something that
- 51:54leads it's a roadway to severe harm.
- 51:59It's, I mean really, it's a lifelong, A lifelong path of
- 52:06medical intervention. So what was your first
- 52:10experience being put on testosterone?
- 52:12How soon after you tell your parents, your boy, you go to the
- 52:14therapist? How?
- 52:16How quickly did they put you on testosterone?
- 52:21I'd say maybe like two or three months after I was formally
- 52:25diagnosed with gender dysphoria was when I started telling my
- 52:28parents, like, I really want to get hormones.
- 52:32I really want to go down. I want to become a real boy,
- 52:36basically. And that was when they were
- 52:39starting to get really, really suspicious.
- 52:41Like, why do you feel this way? What is it that's making you
- 52:46feel like you have to be a boy that you were?
- 52:50Asking me those questions. Right.
- 52:53Why do you feel like you have to go down?
- 52:54Why do you feel like you have to take these treatments?
- 52:56Like you're, you're really young and you might not know what you
- 53:02you really want and we don't make it.
- 53:03We don't want you making permanent decisions at the age
- 53:05that you are. But I just kept pushing and
- 53:07pushing and they were really concerned.
- 53:09So they went to my doctors and they're like, why, Why she's why
- 53:14is she pushing so hard for this? Why does she want to do this so
- 53:17bad? And don't we have another
- 53:20option? Like why does she have to go
- 53:25down this path that at such a young age?
- 53:28Why can't we just wait until she's 18?
- 53:30And what's the likelihood that she's going to regret this if we
- 53:33don't? And my doctors are like, I mean,
- 53:40it's not normal for kids to I'm sure, you know, as a parent,
- 53:44like it's not normal for a kid to to push, push for this so
- 53:47much. It's clear that she knows what
- 53:48she wants. I mean, if you don't affirm her
- 53:56her identity and allow her to to make this decision, if you don't
- 54:01let her transition, it's very likely that she's going to kill
- 54:03herself. So your parents who sound like
- 54:07they were trying to deal with the situation as best they could
- 54:11and they were concerned, you know, this sounds quick and soon
- 54:16when you're how old are you, 12 at this time?
- 54:1913. You're 13 years old and they're
- 54:23asking the doctors, and is this a psychiatrist that you're
- 54:27talking to or a psychologist? Who what is The Who who?
- 54:31Who told who first told your parents that basically a threat
- 54:36to your parents that Chloe will kill, probably themselves.
- 54:40I don't know what you know what pronoun they used, but or
- 54:42himself. I don't know the name you were
- 54:44using, but. Leo.
- 54:45Leo if you if you don't let Leo be Leo, meaning get these
- 54:51surgeries and take testosterone, then Chloe will basically die.
- 54:56When they told me about this, they only told me about this
- 55:02recently. I didn't know that this happened
- 55:04until after I stopped transitioning and the way that
- 55:07they spoke about it sounded like there were multiple doctors that
- 55:09would speak that they were speaking to so I'm assuming it
- 55:10was a gender specialist and maybe like a nurse in the room.
- 55:15So they went to talk to a gender specialist because they just
- 55:16didn't know what to do. Felt over their heads.
- 55:18I mean probably felt very overwhelming for them.
- 55:21This is also during COVID. No, this happened before I
- 55:26started medically transitioning. OK, 'cause that OK, 'cause that
- 55:30the mastectomy was during COVID, early COVID, Yeah.
- 55:33And that they and they're basically told that their
- 55:36daughter would could die. Yeah.
- 55:39It was made out to be a life or death situation.
- 55:42And So what did your parents do after they were told that?
- 55:45They were sold into it. They really didn't think there
- 55:48was any other option 'cause they weren't given one.
- 55:52And so then after you start testosterone, what happens next?
- 55:57About a month before I was put on testosterone, I was put on
- 56:01puberty blockers to stop my body from naturally producing any
- 56:08hormones and just clearing them out to make way for the
- 56:10exogenous hormones. And that was really tough.
- 56:13It was. It was a chemically induced
- 56:19menopause, actually. So I was experiencing like hot
- 56:25flashes, itching. I was very lethargic, very
- 56:28sleepy throughout the day, and it just wasn't a pleasant
- 56:32experience. And I really just wanted to move
- 56:38on to the next big step, which was testosterone.
- 56:41And so after that month or so long period of being completely
- 56:46devoid of sex hormones and almost kind of sickly even.
- 56:49Back of my body and. It was androgen, so it felt
- 56:52pretty amazing. I mean, I felt like I was on top
- 56:54of the world like I was. It really helped to to boost my
- 56:57confidence and I had my energy levels are back up and better
- 57:01than ever. And I started to feel almost
- 57:06sort of like a competitive streak and like a competitive
- 57:11streak, like I'm going to crush. This being a boy thing.
- 57:13Yeah. Yeah, it did.
- 57:17I also, it was, it was, it was like to me, it was like a big
- 57:21step. So naturally I would feel
- 57:23pretty, pretty giddy about it. I also had a pretty steep
- 57:27increase in my libido, which was pretty difficult for me to deal
- 57:30with. Had you already at this point
- 57:33had? Your period, yeah.
- 57:38I. Had only been having them for
- 57:40about. Like a year by that point.
- 57:42I started getting periods when I was about 12 years old and it
- 57:46was so early that my cycle hadn't even regulated itself
- 57:49yet. And I also didn't know that
- 57:53there was more than just one stage in the.
- 57:55Menstrual cycle like all. I knew.
- 58:00All I knew is that. There's a period and then.
- 58:02That's it. Somehow you can get pregnant.
- 58:04I didn't know how that works at all.
- 58:06No one ever told you no, and I didn't.
- 58:09None of my sex Ed. Classes ever addressed it.
- 58:12I learned what I learned what ovulation was from a meme when I
- 58:15was 16 years old. What did you learn in your sex
- 58:17Ed classes? How to have sex?
- 58:20No, it was. It was really bare.
- 58:23Bones honestly, like we learned about gametes and then the most
- 58:28we're ever shown about sex was like, don't have sex.
- 58:32We're not going to explain why, but you can't have sex.
- 58:35Don't do that. And then and then they they
- 58:38showed us like a video of a woman giving birth and like
- 58:42pictures of like of genitalia, both male and female infected
- 58:47with studs. But they.
- 58:51Never explained why things. Like sex are so important or
- 58:55intimate or or even fertility. How your body works as a woman.
- 59:00Or a man's fertility. How that works?
- 59:05So I was being expected to make. Decisions around things like
- 59:10that that I didn't even understand yet, and they didn't
- 59:14make any effort to explain those things to me.
- 59:16So there was no informed consent?
- 59:18Absolutely not. And how?
- 59:19Can you consent when you're a minor in the 1st place?
- 59:23You can't. So you're on testosterone?
- 59:27When did you decide? You wanted the double
- 59:29mastectomy? I was about two.
- 59:33Between like 2 to. Three years on on testosterone,
- 59:39I had been using like a. Binder through that time I.
- 59:42Started using one after I started taking testosterone and
- 59:45if you don't know what a binder is, it's kind of like they come
- 59:50in either half body or full body and.
- 59:51It kind of looks like a tank top.
- 59:52But in the upper part of the garment, it's like a compression
- 59:56area and they work by basically pressing the breasts into the
- 1:00:01upper body to make it look flatter and on one hand like.
- 1:00:08I didn't really want. To be seen without it on under
- 1:00:12my shirt 'cause I didn't want anybody to know that I had
- 1:00:14breasts, 'cause I want everybody to think of me as a guy.
- 1:00:18And I already did look like a male.
- 1:00:21I testosterone was pretty effective on me and I passed
- 1:00:24considerably well as the opposite sex.
- 1:00:25I actually had a much deeper voice than I did now, and it was
- 1:00:29deeper than most of the boys then that I was friends with
- 1:00:33throughout high school, so it would be really weird.
- 1:00:37For. This person who looks and sounds
- 1:00:40just like a guy to have this very feminine looking area of
- 1:00:45the body and but I was I was also very uncomfortable.
- 1:00:50In it like it. It fit well.
- 1:00:54It didn't really cause me any pain per SE, but I, I, I heard
- 1:00:57like from other trans trans identified females like how they
- 1:01:01would experience pain in their back, in the upper back, in
- 1:01:05their, in their breasts and load their chest in the rib cage from
- 1:01:10using one. I never got any of that.
- 1:01:12So I thought it was just fine, but it actually distorted my rib
- 1:01:16cage a little bit. And even now it's, it's been two
- 1:01:19or three years since I've used a binder and I still see like a
- 1:01:23little, I wouldn't say like dense.
- 1:01:27But the bottom of my rib cage, kind of.
- 1:01:28Flares out a little bit because they I used a.
- 1:01:34Supposedly. Safe and reputable brand, but
- 1:01:42these. Things work.
- 1:01:45By pushing the breasts. Into the rib cage.
- 1:01:48And especially if you're developing.
- 1:01:50There is no Safeway. To go about that, it's like it's
- 1:01:54like foot binding. You know, it's just it.
- 1:01:58It it's now it's just binding. Something else?
- 1:02:02To fit into. The society to kind of fit.
- 1:02:05Basically in order to fit in to society's expectations as you're
- 1:02:09as you're experiencing them in a more backwards way even.
- 1:02:15So you're doing that and then but what made you?
- 1:02:17Decide to get the mastectomy. I just got really sick of of
- 1:02:21doing it after a while and. I started to think of myself as
- 1:02:25being just like any other boy and I wanted to be able to take
- 1:02:30my shirt off like all the other boys without worrying and I also
- 1:02:41had an incident in 8th grade where I had been sexually.
- 1:02:46Assaulted by somebody who had been.
- 1:02:47Harassed who had been bullying me throughout for transitioning
- 1:02:50throughout the school year and I didn't really realize just so
- 1:02:53much. It affected me.
- 1:02:55Because I was, I was already transitioning by that point.
- 1:03:00I was already living. I was already in the mindset of
- 1:03:04actually being a boy. So it was like, well, I just
- 1:03:07have to be tough about it. I can't.
- 1:03:09I can't, I can't be too upset about this.
- 1:03:12And so a guy another eighth grade.
- 1:03:16Boy, Yeah, and he sexually assaulted you.
- 1:03:20I mean, how can you share? Obviously, I can only imagine
- 1:03:23how traumatic it was or whatever you're comfortable sharing.
- 1:03:25He groped me. He.
- 1:03:27He just walked up to me in the middle of the.
- 1:03:28Classroom. And he squeezed my breasts.
- 1:03:30He looked me right in the eyes as he did it.
- 1:03:33And were there other people there?
- 1:03:35Yeah, the classroom is full. And yet nobody did a thing about
- 1:03:37it. That's horrific.
- 1:03:41Did that was the teacher. There, Yeah, he didn't.
- 1:03:44He didn't see what happened, though.
- 1:03:46And I was afraid to report it to any staff members because I was
- 1:03:51afraid of getting in trouble myself.
- 1:03:53I the school I went to just sucked and they failed to
- 1:04:01accommodate me throughout the school years.
- 1:04:03I had an IP in place that they just refused to abide by.
- 1:04:05And at one point they even told my parents like it's it's our
- 1:04:11responsibility to help the child and not you.
- 1:04:15And I didn't really have a lot of a lot of friends there.
- 1:04:19And I was even among like the like the teachers and staff
- 1:04:22members. I wasn't really one of the, I
- 1:04:25wasn't like a favorite kid by any means.
- 1:04:31And I felt like if, if I did report it, like they'd probably
- 1:04:34just let the kid off of the slap on the wrist.
- 1:04:36And I didn't know like if he was going to come back after like a
- 1:04:41few days, after a week, and if he could potentially do
- 1:04:44something worse to me if he did. I just didn't want to, I didn't
- 1:04:49want to try it. Do you think there's any
- 1:04:52connection between? Being groped.
- 1:04:55Having your breasts groped as a teen girl who's going through
- 1:04:58gender dysphoria and all these other things that you're going
- 1:05:00through and getting the mastectomy.
- 1:05:03That's why I started binding. Actually, I didn't use a binder
- 1:05:05up until. That point, that was what
- 1:05:07triggered it for me. To protect yourself.
- 1:05:10Yeah, it was. Literally.
- 1:05:11Putting on, kind of. Like an armor, Yeah, I mean.
- 1:05:14I knew it like at one point I wanted to.
- 1:05:18Start hiding my breasts. But I just kind of.
- 1:05:21Kind of put it off because it was like, well, like, I'm not as
- 1:05:24developed as some girls, right? And I wear like baggy T-shirts
- 1:05:29and sweatshirts anyways, so nobody's really going to care.
- 1:05:34Why would they care? Like they already knew me as a
- 1:05:36girl, like they already know like I'm biologically female, so
- 1:05:39why would why would anybody give a crap about that?
- 1:05:43And then that happened. It was like, OK, I guess we'll
- 1:05:46have to start heart start hiding this part of me sooner than
- 1:05:49later. I'm so sorry that happened to
- 1:05:52you. Did you did any?
- 1:05:56Did you, did your therapist know?
- 1:05:57That that happened to you, did you?
- 1:05:58Were you able to share that with anyone?
- 1:05:59No, I didn't tell anybody, any adults about it.
- 1:06:01Did any of therapists? Ever ask you about?
- 1:06:04Any kind of sexual abuse or. Sexual assault they.
- 1:06:07Probably did at some point, but I didn't recognize this as a.
- 1:06:10Sexual assault, it just didn't register me to me at the time
- 1:06:13that it was because when I when I thought.
- 1:06:17Of sexual assault, I would think of like all the.
- 1:06:19Stories I heard from like other girls and women growing up of
- 1:06:23being like raped or beaten. It was nothing of that sort of
- 1:06:26like something worse could happen to me.
- 1:06:28It wasn't the end of the world, right?
- 1:06:30So, but he's publicly squeezing your breasts to mock you.
- 1:06:34And shame you and. No one's intervening or doing
- 1:06:39anything and he just what? Happened next.
- 1:06:41He just walked off. Yep.
- 1:06:45So. After you get the mastectomy,
- 1:06:49what happens? How did you feel?
- 1:06:54I mean. In the.
- 1:06:55Immediate moments after. I actually woke up a few times.
- 1:07:00Before the medication fully wore.
- 1:07:01Off and I would try to stand up a little too quickly and they,
- 1:07:06they, they made me lay back down and go to sleep a few times
- 1:07:10because of that. And I almost, yeah, I almost, I
- 1:07:13almost threw up a few times to that.
- 1:07:15But once I was like fully awake and fully conscious and like, I
- 1:07:22was aware of what just happened. It was the greatest thing in the
- 1:07:27world. Like I'm I.
- 1:07:30Finally look like a real boy now.
- 1:07:32Maybe not right now. I mean they I've got these big
- 1:07:37scars across my chest. And these skin?
- 1:07:39Grafts that are going to take some time to heal, but
- 1:07:42eventually I'm going to look like I'm going to be just like
- 1:07:46any other boy, but I'm going to have these warrior scars on top
- 1:07:49of it and I'm finally going. To be able to to take my.
- 1:07:54Shirt off in the locker room and not have to wear a shirt.
- 1:08:01Not have to. Cover up while I swim.
- 1:08:03Or go on a jog or workout and it's going to be great from here
- 1:08:08on. And I mean that was.
- 1:08:14A very convenient, very happy way of looking at it.
- 1:08:16But that never happened. I'm I'm still healing.
- 1:08:21What do you mean? I mean.
- 1:08:29I've had some issues. With my skin grafts over the
- 1:08:31years, at first there were the skin grafts I use where my.
- 1:08:36My areolas so they. They took, they took them off
- 1:08:39and they, the way it was described to me, I guess they,
- 1:08:46they said it in such a way to make it easier for like a
- 1:08:48teenager to digest. But it was like, OK, so we'll,
- 1:08:52we'll take your areolas off and then we'll scrape the skin on a
- 1:08:56part of the chest kind of like a like a deep knee straight, but.
- 1:09:01More controlled and then we're. Going to place the aerials onto
- 1:09:03that, onto that area, so it's in a more masculine position, they
- 1:09:07said. And at first.
- 1:09:11The the. Graphs seem to be healing OK,
- 1:09:14other than the fact that they were.
- 1:09:17Superficially they were. They're a little bit dry on top,
- 1:09:20but as of last year. Around this time.
- 1:09:26They did a 180 and they've started to leak fluid.
- 1:09:34Just do you know what that? Means have you talked to a
- 1:09:35doctor about that? I've tried.
- 1:09:38I mean, I went to. My.
- 1:09:42I went to. I went back to my.
- 1:09:43Surgeon for the first time in a few years.
- 1:09:46And I tried to to get his help, I got like a 5 minute zoom.
- 1:09:51Fall with him. And that appointment was for two
- 1:09:55purposes. One to.
- 1:09:58To report that I regretted the surgery and two to get some
- 1:10:02help. With my complications and.
- 1:10:03Maybe figure out whatever is going on and the whole time it
- 1:10:09felt like he was being really rude to me, really dismissive of
- 1:10:12my concerns and I was telling him like I'm having to bandage
- 1:10:18my. Chest every day.
- 1:10:19So that whatever this food is doesn't get on to my clothing
- 1:10:22and bedding. And he just told me, yeah.
- 1:10:26Yeah, keep doing that. Yeah, that's, that's, that's
- 1:10:30normal. Just just keep, just keep
- 1:10:32managing it and put some Vaseline on it and keep it
- 1:10:35moist. This is how many years after the
- 1:10:37surgery? 2 years so.
- 1:10:39It's been 2 years since the surgery and you're.
- 1:10:41Still. Experiencing this.
- 1:10:43Yeah, I was. My grafts were supposed.
- 1:10:46To be mostly fully healed by around a year and a half and.
- 1:10:56Did he have an any explanation for why it was happening?
- 1:10:59No, there is zero. He did.
- 1:11:01This to you and he didn't know he.
- 1:11:03Had zero clue about why and he just said perpetually bandage
- 1:11:06yourself. Yeah, for a wound that I
- 1:11:08created, yes. On a 15 year old girl, I didn't
- 1:11:12What a what? A butcher.
- 1:11:15I tried to look up whatever. Whatever's happening, Yeah, I.
- 1:11:18Tried to look up whatever's happening.
- 1:11:19I never had heard or seen seen anything like.
- 1:11:23This before can you name? Who this surgeon is?
- 1:11:29His name is. He has an Asian name.
- 1:11:32I'm probably. Going to butcher the.
- 1:11:34Pronunciation of this, but I think it's Doctor Lee Hope.
- 1:11:36When did you first start doubting your transition?
- 1:11:42I didn't really have like any doubts about transitioning up
- 1:11:48until after I had the surgery, so for longest time I was very
- 1:11:54confident in presenting myself masculinely.
- 1:11:58And calling myself a. Boy and being seen as such.
- 1:12:03And it wasn't until after my breasts were gone that I started
- 1:12:06realizing like, wow, I sometimes I miss being pretty.
- 1:12:11I wish that I could grow my hair out and wear makeup without
- 1:12:14being judged. Because now everybody thinks I'm
- 1:12:17a boy. And if I were to do that, I get
- 1:12:19called all sorts of names. People would like, people will
- 1:12:21call me gay. I'd get, I'd probably get
- 1:12:24harassed for a little bit. There were a few times when my,
- 1:12:28my girlfriends put like nail Polish on me.
- 1:12:31And then I would, I would go to class and the boy next to me
- 1:12:34would be like, why are you wearing nail Polish?
- 1:12:36Why are you wearing earrings? Are you gay?
- 1:12:39And like I but if I were to consider, wouldn't you have
- 1:12:43considered yourself gay because you.
- 1:12:45Were still attracted to men, Yeah, I was, but I didn't want
- 1:12:48to be seen that way. Because I mean, even though I
- 1:12:52live in in California in a pretty, I guess you'd say
- 1:12:56progressive time in high schools, especially like there's
- 1:13:00still that stigma against people who are gay or even people who
- 1:13:06say are male, but they present themselves more femininely vice
- 1:13:09versa. And I just didn't want to deal
- 1:13:11with that. So.
- 1:13:14When did you first? When did you what process did
- 1:13:18you go to go through before eventually deciding to
- 1:13:22detransition? Eventually my feelings around
- 1:13:25around that. Started to I started to go into
- 1:13:32a downward. Spiral.
- 1:13:33Basically I became more and. More distressed over the way
- 1:13:35that I looked every day and I hated that I no longer had soft
- 1:13:40feminine features. Now I had muscle and big
- 1:13:42shoulders and my breasts were gone and I thought that I wasn't
- 1:13:47bothered by my by my mastectomy for the longest but I just
- 1:13:50wanted to be pretty and and have curves and other.
- 1:13:55Places and to be. Effeminate looking, but I
- 1:14:02started. Comparing myself again to other
- 1:14:04women. And feeling like I just didn't
- 1:14:07match up. And I was also comparing myself
- 1:14:10to other men as well. And I realized like, I'm all for
- 1:14:20one. I'm, I'm pretty, I'm pretty
- 1:14:21short. I'm like 5 foot 35 foot 4, which
- 1:14:24is like a pretty average height for a woman, but that's way
- 1:14:27shorter than the average male. So that would be, that would be
- 1:14:31kind of strange. And now that I was presenting
- 1:14:37myself as a guy, I mean, I wasn't bad looking and there
- 1:14:42were quite a few girls who thought that I was attractive,
- 1:14:45but I didn't really have anything, any attraction to
- 1:14:49them. And he, I felt like, like even
- 1:14:52if I did want to pursue a girl, I'm not.
- 1:14:57Actually a biological. Male.
- 1:14:58I don't have the parts that they're looking for and I don't
- 1:15:01want to. I don't want to disappoint
- 1:15:03anybody. And the few boys at school who
- 1:15:09were attracted to me were. Not the most.
- 1:15:15Savoury of people, a lot of them more like really into drugs or
- 1:15:22like they it kind of felt like I was.
- 1:15:27Almost like a. Fetish to them, like I was like
- 1:15:30I literally a boy but like I was small, of a short stature,
- 1:15:36skinny and they didn't always see me as much more than that.
- 1:15:42Do you think pornography played a role?
- 1:15:46Yeah, probably for those boys. That's that's probably.
- 1:15:50Part of it did it. Play any role do.
- 1:15:52You think in your? Transition.
- 1:15:54Yeah, it was. It really distorted my view of
- 1:15:57like. Sex and intimacy, but also my
- 1:16:00own body. And it's going to sound kind of
- 1:16:05funny, but BuzzFeed and other, other publications like that
- 1:16:09really, really made that a lot worse.
- 1:16:12Because I, I first discovered like BuzzFeed and other like
- 1:16:15those kinds of sites through like when I was a kid by looking
- 1:16:18up, I don't know, like which Disney Princess am I?
- 1:16:22And then they have like all those quizzes, but then they
- 1:16:24have the other less appropriate content on there, especially
- 1:16:30about things like sex. And from those there would be
- 1:16:33articles like encouraging, like teenage girls, like younger and
- 1:16:37younger. To explore.
- 1:16:39Their sexuality and what they like as early as possible and
- 1:16:44that things like casual sex or being kinky are good and we
- 1:16:49should all strive to be that way and.
- 1:16:53None of it really discussed like.
- 1:16:55The real meaning of sex about the about the.
- 1:17:00The intimacy of it and why. It's so important and how it's
- 1:17:03designed right for for intimacy. And pleasure and for also life,
- 1:17:08right It was, it was really like.
- 1:17:11Pleasure above all, and pleasure without love.
- 1:17:15Which in the end. Doesn't bring pleasure like long
- 1:17:18lasting pleasure, which I would call peace or joy or happiness.
- 1:17:22Right, right. And it's my distorted view.
- 1:17:26Of sex in relationships on top of my inability to get into
- 1:17:31relationship because of my transition, I was I, I had a lot
- 1:17:35of stress around that because I all my friends were starting to
- 1:17:38get boyfriends and girlfriends and I was missing out on that.
- 1:17:41And I felt like I was a freak or something like there was
- 1:17:43something wrong with me. And so I compensated by getting
- 1:17:46into those online relationships, by sexting older, often random
- 1:17:50men. And it just it all.
- 1:17:53Worked to to make me. Feel so much worse.
- 1:17:57And it was difficult socially. For reasons other than.
- 1:18:04Than romance. Now it was a lot.
- 1:18:08Harder to. To make friends.
- 1:18:12To be as. Intimate as it could be as a
- 1:18:15girl, because now I was taking on the role of a boy and there
- 1:18:20wasn't really a lot of room for me to talk about like my own
- 1:18:23personal hardships and what I was going through, and all I
- 1:18:28really had was the Internet. At what point did?
- 1:18:32You decide I. Want I'm done with this at some.
- 1:18:38Point. It was like.
- 1:18:41Well, I never felt like I was. Enough when I was a girl.
- 1:18:47But I feel the same exact way as a boy now.
- 1:18:51I guess I just can't be good enough as either so.
- 1:18:55Maybe I'm not either. Maybe.
- 1:18:56I'm just non binary, maybe I'm something between the two sexes
- 1:19:04but. No matter what I did, no.
- 1:19:06Matter what I called myself, or what pronouns I used or how I
- 1:19:09how I dressed, I just kept getting worse.
- 1:19:15It wasn't up until at some point in my.
- 1:19:20Late in my junior year. That I realized just what I was.
- 1:19:26Doing to myself. That it was making things worse
- 1:19:30and I couldn't go back. And that was when I started to
- 1:19:36learn about things like like motherhood and parenting and how
- 1:19:41how children's minds develop and how they see the world.
- 1:19:45That it was like, wow, this is, I didn't know all this, that
- 1:19:54that's really important to me and I want to be a mother one
- 1:19:57day, but how am I, if I'm going to, if I'm on these medications
- 1:20:03that that might affect my ability to have kids.
- 1:20:08And now that I I can't breastfeed, I just realized how
- 1:20:12big, just how important that really is, that breasts aren't
- 1:20:17just a sexual object, that there's so much more than
- 1:20:21something to. Be played with or to feed a
- 1:20:24child with because even breastfeeding is very important
- 1:20:29to the bond between a. Mother and her child.
- 1:20:31And things like, well, breast milk, it has things like like
- 1:20:41pre and probiotics in it that help.
- 1:20:42Baby's immune system develop. And breasts and physical
- 1:20:47affection in general help to regulate a baby's body
- 1:20:50temperature and other parts of their health.
- 1:20:55And I'm not. Going to have that anymore I
- 1:20:59never. I never will.
- 1:21:02And it was taken away from me before I even got to become a
- 1:21:05woman, before I understood what that meant.
- 1:21:11And that was that really horrified me.
- 1:21:15I I couldn't keep living like that because now I knew what it
- 1:21:19really meant. What when you had that
- 1:21:26realization? What?
- 1:21:27Did you do? Well, first I went through a
- 1:21:32few. A few weeks of just the most
- 1:21:37horrific. Distress and not being.
- 1:21:39Able to to focus on anything really.
- 1:21:42I cried quite a bit and I. Withdrew.
- 1:21:47Pretty much completely. And then I finally.
- 1:21:51Came to terms of the fact that. I'm still a woman and nothing
- 1:21:59could change that. And I I was still kind of stuck
- 1:22:04in the mindset. Of.
- 1:22:06I could just identify out of whatever I was feeling.
- 1:22:09So I didn't really, I was so kind of wondering like, well,
- 1:22:15what is? My identity now.
- 1:22:16But now my transition was was over for good and I told my mom.
- 1:22:23I told a friend of mine. And I just didn't know what to
- 1:22:27do with myself for a while. Like, I grew up my hair.
- 1:22:30I started buying new clothes. But did you stop taking
- 1:22:34testosterone? Yeah, I.
- 1:22:36Took my final testosterone shot. Almost.
- 1:22:41Two years ago at this point, in May of 20. 21 I was, I was 16
- 1:22:49Are you, do you know if you're able to have kids?
- 1:22:53I haven't gotten a fertility test yet.
- 1:22:56I got my period back about two years, no two months after
- 1:23:01stopping testosterone very quickly and my periods seem to
- 1:23:06be regular now, which is a good sign And now like based on like
- 1:23:11the the symptoms. That I'm experiencing at a given
- 1:23:13time. Like I can, I can tell which
- 1:23:14part of the cycle I'm at. It's very like.
- 1:23:17It's not, it's a. Possibility that I could be
- 1:23:21having. And ovulatory cycles, but I
- 1:23:26think. I'll be able to conceive a kid.
- 1:23:31I just don't know. If like how basically skipping
- 1:23:37half of puberty might effects other parts of that like my egg.
- 1:23:42Quality, whether my hips. Have expanded enough to safely
- 1:23:45naturally give birth, but you started puberty blockers.
- 1:23:51Several years into puberty, yeah.
- 1:23:54So there are obviously D transitioners who they had
- 1:23:59puberty blockers before they even had a puberty.
- 1:24:05So I think. That you know, I'm I'm going to
- 1:24:07pray. And hope for that for you.
- 1:24:09Thank you. What's what's next?
- 1:24:11I mean, well before what's next? What's now?
- 1:24:15Because you're doing some. Incredible things.
- 1:24:17We're just joking earlier about The New York Times is after you
- 1:24:20this morning. Oh, that was beautiful.
- 1:24:23It's. So beautiful when the media.
- 1:24:24When the big one of the biggest papers in the country writes a
- 1:24:26hit piece on you on me. I can't say when I started doing
- 1:24:31this a year ago. Did I expected anything like
- 1:24:33that? But honestly, I wouldn't have it
- 1:24:35any other way. Well, it's kind of fun.
- 1:24:38Well, the way that getting to know you a little bit, the way
- 1:24:40that you. Take it in in stride is awesome.
- 1:24:43It's definitely very warrior woman, I mean.
- 1:24:50I've already lost. A lot it's I wouldn't say like
- 1:24:52my. Attitude is like, I don't have
- 1:24:53much more to lose because I still have.
- 1:24:57Despite what I've lost, I still. Have a lot there's.
- 1:25:00Still a lot in this world for me, but like there's.
- 1:25:07I have to get justice for what happened to me, but I also have.
- 1:25:10To prevent it from happening to anybody ever again.
- 1:25:15Well, you were already doing. Incredible things.
- 1:25:19To accomplish that and it's amazing to watch you do that.
- 1:25:22It's one of the reasons I was so excited to talk to you.
- 1:25:24Thank you so much. You're just getting started.
- 1:25:29I believe it. I want to talk about what your
- 1:25:31goals. Are with your.
- 1:25:32Mission moving forward. But first, the decision for you
- 1:25:36to publicly Share your story, which I can only imagine how
- 1:25:41much courage that took. You made that decision about a
- 1:25:44year ago, right? Yeah.
- 1:25:46So it's been one year since you've been publicly sharing
- 1:25:50your story. Just over a year.
- 1:25:51What was that like to 1st publicly Share your story of
- 1:25:56detransitioning? Yeah, I mean.
- 1:26:01A while after I stopped transitioning I knew like I
- 1:26:05wanted to to start talking about my story but I didn't really
- 1:26:09know where to start so I would just I immediately after I did
- 1:26:16transition I was pretty much kicked out by the trans
- 1:26:20community. For.
- 1:26:21Being in a what's the word an apostate and they just.
- 1:26:29They called you an apostate. No, but they.
- 1:26:32Treated me as such. Because just violated the
- 1:26:35fundamental rule of. Their religion which is gender
- 1:26:40for main care is healthcare. And you dared to criticize the.
- 1:26:45Surgeon that cut off your healthy breasts.
- 1:26:47I mean, before that I would just talk.
- 1:26:50About the pain and regret that came from it and how I felt like
- 1:26:55my doctors lied to me and they did and I was told like you
- 1:27:02should have known exactly what you.
- 1:27:03Were doing you knew what you were.
- 1:27:04Doing for yourself. Don't put this on us, but they
- 1:27:08said that it was your only. Option, yeah.
- 1:27:11And they and they told you with every, with every.
- 1:27:13Step the more extreme it got, the more they celebrated it like
- 1:27:17before I think. What do you mean I had my?
- 1:27:20Celebrate what is. What did that look like to
- 1:27:22celebrate it? When I had my.
- 1:27:26Mastectomy that. Was probably the most praise I'd
- 1:27:30ever got in my lifetime up until that point.
- 1:27:33Like the most I I had was probably like, like my parents
- 1:27:37or classmates telling me that they liked my drawings.
- 1:27:41It was it was incredible. So now.
- 1:27:47Now that. I regret it now that it causes
- 1:27:49me pain. They would.
- 1:27:52They blamed it on me. And some of them would even make
- 1:27:53fun of me for. Regretting it.
- 1:27:55I just want to unpack that for a minute because I think that's
- 1:27:57such an. Incredibly important experience
- 1:28:00that you had, which is that in your entire life, the thing
- 1:28:04you'd most been praised for was your art until you had your
- 1:28:07mastectomy and then this whole and starting on testosterone and
- 1:28:11the other parts of the transition process.
- 1:28:13So the thing to affirm about your identity, your humanity?
- 1:28:18Most for other people became. That you were on these.
- 1:28:21Medical treatments, yeah. And then when you chose to stop
- 1:28:28the medical. Treatments and expressed regret.
- 1:28:30What happened? What did they do?
- 1:28:32What did they say to you? What do they say to you online?
- 1:28:35There is, there was this. One person, also a trans
- 1:28:41identified female who I had known since I was about 13 and I
- 1:28:48think this person had always. Been jealous of me because.
- 1:28:51I had I had a loving family. And I was able to get on these
- 1:28:58treatments. So early and they weren't always
- 1:29:01the nicest to me, but they did celebrate my transition, my
- 1:29:05especially my my my mastectomy the most.
- 1:29:10And now? That I was regretting it.
- 1:29:13They're trying to, like, gaslight me into thinking that
- 1:29:15we had a conversation about the difference between body
- 1:29:19dysmorphia and real gender dysphoria, whatever that means.
- 1:29:22I don't think it's real, personally.
- 1:29:25And they even told me like you were 13.
- 1:29:30You weren't a toddler. You knew exactly what you're
- 1:29:33doing it doing and why you wanted it.
- 1:29:36I knew at the same age that I wanted to to transition, so why
- 1:29:40wouldn't you? This is your fault.
- 1:29:44Doesn't it feel bad? Doesn't it hurt having your
- 1:29:46breasts be gone forever and meaning they still had their
- 1:29:53breasts? Probably.
- 1:29:55Yeah, I. It's pretty twisted.
- 1:30:00It was one of the most deranged. Interactions I've ever had
- 1:30:04actually, because after at some point after taking out all that
- 1:30:09whatever on me, they started crying to me about how they had
- 1:30:13been sexually abused at a young age.
- 1:30:15They were so close to seeing why this is affecting them so much,
- 1:30:20why my regret was affecting them.
- 1:30:22So I think it's so clear that this individual had.
- 1:30:28Like their? Sexual trauma was influencing
- 1:30:34them, their decision in transition, and that's why they
- 1:30:36didn't want to be a girl anymore.
- 1:30:39And that's I see that I see. That quite a bit.
- 1:30:41They were angry that. You were regretting it, Yes,
- 1:30:44and. Confidently, in a way of
- 1:30:45regretting it, yeah. And I got the same kind of
- 1:30:47reaction from a lot of other individuals.
- 1:30:49In the trans community, it was like it was all from like older
- 1:30:53transgender people, many of them many of whom hadn't even started
- 1:30:57on hormones yet. And I was supposedly in the most
- 1:31:01ideal situation, a transition like I was super young and I had
- 1:31:08a supportive family and friend group around me.
- 1:31:12I passed as the opposite sex. Very.
- 1:31:13Well, I was pretty much. Indistinguishable from a real
- 1:31:16male, and yet. It still hurt.
- 1:31:20Me, I still regretted it. So as somebody who wants to live
- 1:31:26that kind of lifestyle, there's that sort of cognitive
- 1:31:30dissonance in like being told like this is life saving
- 1:31:34healthcare and that is the most ideal way to doing it, to do it.
- 1:31:39And seeing somebody who had been through exactly that, having
- 1:31:42been hurt by it, you shattered their.
- 1:31:47You shattered their cult very closely.
- 1:31:49I was very close to. But after a while, the response
- 1:31:54is anger against you because you're daring to.
- 1:31:57To reveal, I think it's very based in fear, Yeah.
- 1:32:00So after a wow. I It's kind of like when you and
- 1:32:03this is a real phenomenon when. People join cults, then leave.
- 1:32:06They become anathema. You know the the cult members.
- 1:32:11Have a profound. Hatred and disgust for people
- 1:32:14that leave their cult. The ones that stay, Yep, I mean
- 1:32:18after. A while I'd been.
- 1:32:20Harassed. So much What do that harassment
- 1:32:22look like? Sometimes it was like random
- 1:32:25people. Dming me stuff.
- 1:32:26Like. You look better as a boy or like
- 1:32:29you should have stayed a boy or keep that to yourself.
- 1:32:32You're disgusting sometimes, like random people, like
- 1:32:35stalking me, like leaving me in comments on my posts, on my
- 1:32:38personal social media. And I just didn't want to deal
- 1:32:41with that anymore. So I went silent about it for a
- 1:32:43bit. But I also discovered that
- 1:32:46they're all in communities having to do transition and
- 1:32:49everything that these the transgender community was was
- 1:32:52telling me about the transition was a lie.
- 1:32:56And I knew there's so many people out there who were just
- 1:33:00like this. What were those lies?
- 1:33:02What were two of the top lies that.
- 1:33:04They're the the trans community, as you we can call it, was
- 1:33:07telling you about D transitioning to try to scare
- 1:33:09you off from doing it. That this is rare that that it.
- 1:33:13Never happens. Meaning that people regret?
- 1:33:15Pretty much, yeah. And that when it does happen,
- 1:33:17it's usually due to. Social pressure and regret is
- 1:33:21actually quite rare. Quite rare.
- 1:33:23So I shouldn't talk about my own regret because then that's
- 1:33:27imposing my own experience on other trans people.
- 1:33:31And I actually never heard about detransition at all up until I
- 1:33:36started detransitioning. I didn't even know what the word
- 1:33:40was until it happened to me. How common is it, do you know?
- 1:33:45We have no idea. We do not.
- 1:33:47Know except if you go on certain Reddit.
- 1:33:50I mean, aren't there? Hundreds and hundreds of these
- 1:33:53stories coming. Out now.
- 1:33:54Yeah, the R slash the trans subreddit was one of my.
- 1:33:57First stops and then how many posts on there.
- 1:34:01I don't know how many posts are on.
- 1:34:02There, but there's. The last time I checked there
- 1:34:06were I think like 4050 thousand people on there and it's growing
- 1:34:1350,000 people on the D trans. Reddit, I think they gain about
- 1:34:181000 people per month even. It's insane, yeah.
- 1:34:22For for for them to say this never.
- 1:34:24Happens. Or almost never happens.
- 1:34:28Would another live be There's no there's no consequences.
- 1:34:31Oh yeah, I mean, it wasn't told that I.
- 1:34:33I knew like there would be consequences to it, but I just,
- 1:34:36I wasn't at an age where I could really fully appreciate that.
- 1:34:41So I. Want to talk about your activism
- 1:34:42because you. Are traveling the country, you
- 1:34:45are speaking before legislate legislatures, Congress, you are
- 1:34:49advocating on major media shows you're leading a crusade.
- 1:34:53When I first heard about you, I'm like, she reminds me of Joan
- 1:34:55of Arc, except you're fighting for children, you know, instead
- 1:34:58of like a, you know, a nation. But it is a nation to some
- 1:35:01degree. Obviously the children of this
- 1:35:02nation and the world. What's that like?
- 1:35:08It's. I don't think any one word could
- 1:35:12describe just how wild. Wild of an adventure it's been.
- 1:35:19I mean just last year I was pretty much a shut in like a
- 1:35:23total loser, kind of a Stoner. Like I just played video games
- 1:35:26all day and just didn't really do much.
- 1:35:29Like after I got my, I was studying for my, for my CHSP,
- 1:35:34which is a diploma, diploma equivalent.
- 1:35:38But I didn't really have any plans for life.
- 1:35:41I didn't really think that I would make it honestly.
- 1:35:43What do you mean by that? Did or did you feel depressed?
- 1:35:46Yeah, I. Was really depressed like I
- 1:35:47thought. I lost everything.
- 1:35:50I mean, I lost all my friends. I went through my senior year
- 1:35:52completely alone, so I just dropped out.
- 1:35:54That was why I was getting my certificate.
- 1:35:56And you were in the 1st place. This is after D transitioning.
- 1:35:59Yeah. I thought I lost everything.
- 1:36:05But at the same. Time there is still something
- 1:36:08keeping me going, keeping me going, and I still wanted to
- 1:36:16make. Friends, even if they're outside
- 1:36:17of. School and I wanted to do my
- 1:36:19best to improve socially and maybe one day become a
- 1:36:24functioning member of society. I didn't know if that was a
- 1:36:27possibility for me, but I just kept going through and I started
- 1:36:31making up with my family because my relationship with them was
- 1:36:34really strained over the course of my transition.
- 1:36:38And just like being with like my, my little nieces and
- 1:36:42nephews, it helped me to realize just how important that is.
- 1:36:47And based on my interactions with the D trans community, like
- 1:36:50I wanted to help other people in this situation.
- 1:36:53And like I knew there has to be kids going through what I did
- 1:36:57because when I first entered that community, it was pretty
- 1:37:02much only adults who had been through the transition process
- 1:37:06as adults. But.
- 1:37:10I just had this intuition. That there has to be a bunch of
- 1:37:14other kids like me. Even if it was just was just one
- 1:37:18kid or 10 kids who are like me, that's far too many and I wasn't
- 1:37:24ready for a while, but I knew. Like at some point I.
- 1:37:26Wanted to start speaking up and I started small.
- 1:37:30At first it was just all my personal social media.
- 1:37:33And then once I felt ready, I started.
- 1:37:35I started posting about it on Twitter and I didn't really
- 1:37:39expect my platform to blow up the way it did.
- 1:37:42But at some point I had like journalists messaging me or like
- 1:37:47emailing me and I had some articles.
- 1:37:53Published on on Me. That helped.
- 1:37:55To really increase my reach and eventually one day I had a
- 1:38:05parent working with a nonprofit. Group called Partners for
- 1:38:07ethical care reaching. Out to me saying that Louisiana
- 1:38:14had a piece of legislation. That was.
- 1:38:19I think it was. Like a conversion therapy ban.
- 1:38:21That included like gender, the gender affirming care model in
- 1:38:27it. And she wanted me to like write
- 1:38:31a testimony for it. But it turned out that the state
- 1:38:36of Louisiana wouldn't accept written testimony if and if I
- 1:38:40were to testify, I would have to actually come there in person.
- 1:38:43And so they asked me if I would be able to fly out and it I
- 1:38:52really wanted to do it. I knew it was like a pretty big
- 1:38:56opportunity for me to do that. But when I told my.
- 1:39:00Parents about it at first they're.
- 1:39:01Like, no, no, you're not doing that.
- 1:39:04Like how old are you? I was 17.
- 1:39:07I was still kidding that I hadn't really been away from
- 1:39:09them that far away or for so long.
- 1:39:14So naturally they're pretty protective of me, especially
- 1:39:17since I wasn't completely healed yet.
- 1:39:21I wouldn't even say that I am now, but I was a.
- 1:39:23Lot worse off just a. Year ago than I am now, but it
- 1:39:28took some convincing on. Their part, but I'm.
- 1:39:32I'm very glad that they said yes and that I've been able to to do
- 1:39:35this because it's been a wonderful journey not only for
- 1:39:39me but for for the other kids who are being affected.
- 1:39:43By this. Your Twitter game is also very
- 1:39:46strong. And you're very.
- 1:39:49Articulate and a wonderful. Spokeswoman and showing the
- 1:39:53harm, but also advocating for good for for children and and
- 1:39:57for families. What are your goals?
- 1:39:59Well. I want to stop.
- 1:40:05I want to stop these. Treatments from ever being
- 1:40:07performed on. Children ever again.
- 1:40:09And I think the standards of care for both adult and child
- 1:40:14patients who have gender dysphoria need to be revised
- 1:40:19because as it is now, the current model doesn't allow for
- 1:40:24real informed consent. It pushes transition as the only
- 1:40:28option, and it doesn't really give these patients the
- 1:40:31information that they need in order in order to make a
- 1:40:36decision on this. They're calling it life saving.
- 1:40:40Care when? Really, it's only taking parts
- 1:40:45of a perfectly functional body. Do you support bans on?
- 1:40:55Affirming. Care for minors, as they call
- 1:40:57it? Yes.
- 1:40:59They should never be performing on.
- 1:41:00Kids, what kind of treatment should they be giving, providing
- 1:41:03for? Children who face gender
- 1:41:05dysphoria, they need psychotherapy, do you think?
- 1:41:08If you'd gotten psychotherapy, you.
- 1:41:10Wouldn't be here today. Absolutely.
- 1:41:12I mean. I had a lot of.
- 1:41:15Compounding issues growing up, but I feel like if.
- 1:41:17They were properly addressed. I wouldn't have felt the need.
- 1:41:22To. Become a boy to become.
- 1:41:25Something that I wasn't. In the state of California.
- 1:41:30My understanding is psychotherapy for.
- 1:41:31Gender dysphoria without the affirming care model meaning
- 1:41:35saying yes, you are the opposite biological sex, you're not
- 1:41:38really a man, you're not really a boy, you're not really a girl
- 1:41:41is illegal, right? I mean it's mind blowing.
- 1:41:45And if you're a parent of a child.
- 1:41:46Who struggles with gender dysphoria and you say you don't
- 1:41:50want your child to be LED down this path of mutilation, puberty
- 1:41:55blockers and the rest. Then you can lose custody.
- 1:41:58Yep, it's abusive not to affirm. Your child.
- 1:42:01Apparently the language is so deceptive because it's not
- 1:42:04affirmation. I mean, what exploitation?
- 1:42:06What is a parent for then, if they're just supposed to let
- 1:42:09their kid? Have the reins on their own
- 1:42:11medical treatment. Have you been able to talk to
- 1:42:14your? Parents about what?
- 1:42:16Happened. I mean in an objective way about
- 1:42:25just. About like what's happened Yeah,
- 1:42:27but we haven't had like a like a deep emotional conversation
- 1:42:31about it. I'm kind of I'm kind of afraid
- 1:42:33of doing that right now just because I feel like it would be
- 1:42:36really deeply painful. And I don't know if like we've
- 1:42:40if either I or my mom or. Dad have really recovered
- 1:42:43enough. To have a conversation like that
- 1:42:45yet, but at the same time, it's like the clock's ticking.
- 1:42:50They won't be here forever and I have to have that conversation
- 1:42:53at some point. It's just a really scary
- 1:42:54prospect for me, they sound. Like they did their best with
- 1:43:00what they. Knew.
- 1:43:02But at the same time, I'm sure it's devastating deep down for
- 1:43:06them. They have a lot of guilt.
- 1:43:07Yeah, I think any parent would. That's a very.
- 1:43:12Gracious, you're you've got. A very gracious approach with
- 1:43:16and how you talk about them. So you're going to end this evil
- 1:43:22practice once and for all, and then what?
- 1:43:24Once you've ended the evil practice of these, the medical
- 1:43:29community that's been poisoned by this ideology, what are you
- 1:43:32going to do next? It's such a, it's such a simple
- 1:43:35question. And yet it's so overwhelming.
- 1:43:37Well, you're you are 18, so there's so many.
- 1:43:40Possibilities. You know any 18 year old?
- 1:43:42Is like, I mean the mass majority of 18 year olds.
- 1:43:44Are like, I don't know, this sounds interesting.
- 1:43:46This sounds something. So you're already, like doing
- 1:43:48something tremendously. Yeah.
- 1:43:50I mean, you've lived already so much life once this is said and
- 1:43:54done. There's still so many, so many
- 1:43:59things in this world. To fight for like.
- 1:44:03I'm. I'd say that over the.
- 1:44:05Years I've become. A very family oriented.
- 1:44:07Person and there are a lot of issues affecting children and
- 1:44:11families and mothers and fathers right now.
- 1:44:14And I think once I'm done with this, I might continue.
- 1:44:18On to that. But what are some examples of
- 1:44:21things you're passionate about for me?
- 1:44:23You might know, I mean, obviously with live action, I've
- 1:44:252500 children killed every day by abortion.
- 1:44:28It's like these children are in danger of death and I'm going to
- 1:44:31fight for them. But what are some things that
- 1:44:32you've seen that you're just concerned about and want to try
- 1:44:36to stop? I mean a lot of parents now.
- 1:44:39Are totally laissez faire on how they parent their kids now
- 1:44:43that's they go home they have an app they they have a drink they
- 1:44:48spend time with other adults rather than their own kids and
- 1:44:51they're just letting the parent they're letting the screens
- 1:44:54parent their children rather than themselves and that's kind
- 1:44:59of how I got. To this point.
- 1:45:01I learned I learned about transitioning entirely from
- 1:45:04social media and my parents had no idea what I was seeing online
- 1:45:09and usually it doesn't lead to. Something that's extreme, but.
- 1:45:14I've seen the same thing with a lot of my friends growing up and
- 1:45:17that their their parents let them have completely
- 1:45:21unrestricted Internet access and they're exposed to things like
- 1:45:24pornography from a very young age I think.
- 1:45:28That's another issue that I'm. That I'm very passionate.
- 1:45:33About, I think that there needs to be.
- 1:45:35Age restrictions on pornography? I'm with your websites.
- 1:45:40I would just ban it, that's my position.
- 1:45:43Ideally, yes, that's a step right there.
- 1:45:45Wow. Ideally, yes.
- 1:45:47But in a state. Like California or pretty much
- 1:45:51throughout the US. That would never happen,
- 1:45:54unfortunately. Do you want to have a family
- 1:45:56yourself one day? Oh yeah.
- 1:45:59I hope I have a big family one day.
- 1:46:00That's awesome, but first. I want to travel the world, and
- 1:46:05outside of activism and politics, I've kind of always
- 1:46:12been on the artistic. Side.
- 1:46:14Yeah, those, those are pictures of the kid with the.
- 1:46:17Funny noses of the story. I mean, other than the funny
- 1:46:21stuff that I would draw in class.
- 1:46:23I've always liked doing things like like character design and
- 1:46:26illustration, and in recent years I've gotten into fashion
- 1:46:31and I you are very fashionable. I love when you're when I've.
- 1:46:35Seen your videos and stuff When you're at a rally or you're
- 1:46:39testifying, you're dressed like in a really cool.
- 1:46:43You have a very cool aesthetic that I I like.
- 1:46:46I feel like the way that I dress in a lot of these.
- 1:46:48Interviews and at these at these high profile events though.
- 1:46:55Doesn't really capture me. Very well.
- 1:46:57I feel like it's a little too stuffy for me.
- 1:46:58I mean, I like it. It's fancy, you know, But you're
- 1:47:02more of a a relaxed vibe. Not necessarily.
- 1:47:09I mean, I always have some sort of crazy idea.
- 1:47:11And kind of. Building up my wardrobe right
- 1:47:12now, the idea I have for a for a brand is if you're going to say
- 1:47:21it, someone listening might steal it, so just proceed.
- 1:47:23With caution. I'm just kidding.
- 1:47:24My fears are super, super good. It's constantly evolving, but.
- 1:47:33And it's very, it's very much a work in.
- 1:47:34Progress. I don't have a name for it.
- 1:47:36Or anything right now. But the the Moto I have for it
- 1:47:40is of future and past and there would be two distinct styles.
- 1:47:45One of them would be kind of nostalgic, very bright colors, a
- 1:47:49lot of a lot of cute motifs, and the other would be more
- 1:47:53futuristic, almost kind of like. A cyberpunk I want to figure.
- 1:47:56Out how to do that without it being cringy, but I guess like
- 1:47:58if you're going to cyberpunk, you're already in cringe
- 1:48:00territory. I like it, Chloe, you're an.
- 1:48:05Inspiration. I'm really excited to see what
- 1:48:07you do with your one beautiful life and thank you so much for
- 1:48:10sitting down with me in this kind of warm room to tell me
- 1:48:14and, and just your courage in sharing so much personal stuff
- 1:48:19with the world, but so you can help other people and and help
- 1:48:22other children. So thank you.
- 1:48:23Thank you so much. How can people find you?
- 1:48:26And support your work. I'm on Twitter and Instagram at
- 1:48:29chapter. Triple OCOLE Nice and what about
- 1:48:33is there like a a website to donate?
- 1:48:34Or to contribute financially. I know that what you're doing is
- 1:48:38not free. You have to support yourself.
- 1:48:40I'm on donorbox at donorbox dot dot.
- 1:48:43Org slash Chloe dash. Cool.
- 1:48:46Awesome. Thanks Chloe.
- 1:48:48Oh yeah, and I also. Have.
- 1:48:52AI have an ongoing lawsuit. And the fun for it is on.
- 1:48:55The official Center for American Liberty website.
- 1:48:57Nice, nice. Sue them into oblivion.
- 1:49:00For the children, that's the plan for the children.
- 1:49:02Thank you, Chloe, you. Rock.