Ep 76 - Everything Except Susan: The Disappearance of Susan J. Smith

Talking Trash & Tacos · Sep 27, 2026 · 10m

CORRECTION: In this episode, we mistakenly said Richard Oehlers when we meant Sean Oehlers. The 2001 Toledo Blade marriage-license listing identifies Sean Oehlers and Bonnie Henry. We apologize for the error.On March 30, 2006, 41-year-old Susan J. Smith disappeared from Toledo, Ohio.She missed work that evening. Her purse, cell phone, makeup, cash and other belongings were still at home. About a week later, the blue Dodge Durango she had been driving was found abandoned on Brooke Park Drive—but Susan was nowhere to be found.More than 20 years later, her children are still waiting for…