Latest / Deep Dive Ortho — Orthopaedic Surgery, AI & Digital Health Podcast. / The Art of Indifference

Transcript

The Art of Indifference · Deep Dive Ortho — Orthopaedic Surgery, AI & Digital Health Podcast.

0:00
Welcome to the Deep Dive, where we unpack complex
0:02
ideas and explore insights that might just change
0:05
the way you approach your professional and personal
0:06
life. Today, we're embarking on a, well, a deeply
0:11
insightful journey, I think, into the very nature
0:13
of happiness, success, and crucially, how we
0:15
grapple with the inevitable challenges that come
0:18
with demanding careers. For many of us, especially
0:21
those of you navigating high stakes environments
0:23
like medicine, the pressures to achieve, to be
0:25
perfect, to constantly innovate, and, you know,
0:28
to always stay positive, well, they can feel
0:31
immense. But what if those very pursuits, those
0:34
relentless efforts to always feel good or be
0:37
seen as flawless, are actually holding us back?
0:39
We're going to challenge some deeply ingrained
0:42
beliefs about what it truly means to thrive.
0:44
We'll be looking at why our attempts to always
0:46
feel good might paradoxically be making us feel
0:49
worse, and how, counterintuitively, embracing
0:51
discomfort and imperfection can lead to profound
0:53
personal and professional growth. We're incredibly
0:56
fortunate to be joined today by the insightful
0:58
Professor Moimam, who will help us navigate these
1:00
often uncomfortable yet ultimately perhaps liberating
1:04
ideas. It's a genuine pleasure to be here. This
1:06
exploration into human values and our intrinsic
1:09
relationship with suffering, it's not merely
1:11
an academic exercise, I believe. It's particularly
1:14
relevant, as you say, in high -stakes professional
1:16
environments, where the pursuit of an idealized
1:20
version of perfection can often lead to burnout,
1:23
disillusionment, and a profound sense of disconnection
1:25
from one's true purpose. Understanding these
1:27
dynamics is, I think, crucial for sustainable
1:30
well -being. That's a powerful starting point.
1:32
So let's begin to unpack this. We are constantly
1:35
relentlessly bombarded with messages telling
1:37
us to be happier, healthier, and better than
1:40
everyone else. Just open any social media feed,
1:42
and you're met with a curated highlight reel
1:45
of successes, perfectly managed careers, seemingly
1:48
flawless lives. It's quite something. It can
1:51
feel like we need to give a damn about absolutely
1:53
everything all the time, every patient outcome,
1:55
every administrative task, every new research
1:57
paper, every potential career advancement. In
2:00
the relentless pursuit of what we perceive as
2:02
positive, this constant striving for an ideal
2:04
state can actually be profoundly detrimental
2:06
to our mental well -being, particularly for medical
2:09
professionals who are already under immense systemic
2:12
and internal pressure to perform flawlessly,
2:15
to never make a mistake, and to always present
2:17
an image of unwavering competence. Indeed. What
2:21
you're describing perfectly illustrates a curious
2:23
phenomenon, often termed the backwards law. It
2:27
suggests that the more desperately you pursue
2:29
a positive experience, be it happiness, wealth,
2:33
or even external validation like professional
2:35
recognition or attractiveness, the less satisfied
2:38
you ultimately become. The paradox lies in this.
2:41
The very act of intensely pursuing something
2:44
reinforces an underlying feeling of lacking it
2:46
in the first place. Oh, right. Think about it.
2:49
If you're constantly trying to be happy, it implies
2:51
you're not, doesn't it? And that very pursuit
2:54
creates a kind of void. For medical professionals,
2:57
this can manifest as an endless chase for the
2:59
perfect diagnosis, the ideal outcome for every
3:01
single patient, or the unblemished career path
3:04
free from any perceived failures or setbacks.
3:07
This relentless pursuit, ironically, can lead
3:09
to significant internal distress, a sense of
3:11
chronic inadequacy, and ultimately burnout because
3:14
the goal posts are always shifting. Like a treadmill
3:16
you can't get off. Exactly. It's like being on
3:19
a hedonic treadmill, where no matter how fast
3:21
you run, you never quite get anywhere new. Your
3:24
brain adapts to new levels of pleasure or achievement
3:27
very quickly, you see, prompting you to seek
3:30
the next high. This leads to a perpetual state
3:33
of desire rather than contentment. That's truly
3:37
fascinating, and it challenges so much of what
3:39
we're taught, doesn't it, about striving for
3:41
goals. So the desire for more positive experiences
3:45
is itself, in a way, a negative one. It's a bit
3:47
of a mind bender, isn't it? Could you elaborate
3:50
on this concept because it really does go against
3:52
a lot of conventional wisdom, especially in fields
3:54
where achievement is so highly valued? Certainly.
3:57
Consider the profound observation by the philosopher
3:59
Alan Watts who said something like, You will
4:02
never be happy if you continue to search for
4:04
what happiness consists of. You will never live
4:07
if you are looking for the meaning of life. This
4:10
suggests that constantly striving for an external
4:12
definition of happiness or success Well, it keeps
4:16
us from truly experiencing what's present. When
4:19
you're perpetually looking for happiness to arrive
4:21
from an external source, a promotion, a successful
4:25
procedure, a new car, you're by definition not
4:28
experiencing it now. You're just always waiting
4:30
for it. Exactly. It implies that a certain comfort
4:33
with what is, even when it's challenging or uncomfortable,
4:36
is actually a more direct route to genuine satisfaction
4:39
and a sense of well -being. It's about being
4:42
present with reality, with the struggles and
4:43
the triumphs, rather than always chasing an idealized
4:46
future state that remains perpetually out of
4:48
reach. For a clinician, this might mean finding
4:51
fulfillment in the nuanced, often imperfect reality
4:54
of patient care, rather than only in the miracle
4:56
cases or the textbook outcomes. And where does
4:59
this overwhelming societal pressure to be amazing,
5:02
to constantly perform at an exceptional level,
5:05
come from? Particularly for professionals who
5:08
often have exceptionally high standards for themselves,
5:10
like doctors who often feel they must embody
5:12
an almost superhuman level of competence and
5:15
composure, especially when life and death are
5:18
on the line. Well, our contemporary consumer
5:20
culture and the pervasive nature of social media
5:24
play a profoundly significant role. They really
5:26
do. They fostered what has been termed a feedback
5:29
loop from hell. We're constantly inundated with
5:33
images and narratives of others appearing to
5:35
live extraordinary lives, the perfect patient
5:37
interaction, the breakthrough research, the seamless
5:39
surgical procedure, the perpetually calm and
5:42
compassionate bedside manner. You know, the sort
5:44
of thing. Yes, those curated highlights. Precisely.
5:46
And this creates a deeply problematic and insidious
5:49
assumption that negative experiences like anxiety,
5:52
fear, guilt, or even simple frustration are somehow
5:55
not OK, or that they indicate a personal failing.
5:57
We start to feel bad for feeling bad. which is
6:00
an incredibly self -defeating and exhausting
6:01
cycle. This internal conflict, particularly for
6:05
those in roles demanding constant composure,
6:08
rapid decision -making, and profound resilience,
6:10
can lead to chronic stress, deep -seated anxiety,
6:13
and an almost existential unease. It's no coincidence,
6:17
I think, that stress -related health issues,
6:20
anxiety, disorders, and depression have seen
6:22
a significant rise, despite widespread material
6:25
comfort and unprecedented technological advancement.
6:27
The crisis, for many, becomes less about material
6:30
lack and more about a spiritual void, a profound
6:33
sense of not knowing what truly matters, when
6:36
everything appears available. When every possible
6:39
achievement seems within reach, yet none truly
6:42
satisfies or brings lasting contentment. It creates
6:45
a vacuum of meaning. It's almost like we've become
6:47
victims of our own success, in a way, with so
6:50
many opportunities and so much information that
6:52
we don't know what to truly invest our energy
6:54
in, leading to a kind of internal paralysis or
6:56
even a sense of being perpetually overwhelmed.
6:59
This is precisely where accepting the negative,
7:02
acknowledging that these feelings are normal,
7:04
becomes so crucial, isn't it? It means moving
7:06
beyond that destructive internal conflict you
7:08
described. Precisely. The acceptance of one's
7:12
negative experience is paradoxically a profoundly
7:15
positive experience when you're able to not give
7:18
a damn. about the inevitable pain and struggle
7:21
inherent in life, when you stop resisting it,
7:24
you become remarkably resilient. Now this isn't
7:27
about apathy or indifference. It's about strategically
7:29
choosing what truly matters to you and acknowledging
7:32
that nearly all worthwhile achievements, all
7:34
significant growth, and all genuine satisfaction
7:37
emerge from confronting and surmounting discomfort.
7:39
So leaning into the difficulty. In a way, yes.
7:42
Take the American poet and novelist Charles Pukowsky.
7:45
His epitaph simply read, don't try. This wasn't
7:49
an invitation to laziness, obviously, but a powerful
7:51
philosophical statement suggesting that his success
7:54
came not from striving to be a winner or conforming
7:56
to expectations, but from an unflinching honesty
7:59
about his own failures and limitations, simply
8:01
allowing himself to be who he was and write about
8:03
it. Interesting take. For medical professionals,
8:06
this could mean moving beyond the idealized self
8:08
-image of the infallible healer and embracing
8:10
the complexities and emotional toll of their
8:13
demanding work, the difficult conversations,
8:15
the ethical dilemmas, the inevitable human errors,
8:18
the profound losses. Recognizing that these very
8:21
challenges and difficult moments are an intrinsic
8:24
part of the growth process, not deviations from
8:26
it, is key. It's about finding strength in acknowledging
8:30
vulnerability, not hiding from it. So if trying
8:33
to avoid pain only causes more suffering, and
8:36
if we're to lean into discomfort, how do we actually
8:39
learn to embrace it? Especially when dealing
8:41
with the intense psychological and emotional
8:43
toll that professions like medicine can take.
8:45
We're often taught, aren't we, to compartmentalize
8:48
or suppress these feelings, to maintain a professional
8:50
facade, to appear strong for our patients and
8:52
colleagues. Well, pain, whether physical or psychological,
8:56
is fundamentally a crucial feedback mechanism.
8:59
It's a biological alarm system, really. It teaches
9:01
us what to pay attention to, what our limitations
9:03
are, and how to avoid making the same mistakes.
9:07
Neuroscience research has consistently shown
9:09
that our brains register little difference between
9:11
physical and psychological pain. Neuroimaging
9:14
studies, using fMRI, for example, demonstrate
9:17
activation in similar brain regions. The insula,
9:20
the anterior cingulate cortex for both physical
9:22
injury and deeply failed social exclusion or
9:25
emotional disguise. So it feels the same biologically?
9:28
Very similar pathways, yes. Just as the stub
9:31
toe teaches you to be more careful, the emotional
9:33
pain of a difficult outcome, a misdiagnosis,
9:36
or a personal failure in your practice can teach
9:38
invaluable lessons in resilience, adaptation,
9:41
and, frankly, humility. The real danger lies
9:43
in a society that increasingly coddles itself
9:45
from these inevitable discomforts, leading to
9:48
a profound disconnection from reality. When we
9:51
attempt to shield ourselves from all forms of
9:53
pain, we lose vital learning opportunities and
9:55
become rather fragile. And it's not just about
9:57
avoiding pain, is it? It's also about acknowledging
10:00
that problems are a constant and inherent part
10:03
of life woven into the fabric of our existence.
10:06
Even for highly successful individuals like leading
10:09
surgeons or pioneering researchers, it's not
10:11
about eliminating problems, but maybe changing
10:14
the kind of problems you have. Absolutely. Life
10:16
is an endless series of problems. The solution
10:19
to one merely creates the next. Now, this isn't
10:22
pessimism. It's a deeply rooted realism, I think.
10:25
Warren Buffett, for instance, he has money problems,
10:27
but there are arguably better ones, issues of
10:29
investment diversification or philanthropic strategy
10:32
perhaps, than say the survival challenges faced
10:34
by a homeless person. Different scale of problems.
10:36
Precisely. And this is a critical insight. Don't
10:40
hope for a life without problems, because such
10:42
a life is a fantasy, a delusion. Instead, hope
10:45
for a life full of good problems, those that
10:47
challenge you, force you to grow and align with
10:50
your chosen values. Denying problems, or worse,
10:54
adopting a victim mentality, only provides a
10:56
temporary high through delusion or blame leading
10:59
to long -term insecurity and emotional repression.
11:03
This is particularly salient in high pressure
11:05
fields like medicine where admitting to struggle,
11:08
acknowledging a systemic issue, or even a personal
11:10
mistake might be perceived as weakness. Which
11:12
can be incredibly damaging. It can. This can
11:15
lead professionals to deny or externalize issues
11:18
rather than confront them head -on, perpetuating
11:20
the very problems they seek to avoid, and eroding
11:22
trust within teams and with patients. This raises
11:25
an important question, then. If emotions are
11:27
simply signals, as you've described, providing
11:29
us with feedback, how do we prevent them from
11:31
dictating our actions? Especially the powerful
11:34
negative ones, which can be so overwhelming and
11:37
demand immediate reaction in a clinical setting.
11:39
That's a crucial point. Emotions evolved for
11:42
one specific purpose, to help us live and reproduce
11:46
better. Fundamentally, they are biological signals
11:49
nudging us towards beneficial change. Negative
11:53
emotions, for instance, are call to action if
11:55
you feel crappy. Whether it's frustration with
11:58
a colleague or anxiety about a procedure, it's
12:00
often because an issue is unaddressed or unresolved.
12:03
It's your internal system saying, pay attention.
12:05
A warning light. Exactly. Positive emotions,
12:08
on the other hand, are rewards for appropriate
12:11
action, reinforcing behaviors that serve us.
12:13
The critical point is to recognize that just
12:16
because something feels good doesn't necessarily
12:18
mean is good for you in the long run, and vice
12:20
versa. A difficult conversation might feel bad
12:23
but be incredibly necessary. We could question
12:26
our emotions rather than blindly trusting them,
12:29
especially in professional contexts where a detached
12:31
analysis, ethical considerations, and rational
12:34
decision -making are sometimes paramount. However,
12:37
it's equally important not to fall into the trap
12:38
of repressing negative emotions entirely, as
12:41
that denies us vital feedback needed for problem
12:43
solving and personal growth. Finding a balance.
12:46
It's about discerning the message. Understanding
12:49
the why behind the feeling, not silencing the
12:51
messenger. So it's not about being emotionless
12:54
or cultivating a stoic detachment in all situations,
12:57
but rather about understanding their purpose,
13:00
interpreting their signals, and then aligning
13:02
them with our deeper values, making them work
13:04
for us rather than against us. Precisely. It's
13:08
profoundly about choosing your struggle. Everyone
13:11
naturally desires happiness and an easy life,
13:14
free from friction. But real, lasting fulfillment,
13:18
profound meaning, and genuine growth don't come
13:20
from avoiding pain. They come from accepting
13:22
and actively engaging with negative experiences.
13:25
For example, aspiring to an amazing physique
13:27
isn't about enjoying every single minute in the
13:30
gym. In fact, much of it involves discomfort,
13:32
doesn't it? It's about appreciating the pain
13:34
and physical stress of the process. The burning
13:37
muscles, the sweat, the exhaustion, the discipline.
13:40
That's where the satisfaction lies. Similarly,
13:43
a successful medical career isn't just about
13:45
the rewarding cases, the successful surgeries,
13:48
or the accolades. It's also profoundly about
13:50
embracing the long, often unpredictable hours,
13:55
the complex ethical decisions that keep you awake
13:57
at night. Difficult conversations. Absolutely.
14:00
The emotional toll of those conversations, the
14:02
grief of losing a patient, and the inevitable
14:04
setbacks and human errors that occur. Who you
14:07
truly are, your character, your resilience, is
14:10
forged and defined by what you are willing to
14:12
struggle for. It's in those moments of pushing
14:15
through discomfort that true character is revealed
14:17
and built. And this leads us to the idea that
14:19
we're perhaps not as special as society often
14:21
tells us we are, which can be a particularly
14:23
tough pill to swallow in high -achieving fields
14:25
where exceptionalism is almost an assumed trait.
14:29
It's as if simply being good isn't good enough
14:31
anymore. The You Are Not Special notion. It is
14:35
a powerful, almost confrontational counterpoint
14:37
to a culture increasingly obsessed with exceptionalism.
14:41
The self -esteem movement, which gained traction
14:43
back in the 1970s, focused heavily on feeling
14:46
good about oneself regardless of actual achievement,
14:49
leading to practices like great inflation and
14:51
participation awards. Decades of data suggest
14:56
that merely feeling good about yourself without
14:58
a valid reason, without earned competence, fosters
15:01
a population full of what has been referred to
15:03
as Jimmy's. Individuals with delusional self
15:06
-confidence often all talk and no action, who
15:08
may live off the efforts of others or fail to
15:11
adapt to real -world challenges. Imagine a Jimmy.
15:14
in a hospital setting. Perhaps a resident who
15:17
constantly overstates their capabilities, avoids
15:19
difficult learning opportunities, or blames nurses
15:21
or other team members when things go wrong, rather
15:24
than taking ownership of their own areas for
15:26
growth. That sounds dangerous. It hinders genuine
15:29
progress, absolutely. True self -worth, in contrast,
15:33
isn't about how you feel about your positive
15:35
experiences. It's about how you feel about your
15:37
negative ones and your willingness to address
15:39
them honestly, to accept your flaws and work
15:41
on them. Entitlement, whether manifested as superiority
15:45
or victimization, is a destructive high that
15:52
prevents genuine improvement because it blinds
15:55
individuals to their actual problems and their
15:57
own capacity for change. This tyranny of exceptionalism
16:00
feels particularly acute in high -achieving professions
16:03
like medicine, where average is often synonymous
16:06
with failure, and there's immense pressure to
16:08
always be at the forefront, discovering the next
16:10
big thing, publishing groundbreaking research,
16:12
or performing the most complex procedures. Correct.
16:15
The constant flood of extraordinary information
16:18
via mass media, academic journals, professional
16:20
networks, it conditions us to believe that exceptionalism
16:23
is the norm. We see the groundbreaking research,
16:26
the heroic interventions, the perfect academic
16:29
records, the doctors who cure seemingly impossible
16:32
diseases. However, since most of life is, in
16:36
fact, an extraordinary and quite average, much
16:38
of clinical practice involves routine cases,
16:41
careful documentation and incremental progress.
16:44
This relentless exposure to exceptionalism leads
16:46
to widespread insecurity and a pervasive feeling
16:49
of not good enough. I can see that. This drives
16:52
people to compensate through various coping mechanisms,
16:55
often unhealthy ones, such as workaholism, obsessive
16:58
pursuit of status, or an inability to delegate.
17:01
For medical professionals, it can lead to a feeling
17:03
that unless they are at the absolute pinnacle
17:05
of their field, constantly innovating or achieving
17:08
breakthrough successes, they are somehow failures.
17:11
But true greatness, as the discussion suggests,
17:13
often comes from an obsession with improvement.
17:15
Stemming from an honest belief that one is not
17:18
already great, but could always be much better.
17:20
A growth mindset, essentially. Precisely. This
17:23
means accepting the bland and mundane truths
17:26
of life. That most of it will be boring, routine,
17:29
and not nit -worthy in a headline -grabbing way.
17:32
And that's perfectly fine. Actually, it's normal.
17:35
This acceptance lifts that immense self -imposed
17:37
pressure and paradoxically frees you to pursue
17:40
what truly matters, focusing on consistent incremental
17:43
progress rather than a mythical, unattainable
17:46
peak of perfection. It's a compelling argument
17:49
against the relentless pursuit of external validation,
17:51
isn't it? It suggests that the real, transformative
17:54
work happens internally, shifting our focus from
17:56
outer accolades to inner integrity. So if accepting
17:59
imperfection and embracing struggle are key to
18:01
a more fulfilling professional and personal life,
18:04
how do our values play into this? And how do
18:06
we even begin to identify what truly matters
18:08
to us, especially when we're so conditioned by
18:10
external measures of success and prestige? Ah
18:13
yes, values. This is where the concept of the
18:16
self -awareness onion comes into play. It's quite
18:19
a useful framework for introspection, I find.
18:22
It has multiple increasingly challenging layers.
18:25
The first layer is a basic understanding of our
18:27
emotions. Being able to identify what makes us
18:31
happy, sad, angry, anxious or hopeful. Just knowing
18:34
what you feel. Exactly. But even that isn't always
18:37
straightforward. We all have emotional blind
18:39
spots, often related to emotions we were taught
18:42
were inappropriate or undesirable during our
18:44
upbringing. For example, some might have been
18:46
told that doctors don't cry or you must always
18:49
be strong. It takes years of conscious practice
18:51
and effort to identify these suppressed emotions
18:53
and learn to express them appropriately. But
18:56
it's hugely important for psychological health.
18:59
OK, so that's layer one. What's next? The second,
19:01
deeper layer, involves asking why we feel these
19:04
emotions connecting them to our underlying understanding
19:07
of success or failure. Why do you feel that intense
19:10
frustration when a patient doesn't follow your
19:12
advice? Is it because you genuinely care for
19:14
their well -being? Or perhaps because you perceive
19:17
it as a failure of your own authority or skill?
19:19
Digging deeper into the why. Precisely. Why do
19:22
you feel lethargic and uninspired after a successful
19:25
procedure? Is it because you've become disconnected
19:28
from your initial purpose? This layer helps us
19:30
understand the root cause of our overwhelming
19:32
emotions, moving beyond surface level reactions.
19:35
But the crucial and often most uncomfortable
19:38
layer is the third, our personal values. A core
19:41
of the onion. Exactly. This involves asking,
19:44
why do I consider something a success or a failure
19:47
in the first place? By what standards do I measure
19:49
myself, my career, my relationships? Our values
19:53
fundamentally determine the nature of our problems
19:55
and thereby the quality of our lives. If your
19:57
value is external validation, your problems will
20:00
revolve around seeking approval. If it's compassion,
20:03
your problems will involve navigating suffering.
20:06
Many people avoid this deep self -questioning,
20:09
often blaming external factors for their dissatisfaction.
20:12
It's the hospital system, it's difficult patients,
20:14
it's the long hours. which prevents them from
20:16
addressing the true root causes of their issues,
20:19
which often lie in misaligned values. It's about
20:21
questioning the very metrics we use to measure
20:23
ourselves, then, rather than just the goals themselves.
20:27
That can be a radical shift in perspective for
20:30
professionals accustomed to clear, often externally
20:32
defined, objectives like passing exams, achieving
20:35
board certification, or securing grants. Precisely.
20:38
We see this contrast vividly in what's been termed
20:41
rock star problems. Take Dave Mustaine of Megadeth,
20:44
for instance. Despite immense success selling
20:47
millions of albums, touring globally, he reportedly
20:50
still considered himself a failure for decades.
20:53
Decades. But why? They were huge. Because his
20:56
metric was being more successful and popular
20:58
than Metallica, the band he was famously kicked
21:01
out of early on. His value was based entirely
21:03
on external comparison, leading to decades of
21:07
internal torture and resentment, despite his
21:09
considerable achievements. Wow. In stark contrast,
21:12
Pete Best, the original Beatles drummer, who
21:14
missed out on, well, arguably the biggest global
21:17
superstardom imaginable. He reportedly found
21:20
deep happiness by reprioritizing his values,
21:23
moving away from fame and glory towards a loving
21:26
family and a simple life, working for the civil
21:28
service. His internal metric of success, based
21:31
on what truly mattered to him, connection and
21:34
stability, allowed him to find fulfillment. Despite
21:37
missing out on the Beatles? Quite. This highlights
21:41
that some values, frankly, are more conducive
21:43
to healthy problems and a fulfilling life than
21:45
others. Some values just lead to more suffering.
21:47
That distinction is incredibly clear. And you
21:49
mentioned values that lead to poor problems.
21:52
Could you expand on what constitutes these values
21:54
that tend to generate unfulfilling, often unsolvable
21:57
problems? Certainly. Common values that can lead
22:00
to poor problems include prioritizing pleasure
22:02
above all else, seeking constant highs. Also,
22:05
chasing material success or status is the primary
22:07
goal. Always needing to be right is another big
22:10
one, and maintaining a facade of constant positivity
22:12
or superiority. Why are those so problematic?
22:15
Because these values create problems that are
22:17
often unsolvable and leave us feeling empty.
22:20
They're either externally dependent, relying
22:22
on others' opinions, or fleeting circumstances
22:25
impossible to achieve perfectly, or they require
22:28
us to deny reality. For example, if your self
22:31
-worth is based on always being right, you'll
22:33
struggle immensely to learn from mistakes, accept
22:36
feedback, or be open to new perspectives. That's
22:39
highly detrimental in any evolving field like
22:41
medicine, where new research constantly challenges
22:43
old assumptions and continuous learning is absolutely
22:46
paramount. You have to be willing to be wrong
22:48
sometimes. Absolutely. Similarly, denying negative
22:51
emotions by forcing positivity is a form of avoidance.
22:54
It prevents you from addressing underlying issues
22:57
that genuinely require your attention. Healthy
22:59
emotional expression, even of anger or frustration,
23:02
is crucial for problem -solving and psychological
23:04
well -being, as long as it aligns with broader
23:07
values like respect and nonviolence. It's about
23:09
expressing the emotion appropriately, not suppressing
23:12
it entirely until it manifests in unhealthy ways.
23:15
What, then, are healthier values that can lead
23:17
to more meaningful problems and genuine fulfillment?
23:20
What should we strive to cultivate? Healthy values
23:23
are typically achieved internally. They are immediate
23:26
controllable, and engage you directly with the
23:29
world as it is, rather than how you wish it were.
23:32
You don't need external circumstances to align
23:34
perfectly to enact them. Examples include things
23:36
like creativity, honesty, humility, curiosity,
23:40
perseverance, or compassion. Things you can practice
23:43
moment to moment. Exactly. These are values you
23:46
can embody and enact regardless of external circumstances,
23:49
day in and day out. When you choose better values,
23:52
you allocate your energy to things that genuinely
23:55
improve your well -being and generate happiness
23:57
as a side effect, not the primary pursuit. You're
24:00
not chasing happiness. You're living in a way
24:02
that produces it. This is the essence of self
24:05
-improvement, choosing better things to give
24:07
a damn about, leading to better, more solvable,
24:09
and ultimately more fulfilling problems, and
24:11
thereby a richer life. And this choice itself
24:14
is incredibly powerful, isn't it? It suggests
24:17
that even in seemingly dire, uncontrollable circumstances,
24:21
we retain a profound sense of agency over our
24:24
own experience. It is profoundly so, because
24:27
you are always choosing whether you realize it
24:29
or not. The distinction between a problem being
24:31
merely painful or genuinely powerful often lies
24:35
in whether we feel we chose it and are responsible
24:37
for our response to it. Consider William James,
24:40
often called the father of American psychology.
24:43
Despite a life plagued by severe health issues,
24:46
intense depression, and repeated professional
24:47
failures, he transformed his life. He did this
24:51
by dedicating one year to the radical experiment
24:53
of believing he was 100 % responsible for everything
24:56
that occurred to him, regardless of fault. Everything.
24:59
Even things outside his control. Yes. This radical
25:02
acceptance of responsibility, even for things
25:04
not objectively his fault, empowered him to change
25:06
his circumstances and ultimately shaped his profound
25:09
legacy. He found that by taking responsibility,
25:11
he gained power over his own life and choices
25:13
rather than remaining a passive victim of circumstances.
25:16
So it's not about fault, but about responsibility.
25:19
That's a crucial distinction, especially for
25:21
professionals who might carry immense burdens
25:24
of responsibility for patient outcomes, for team
25:26
dynamics, even when factors are beyond their
25:29
direct control. You might not be at fault for
25:31
a global pandemic, for example, but you are responsible
25:34
for your actions within it. Exactly. Fault is
25:37
past tense. It's about what happened. Responsibility
25:40
is present tense. It's about how you choose to
25:42
respond now. You might not be at fault for a
25:45
difficult situation like a complex medical case
25:47
with an unexpected turn or a patient's non -compliance
25:51
leading to a poor outcome, but you are always
25:54
responsible for how you choose to react to it,
25:56
how you see it, and what values you apply to
25:58
that moment. For example, in a challenging surgical
26:00
case, if an unexpected complication arises, you
26:04
might not be at fault for its occurrence, but
26:06
you are absolutely responsible for your immediate
26:08
response, your critical thinking, your communication
26:11
with the team, and your subsequent learning from
26:13
the experience. Owning your response. Yes. Malala
26:17
Yousafzai, shot by the Taliban for advocating
26:19
for education, exemplifies this on a grand scale.
26:22
She didn't choose the attack, obviously, but
26:25
she chose how to respond, ultimately turning
26:27
profound pain into a platform for global change.
26:31
Blaming others while a common human response
26:33
only perpetuates one's own misery and effectively
26:36
disempowers you. It's about taking ownership
26:38
of your emotional landscape and deciding on better
26:41
values to move forward, even when the circumstances
26:43
are not of your making. It's the profound recognition
26:46
that while we can't always choose what happens
26:49
to us, we always choose how we respond, and that
26:51
choice defines our agency and our character.
26:54
This leads beautifully to the idea of embracing
26:56
uncertainty, which can feel deeply counterintuitive,
26:59
almost professionally irresponsible perhaps,
27:01
especially in professions where precision, evidence
27:03
-based practice, and certainty are often prized
27:05
above all else, and where mistakes can have profoundly
27:08
significant, even life or death, consequences.
27:11
Indeed, certainty is often the enemy of growth.
27:14
It sounds paradoxical, but it often is. We are,
27:17
in essence, always wrong, just progressively
27:20
less wrong, as we learn and grow. Our understanding
27:24
evolves. Our brains are fundamentally meaning
27:26
machines, constantly trying to make sense of
27:28
experiences to form coherent narratives. In doing
27:31
so, we often unconsciously fabricate connections
27:33
or memories to maintain existing beliefs and
27:36
preserve a sense of certainty, even when that
27:38
certainty is, frankly, an illusion. Our brains
27:40
trick us. To some extent, yes. The phenomenon
27:43
of false memory syndrome, for instance, has powerfully
27:46
demonstrated how susceptible our beliefs and
27:48
memories are to our current values, desires,
27:51
and even suggestions from others. Therefore,
27:54
continuous self -scepticism and rigorous challenging
27:56
of our own beliefs and assumptions, even deeply
27:58
held clinical ones, is not merely beneficial.
28:01
It is the only logical path to true progress
28:03
and intellectual development. Clinging to the
28:06
illusion of certainty ultimately limits our capacity
28:09
to learn, to adapt to new evidence, and to innovate.
28:12
For a medical professional, this might mean accepting
28:15
the inherent uncertainty in a complex differential
28:17
diagnosis or being open to a new, perhaps less
28:21
conventional treatment pathway when standard
28:23
approaches fail, rather than clinging stubbornly
28:25
to familiar but ineffective methods. It's about
28:28
being open to being wrong, then, rather than
28:30
clinging to what we think we know, which, as
28:33
you say, can be a particularly challenging mindset
28:36
shift for medical professionals who are extensively
28:38
trained to diagnose with confidence and act decisively.
28:41
Precisely. The more you embrace being uncertain
28:44
and not knowing all the answers, the more comfortable
28:47
you paradoxically become with the inherent complexities
28:50
of your field and of life itself. Uncertainty
28:53
removes judgment of others and, crucially, of
28:56
ourselves. It fosters openness to new experiences
28:59
and continuous learning. It also directly confronts
29:03
what has been called Manson's Law of Avoidance,
29:06
which states that the more something threatens
29:08
your identity, the more you will avoid it. Interesting.
29:11
How does that work? Well, this is why people
29:13
can be afraid of success just as much as failure
29:15
both challenge who they believe themselves to
29:17
be. If your identity is the expert who never
29:20
makes a mistake, admitting an error or facing
29:22
a truly novel uncertain case can be terrifying.
29:25
it threatens that core identity. So you avoid
29:28
situations where you might fail or even succeed
29:30
in a way that changes you. Exactly. Letting go
29:32
of rigid self -definitions such as I'm not good
29:35
at patient communication or I'm not cut out for
29:37
the specialty or I'm not an academic is incredibly
29:40
liberating and allows for real growth. The idea
29:44
is to metaphorically kill yourself psychologically
29:47
to let go of arbitrary self -constructions that
29:50
trap you in fixed roles and limit your potential.
29:53
True self -knowledge in this sense isn't a fixed
29:55
destination, but a continuous journey of discovery,
29:59
an acceptance that you never truly know yourself
30:01
completely, and that's a profound and good thing
30:03
as it encourages continuous striving and evolution.
30:06
So if we're always choosing and we need to embrace
30:09
uncertainty and the possibility of being wrong,
30:12
how do we translate that into tangible action
30:14
when we feel stuck? overwhelmed, or perhaps when
30:17
facing a daunting new medical procedure, a complex
30:20
research project, or an ethical dilemma with
30:22
no clear answer. Ah, well that's where the do
30:25
-something principle comes in. It's a powerful
30:27
antidote to analysis paralysis, I find. We often
30:29
operate under the assumption that motivation
30:31
will precede action. We think we need to feel
30:33
inspired, then we become motivated, and then
30:36
we act. Right, I need to feel inspired, then
30:38
I'll act. That's the usual model. It is, but
30:40
the loop actually works powerfully in reverse
30:42
as well. Action leads to inspiration, which fuels
30:46
motivation and so on in an endless positive feedback
30:50
loop. If you lack the motivation for a significant
30:53
change, perhaps starting a new research project
30:55
that feels too big, tackling a complex clinical
30:58
challenge you've been putting off, or even just
31:00
writing a difficult referral for a patient, simply
31:03
start with the small, menial task related to
31:06
it. Don't wait for the lightning bolt of inspiration.
31:08
Exactly, don't wait. The act of doing something,
31:11
even imperfectly, even if it feels trivial, generates
31:14
momentum, creates small wins, and sparks insights
31:17
that you couldn't have achieved through mere
31:19
contemplation or worry. This approach makes potential
31:22
failure feel less significant because any action,
31:26
regardless of its immediate outcome, is considered
31:28
progress, a step forward in the process. So it's
31:31
about breaking the paralysis and just beginning,
31:33
even if you feel completely clueless or worried
31:36
about getting it wrong or unsure of the final
31:38
destination. It's about iterative progress, a
31:41
bit like a doctor doing daily rounds even on
31:43
difficult cases just keep moving forward. Exactly.
31:46
As the famous saying goes, do or do not, there
31:48
is no how without the doing. You figure out the
31:51
how by doing. You might feel that changing your
31:53
values and the things you truly care about will
31:55
feel disorienting, even like a failure, and it
31:58
may lead to friction or rejections from others
32:00
whose relationships were built on your old values.
32:02
That can happen. But these discomforts are inevitable,
32:06
a necessary side effect of genuine growth. As
32:09
part of the process, it's about recognizing that
32:11
not knowing what you're doing is entirely normal.
32:14
even when you're accomplished and highly experienced.
32:16
Life is about navigating uncertainty and acting
32:19
anyway. The fear of not knowing or of making
32:22
mistakes can be crippling. But the only way through
32:24
it is to take that first step. Even if it's a
32:27
crappy first step, like the novelist who committed
32:29
to writing 200 crappy words a day and ended up
32:32
writing 70 novels, the action itself sparks the
32:35
inspiration and motivation to continue. It's
32:37
the consistent, imperfect action that truly transforms
32:40
us. Shifting gears slightly, let's talk about
32:42
relationships. You've suggested that true freedom
32:45
and meaning actually come through commitment,
32:47
and that this requires the often difficult ability
32:50
to say no. How does this apply to our personal
32:53
and professional interactions, especially in
32:56
complex, team -based medical environments where
32:58
collaboration is vital, but so is protecting
33:01
your own well -being? Well, absolute freedom
33:03
by itself is often meaningless. If you have infinite
33:06
choices, none truly hold significance, do they?
33:10
True meaning and importance in life come through
33:12
the rejection of alternatives, a narrowing of
33:14
freedom, and a deep commitment to one path, one
33:17
belief, or one person. This might seem counterintuitive
33:20
in a culture that champions endless options and
33:22
constant flexibility. Keep your options open
33:25
is the mantra. Right, don't tie yourself down.
33:27
Exactly. But depth of experience, achievable
33:30
only through sustained commitment and focused
33:33
effort, yields profound rewards that breath alone
33:35
cannot. Consider the author's personal anecdote
33:38
of five years of extensive global travel. While
33:42
exhilarating, he noted many experiences ultimately
33:45
lacked lasting significance because they weren't
33:47
deeply invested in, just skimming the surface.
33:50
This applies directly to professional specialization,
33:53
to building long -term patient relationships
33:55
based on trust, or even to conducting consistent,
33:58
focused research over many years. The willingness
34:01
to say no to countless other attractive opportunities
34:03
to dedicate your finite time and energy is what
34:06
gives weight and meaning to the yes you give
34:08
to a chosen few. It allows you to achieve true
34:11
mastery and impact. And this idea of saying no
34:14
and setting clear boundaries is central to healthy
34:16
relationships, isn't it? Whether with colleagues,
34:18
patients, or even family, it's not just about
34:20
protecting your own time, but about fostering
34:22
genuine connection. Crucially so. Unhealthy relationships
34:26
are often built on two people trying to escape
34:29
their own problems by using each other, rather
34:31
than acknowledging and addressing their individual
34:33
issues with mutual support. The key difference
34:36
lies in clear, respectful boundaries and the
34:39
willingness to both reject requests when necessary
34:42
and to be rejected without resentment. That's
34:45
important too. Being okay with someone else saying
34:47
no to you? Yes. This means taking responsibility
34:50
for your own values and problems rather than
34:53
constantly molding your behavior to accommodate
34:54
others or taking on their issues as your own.
34:58
For medical professionals, this could mean setting
35:00
limits on work hours to prevent burnout, a very
35:03
real issue. or clearly communicating realistic
35:06
expectations to patients about treatment outcomes
35:08
or your availability, even if it might lead to
35:11
initial discomfort or perceived disappointment.
35:14
It's about fostering respect and self -reliance
35:16
in others, rather than creating co -dependency
35:19
or accumulating resentment through over -giving.
35:21
So a saver mentality, where you constantly try
35:24
to fix others' problems, whether they're patients,
35:26
colleagues, or even family members, isn't actually
35:28
helpful in the long run. It sounds like it can
35:30
actually be quite detrimental. No, it often creates
35:32
codependency and can ultimately disempower the
35:35
other person. Genuine love, support, and professional
35:39
collaboration involve helping someone solve their
35:42
own problems, equipping them, supporting them,
35:45
but not solving the problems for them. True growth
35:48
comes from wrestling with one's own challenges.
35:50
Right. A sacrifice is only truly valid if it's
35:53
voluntary and given without expectation of return,
35:57
not born of obligation, guilt, or manipulation.
36:00
Conflict, though uncomfortable and often avoided,
36:03
is not only normal but absolutely necessary for
36:06
building genuine trust and maintaining healthy
36:08
relationships. Conflict is necessary. That sounds
36:10
challenging. It is. But without open disagreement,
36:14
without the ability to frankly say no or express
36:16
a differing opinion respectfully, relationships
36:19
are built on manipulation, resentment, and misrepresentation.
36:22
They become superficial. Trust, the most vital
36:25
ingredient in any relationship, whether a patient
36:27
-doctor bond or within a multidisciplinary team,
36:30
is earned through honesty and a consistent track
36:33
record of aligning values with actions, especially
36:35
after a breach of trust has occurred. If someone's
36:38
highest priority is always to feel good or to
36:40
make others feel good without facing underlying
36:43
truths or difficult conversations, the relationship
36:46
ultimately suffers and lacks depth. Finally,
36:49
let's confront perhaps the most profound idea
36:51
we'll discuss today. the inevitability of death.
36:54
For those in medicine who confront life and death
36:57
daily, often holding it in their hands, how does
37:00
contemplating our own mortality shape our values
37:02
and purpose? It must be a uniquely intense experience
37:05
for medical professionals. It is intense, yes.
37:09
Humans uniquely conceptualize their own death,
37:11
unlike any other creature we know of, and this
37:14
leads to a deep pervasive death terror and existential
37:17
anxiety. This subtly or sometimes overtly, underlies
37:22
much of what we do and how we live. To compensate
37:25
for this terror, we construct immortality projects,
37:28
grand narratives about our lives, building legacies,
37:31
achieving greatness, contributing to something
37:33
larger than ourselves that will outlast us. In
37:37
a sense, yes. Our values are, in essence, these
37:40
immortality projects. They are the things we
37:42
choose to believe are more important than our
37:43
own fleeting existence. When these values fail,
37:46
or when we lose sight of them, death terror can
37:48
creep back to the forefront of our consciousness.
37:51
Ernest Becker, who wrote his seminal work, The
37:53
Denial of Death, literally on his deathbed, argued
37:55
that embracing the impermanence of existence
37:57
is the bitter antidote to our frivolous ambitions,
38:00
our sense of entitlement, and our endless distractions.
38:03
It forces us to confront what truly matters beyond
38:05
our fleeting individual existence. That's a powerful
38:07
perspective. And as someone who has deeply felt
38:10
the sting of loss, I can certainly attest to
38:12
how it fundamentally shifts your outlook. The
38:15
death of my friend Josh some years ago was profoundly
38:18
painful. Yet paradoxically, it cracked open my
38:21
world in a way nothing else had. It gave me permission
38:24
in a strange way to truly live, inspiring a deep
38:28
sense of responsibility, insatiable curiosity,
38:30
and a drive to work hard at what genuinely matters.
38:33
All subsequent struggles, even significant ones,
38:35
have felt lighter because they are measured against
38:37
that ultimate truth. So how does facing mortality
38:40
directly, for all of us, help us live better
38:42
and make more meaningful choices in our professional
38:45
and personal lives? Your experience resonates
38:47
deeply with a core message here. Confronting
38:50
death, truly peering into that darkness, forces
38:53
us to obliterate superficial values and ask the
38:56
truly important question, what are your legacy?
38:59
How will the world, or even just your small corner
39:01
of it, be different and better when you're gone?
39:04
What mark will you have made that transcends
39:06
your individual existence? Now, this isn't about
39:08
grand achievements for everyone, not about building
39:11
hospitals or discovering new cures for every
39:13
single person. That's not realistic or necessary.
39:16
It's more personal. Yes. It's about choosing
39:18
values that stretch beyond serving merely yourself.
39:21
Values that are simple, immediate, controllable,
39:24
and tolerant of the world's inherent chaos and
39:26
uncertainty. This is the root of true happiness.
39:29
A fleeting yet profound sense of being part of
39:32
something greater and more unknowable. The more
39:35
we peer into the darkness of our own mortality,
39:37
the brighter and clearer life's true priorities
39:39
become. Stripping away the trivial and focusing
39:41
our precious energy on what genuinely contributes
39:44
to our lives and the lives of others. And accepting
39:47
suffering as an inevitable, even valuable part
39:49
of the human experience. We've covered a remarkable
39:53
amount of ground today, haven't we? challenging
39:55
the very foundations of how we define success
39:58
and happiness, and offering a compelling new
40:00
lens through which to cope with the inevitable
40:03
struggles and imperfections of life. The core
40:05
idea, it seems, is that choosing what to give
40:08
a damn about, choosing your struggles wisely,
40:11
and accepting the discomfort that comes with
40:13
growth. Well, that's perhaps the most worthy
40:15
struggle of all. I think so. For those of you
40:18
navigating demanding professional landscapes,
40:20
particularly in medicine, the insights we've
40:22
discussed offer a powerful and practical framework.
40:26
A framework for cultivating genuine resilience,
40:28
building true self -worth that isn't dependent
40:31
on external validation, and finding a deeper
40:33
sense of purpose beyond conventional metrics.
40:36
It's about embracing imperfection, choosing your
40:38
battles wisely, and aligning your actions with
40:40
values that truly resonate with your deeper purpose,
40:43
leading to a more meaningful and impactful career
40:45
in life. It certainly gives you something profound
40:48
to think about, doesn't it? Remember, you are
40:51
already great. Not because of external achievements
40:53
or because you've avoided all struggle, but because
40:56
you continue to choose what to care about in
40:58
the face of endless confusion and inevitable
41:01
death. And that, in itself, is a beautiful and
41:04
courageous thing. If you've found value in today's
41:07
Deep Dive, please do consider rating and sharing
41:09
this with a colleague or friend who might benefit
41:11
from this conversation. Until next time, keep
41:14
digging deeper.